Friends — doesn’t receiving a gift that millions of other people have leave a little something to be desired? The thought of giving that type of gift isn’t very appealing either. To cure our shopping malaise, here’s my list of the top 10 unique and rare items that you won’t find anywhere else:
|
1. Your Book Rebuilt by TYLERBENDER Send in your favorite retired book and get back an amazing decoy journal to stash in your library. It’s a great way to recycle old books, and keep nosey-rosys out of your business! $50. |
|
|
I’m not even a knitter, but supporting an independent fiber farm (and adorable sheep like this) has got to be really good for the karma. Personally, I’d take the yarn and make a lifelike sculpture of this sheep’s head. $140 per share in the CSA. (See the video Etsy did with MVKnits.) |
|
|
Feltidermy is taking the Etsy world by storm as a less-expensive and more-fun way of preserving the likenesses of pets that have unfortunately ‘eaten the big one.’ This seller will work with you to preserve the memory of a loved one’s recently deceased pet, but will be “announcing the cutoff date for Christmas custom creations soon.” Act now (or forever hold your peace!). This large size bunny is $120. |
|
|
4. Blue Baseball by LemonBall These unique handstitched baseballs are so old school it hurts, and are made in the ol’ US of A. Speaking from experience, they make great gifts for all the sports fans on your list (who are notoriously hard to shop for.) $24. |
|
![]() |
5. Brief jerky by mixedspecies In economically difficult times, gifts that can serve multiple functions are the best gifts. These briefs are not only unbelievably fashionable, but they’re also a great source of emergency protein. One size fits/feeds most. $139. |
|
For all the dirty birdies in our lives, this custom soap loaf* (where you choose your own scent, color, and exfoliant) is just what the doctor ordered. Literally. *Each loaf normally yields 15-17 3.5 oz bars. $45. |
|
|
7. Recycled Wine Bottle Glasses by SurfsideCreations Besides being an amazing display of craftsmanship and ingenius recycling, these wine bottle glasses would be much easier to drink out of than the hundreds of broken bottles that litter my apartment. $70. |
|
|
8. Commission a Pet Portrait by candiceart For the people on your list who would rather have a portrait made of their pet than get a portrait of you. $75. |
|
|
9. Custom Thumbprint Ring by chrisparry This seller will create a true-to-life portrait of your thumbprint onto the top of a silver ring, so that future generations will always remember how OOAK you are! $249. Note: Leaving this at a crime scene would be disastrous. |
|
|
10. Custom-made 3D Island by AdmiralSlade For the recluse in your life who would rather spend the holidays on his or her own island! This little model is meant for gamers, but I think it could work as an intriguing element for your home decor. $6. |
Good luck, friends. Get out there and “cut your own loaf.”









73 comments
Sign in to add your ownroundabout says:
Fun stuff! I know a few folks who would love the jerky undies.
3 years ago
dessertfirstdesigns says:
mmmm, that baseball looksvaguely like something my husband might actually like. Love the journals!
3 years ago
AZCreativeStudio says:
Great gift ideas! I love the Citroen 2CV! :)
3 years ago
ElysianFields says:
Great list. Can I add mine? Can't get these anywhere as I am the only one making them , lol. http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=17835467 I also donate a dollar from each sale to the Arbor Day Foundation.
3 years ago
expressyourself says:
Lovely list.
3 years ago
MeadowbelleMarket says:
Who doesn't like sweet little lambs! The cloudpeople diorama is creatively unique! I love these gifts -- filled with whimsy.
3 years ago
ME2Designs says:
Wonderful collection of ideas - and great theme!
3 years ago
WrenWillow says:
How eclectic! Love the lambs and the uhhhh beef jerky. I never thought as a vegetarian i'd say those words.
3 years ago
JustFeltHungry says:
I love the peppermint oil on canvas! And the cloudpeople...
3 years ago
beachhouseblues says:
Love the yarn!
3 years ago
movetheneedle says:
I love the thumbprint ring.
3 years ago
foudreblanche says:
I love the thumbprint ring too.
3 years ago
sweetshorn says:
Rad. Rad. Rad. You're the best.
3 years ago
SASessories says:
Lot's of unique finds on Etsy!!!
3 years ago
dogties says:
Excellent choices!!! We love not shopping at the mall... Handmade Rocks the World.
3 years ago
JetWhitePonytail says:
Ahh, the lure of non-massproduced goods! Creates a most memorable gift. Don't forget vintage as another way to treasure up the holidays!
3 years ago
InuInspirations says:
haha! love the feltidermy!
3 years ago
JoyandWhimsy says:
All very nice and that "Book Rebuilt" is very cool! Antique books also make great gifts so check my site this week b/c I'll be listing lots of vintage Out-of-Print books including Colorplate Bird Books, an antique Charles Dickens "Christmas Stories", a very early edition of JRR Tolkien, etc....I have a few up now but there'll be lots more!
3 years ago
ArtWhims says:
There are some nice items featured here... I like the idea of being able to cut my own soap! That sounds like fun... perhaps a tradition in the making!
3 years ago
BeadsInTheBelfry says:
ha ha! This is an awesome list. Thank goodness for uniqueness. Love 'em all but the island is my personal fave.
3 years ago
kachingdesign says:
Hooray handmade!
3 years ago
Yoola says:
go handmade :)
3 years ago
littleredbear says:
Wohoooo cheers to handmade!! owww very nice cloud diorama.
3 years ago
zwzzy says:
eeee that lambs face is priceless! loves!!
3 years ago
nateclarkknives says:
You can add my item to that list of unique gifts!!
3 years ago
chocolateandsteel says:
I don't think my husband would get very far with jerky knickers. We have two dogs:) Love it all, especially the ring by Chris Parry. Bravo!
3 years ago
lotusbaby says:
my husband needs new underwear and likes jerky. hmmmmm.
3 years ago
Studio618 says:
Recycled wine bottles - very cool and GREEN idea. Yay for all those creative ideas.
3 years ago
gretchenmist says:
that's so true – haven't seen any of these anywhere else! the ring is a great idea :)
3 years ago
camillaskye says:
What a great list! Thank you.
3 years ago
christinececelia says:
Fantastic picks! The recycled books, wine glasses... so unique- I love um! They are just too cool- really, too cool!
3 years ago
lesleyfunkyart says:
this is a great collection. Very unique items.
3 years ago
michelemaule says:
Yes! Handmade is the way to go.
3 years ago
kingfishercrafts says:
Bingo! Great list. Love the feltydermy.
3 years ago
BayMoonDesign says:
Great finds! I love the thumbprint ring. Buy handmade for the holidays!
3 years ago
TheCottageCheese says:
I always did want to own my own island! Great list. And a new flavor of edible undies for the meatatarian in your life!
3 years ago
PoshDots says:
very cool list!
3 years ago
nanouke says:
This is amazing! Great finds!
3 years ago
chetart says:
Really great stuff. Feltidermy is hilarious!
3 years ago
lemondropstudio says:
Great ideas! I love 'em all. The jerky undies, oh man! FUN LIST! Happy shopping everyone!
3 years ago
Cajajewelry says:
the thumb ring is so awsome!
3 years ago
bijougirldesigns says:
go handmade!
3 years ago
4TheSparrowsNest says:
Gifts you can't get at the mall...now THESE are the types of gifts that I love to both give and receive.
3 years ago
jodieflowers says:
Awesome Items! So many cool things on Etsy!
3 years ago
MichelleStudio says:
Love that ring.
3 years ago
nfall2rt says:
cute gift ideas!
3 years ago
kerrihale says:
awesome article!
3 years ago
JensJewellery says:
Love the thumbprint.. and the comment about leaving it at the scene of a crime.. LOL Jenni
3 years ago
wildstrawberry says:
love the yarn... very clever gifts
3 years ago
angie180281 says:
i am buying ALL my christmas gifts from ETSY! Go handmade!
3 years ago
graceB says:
love it!
3 years ago
CRSisters says:
Very unique!!!
3 years ago
bleedingheartblossom says:
That Brief Jerky is CRAZY!! What a cute idea with the Feltidermy. Also, GREAT deal on the cut your own loaf soap. I love handmade soap.
3 years ago
rebeccanovotny says:
AWESOME! Is anyone else having a hard time Christmas shoppin when there are so many beautiful things to buy yourself?
3 years ago
BluCille says:
The soap packaging looks so festive!
3 years ago
BabbidgePatch says:
fun collection ~ Etsy sellers are ** creative **
3 years ago
MYGHANDBAGS says:
An array of talent at Etsy. I appreciate the visions of everyone's crafts.
3 years ago
alankarshilpa says:
I loved your "Ten things you can't get in the mall", especially the custom made 3-D island. What a neat idea.
3 years ago
fragmentsbyedith says:
great list! all gifts are so original. love the thumbprint ring.
3 years ago
blainedesign says:
I bought the Lemon Ball handmade baseball as a gift for my nephew this Christmas, and I will vouch for it as a first rate, handsome, genuinely unique item. Sports couture.
3 years ago
rebeccascreations says:
The little red car stuffed is adorable. Great gift for the little ones.;) rebecca
3 years ago
modernfigurative says:
i love the thumbprint ring!
3 years ago
heroncovewoodcarving says:
some very cool gift ideas!!!!
3 years ago
beadboxsupply says:
Absolutely ADORE the peppermint!! Darling!!
3 years ago
kiwigemwraps says:
the custom thumb print ring is GORGEOUS!
3 years ago
bizarregalah says:
Fabulous list - I'm tickled with the feltidermy!
3 years ago
WhatsYourAnimal says:
That's what etsy is all about. Buying unique.
3 years ago
kalicat says:
Very nice ring Chris, It s abit like Baby jewllery with babies toes/fingers prints but taken a step further, it is great x Cat
3 years ago
2212jewelry says:
very beautiful!!! congrat!
3 years ago
BusyBeeBumbleBeads says:
Love the angora goats, way too sweet!!!
3 years ago
didio says:
The blue and yellow baseballs are great! What a great gift to give to some little boy(or big boy!)
3 years ago
FLASH1214 says:
Wow I love it all everyone is so talented I'm so happy I joined Etsy. CONGRADULATIONS TO ALL
2 years ago
ClassyPen says:
A stylish pen by Classypen is a great gift... You cannot find in a mall a pen of this quality. It will wow everyone around you.
2 years ago