No matter the weather, Food & Wine Associate Editor Kristin Donnelly lives for ice cream. She loves making her own, inspired by a recent F&W story on Ohio ice cream artisan Jeni Britton. But you don’t need an ice cream machine to throw an incredible sundae potluck party. Just set out a few of your favorite store-bought pints and ask each guest to bring a topping.
To add great style, look to Kristin’s favorite Etsy picks below.

Printed from a vintage block, TheAerialist’s retro-style invitations would set a sweetly old-fashioned tone for the party.
MrPS’s raspberry-sherbet-colored tea towel uncannily matches TheAerialist’s invitations and would be perfect for cleaning up ice cream drips.
I’d tie Judyscrafts‘s nostalgic tags around sundae cups or goodie bags, or use them as place cards.
You’d never guess that the wavy-edged plastic bowls from ddcreations were made by Tupperware (who knew the company was so mod?). Even kids can eat their sundaes in style with these unbreakable pieces.
Photograph by © Frances Janisch

Banana splits would be much more fun to eat out of BinspiredVintage’s plastic banana boats with matching spoons. The boats would also be great for setting out maraschino cherries and other fruit toppings.
Cookies or tuiles are terrific for topping sundaes or for making ice cream sandwiches. I’d arrange them on raedunn’s chunky clay plates, which have the words à la mode in the center.
I love old-fashioned ice cream soda shops with apothecary jars, like this French-labeled one from GardenAdornments. I’d set out one or two filled with ice cream cones or biscotti.
Photograph by © Francis Miller, LIFE Magazine, 1962

Resign’s resin spoons would be great for serving sundae toppings.
DodgeStationPottery’s wonderfully minimalist ridged white bowls could do double duty as holders for sundae toppings, like an addictive rice brittle crunch, or for scoops of ice cream.
I’d use the small vintage glass pitcher from ScottieinaCanoe for pouring fresh blueberry sauce so I could see its pretty color.
Photograph by © Frances Janisch
Special Subscription Deal for Etsy Friends:
Get 2 Years of Food & Wine for the Price of 1!
Food & Wine magazine brings readers delicious recipes, the hottest new chefs and restaurants, accessible wine guides, and much more in each issue. Click here.
For more fun summer entertaining ideas, go to foodandwine.com/entertaining. Check back here on the Etsy blog for more party planning posts — the editors at Food & Wine will be sharing more ideas, recipes, and their Etsy picks this summer.


92 comments
Sign in to add your ownParadiseBodyShop says:
I'm a self proclaimed ice cream lover - this is making me crave some!
2 years ago
beautifulbridget says:
yummy!!
2 years ago
CarryTheWord says:
I'm drooling!
2 years ago
UglyBaby says:
With the record breaking heat in Seattle yesterday -- I'll I've been able to think about is ice cream. This blog post is not helping!
2 years ago
BInspiredVintage says:
What great finds! How fitting that one of my vintage finds was featured in a piece about ice cream, since I'm totally addicted to the sweet goodness!!! Thanks so much!
2 years ago
VixVintage says:
I'm drooling too!
2 years ago
LaLah says:
the plastic banana boats are adorable!
2 years ago
bobnstitch says:
yummy now I want ice cream
2 years ago
MouseTrapVintage says:
Oh man, I will be doing this this weekend for sure! LOVE this idea!!!
2 years ago
DalenaVintage says:
I love this article! Delicious photos...wish I would have read this for the tips prior to my ice cream social earlier this month!
2 years ago
burntmill says:
yum ice cream! not helping my diet all I can think about is ice cream now :P
2 years ago
mirthmarket says:
This article was delicious! Now I'm craving some Jeni's Ice Cream!
2 years ago
mycountrycottagesign says:
Love all the Ice cream dishes and items. Such a fun way to eat Ice Cream!!!
2 years ago
paedrin says:
sweet couture
2 years ago
SewnNatural says:
who can't smile and feel "in the moment" when eating (or, second best, reading about) ice cream? Thanks :)
2 years ago
dbabcock says:
Mmmmm. Make my fresh peach ice cream!
2 years ago
odiliafu says:
Yummy!! I love green tea ice cream in summer; rocky road in winter.
2 years ago
livingstonandporter says:
LOVE RAE DUNN and so happy she is here. So many sweet picks... :-)
2 years ago
sandali says:
WOW -- I LOVE all the flavors of ice-cream ... every single one is to die for, especially chocolate -- it's priceless ;) Great article with fun featured items -- HOERA for ice-cream -- Trigger Happy Days ;)
2 years ago
kidacollective says:
Ooh, yum. I adore vintage sundae sets - I think mine was the first kitchenware I ever bought (can you tell where my priorities lie?).
2 years ago
modhmary says:
I love, you love, we all love (except maybe the lactose intolerant, bless those poor folks) ICE CREAM!! Ginger ice cream is especially lovely. Vintage bowls pictured are very tempting...
2 years ago
cutiepiecompany says:
Yum!!
2 years ago
ClickityClack says:
I have a collection of handcrank ice cream makers from a little 1 pint one to a 6 quart one....about 7 in all. My sister has the old family handcrank that will churn out a whopping 10 quarts at a time! We had a neighbor hood ice cream party using 3 of my larger machines. Each had a different kind of ice cream and if you wanted to eat some, you had to take a turn at cranking! Here is one of my favorites called Six Threes (makes 4 quarts) 3 cups of heavy cream 3 cups of milk 3 cups of sugar Add to churn and crank until it starts to thicken. Add the juice of: 3 oranges 3 lemons and 3 mashed bananas Crank until done. Wonderful citrus flavor on a hot day!!
2 years ago
klacustomcreations says:
what a cool feature, love ice cream and these are some delicious finds!
2 years ago
worksofwhimsy says:
Great idea. Time for an ice cream break!
2 years ago
LisaFerinDesigns says:
I'm drooling, and hungry! Love those banana split dishes!!
2 years ago
TheNightjar says:
these are great! love the spoons and the ala mode dish!
2 years ago
stubborndog says:
I love all of this... and icecream...
2 years ago
TheCottageCheese says:
Yum Yum Yum. My husband can down a pint of Chunky Monkey in 10 minutes flat. No joking. He has conditioned himself not to get the "brain freeze". ;)
2 years ago
kharmany says:
I just found this: http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?ref=vl_other_2&listing_id=26175211 from a pretty gifted artist.
2 years ago
treeforyou says:
My parents own a restaurant and they make the best ice cream ever :) Great post, love the pics!!
2 years ago
nhubui says:
look delicious :D
2 years ago
misscourageous says:
great finds, but disappointed at the lack of mention of wonderful toppings available here on etsy... backyardbakery.etsy.com comes to mind (super yummy!)
2 years ago
paramountvintage says:
so many special treasures for a special party!
2 years ago
MentaEra says:
CC thanks for the recipe! :P
2 years ago
beachhouseblues says:
Wonderful!!
2 years ago
belovedbaglady says:
Yum!!! Check out my vintage pink glass bowls...lovely with ice cream : )
2 years ago
thebestvintage says:
Makes me want a dish of coconut chip right now!!
2 years ago
Jrisco says:
i have been making my own ice cream all summer....it is super easy - 1 cup milk, 1 cup of sugar blend together with a wire wisk until sugar is dissloved, add 2 cups heavy cream and 1-2 tea. vanilla - stir it up and put into any machine. Add 1/2 cup chopped dark chocolate the last 10 minutes of machine time. My machine takes about 25 minutes to make the most delicious ice cream! :) enjoy!
2 years ago
mgilinfo says:
Wow... party time... :)
2 years ago
IcingOnTheCupcake says:
Fun! Yummy!
2 years ago
LabyrinthLeather says:
I gained five pounds just by reading this article =:)
2 years ago
jewelrybyjackie says:
Mmmmmm. Home-made ice cream is just the best! Looks delicious!
2 years ago
aBreathofFrenchair says:
Yummy!
2 years ago
pulpsushi says:
I so want some ice cream now!!
2 years ago
HibouCards says:
Ok now I want ice cream! Oh and I love those ice cream cone cups!
2 years ago
Vanessa says:
best combo in my opinion: mango and hazelnut. who knew?
2 years ago
truLuxe says:
Does this mean we're going to see handmade ice cream sold on Etsy??? : P
2 years ago
That70sShoppe says:
Ice cream is one of my favorite treats!
2 years ago
patspottery says:
Now you went and did it!! It's off to the fridge for some ice cream for me:>)
2 years ago
mullishmuse says:
yep, "ice cream machine" are the keywords for summer 2009. bought an electric one on fourth of july for sale and have made it a ton of ways, lot of folks i know have too. my mango caramel, a personal favorite. :) seriously, this was a total hip piece; love the banana serving dishes! i love the classic icecream themed party. i love ice cream!
2 years ago
steinschmuckdesign says:
Yummie yummie... lovely choices!
2 years ago
tinyspace says:
makes me hungry
2 years ago
spacejam says:
i want ice cream!!1 NOW!!! lol
2 years ago
evihan says:
sooooooo yummmyyyy
2 years ago
jenniferlynnstudio says:
Who doesn't like ice cream?..I even named one of my necklace's...guilty pleasures..chocolate mint! Love those ridged bowls!
2 years ago
zeropumpkin says:
oh i almost have ice cream once a week :P
2 years ago
ovgilliesdesigns says:
Mmmmmmmm the yummiest article! ....love digging into ice cream, and then all those toppings.....ok, off to get some!
2 years ago
JamieAvery2 says:
I LOVE Jeni's Ice Cream!!!!! Delicious and environmentally friendly! PS. you can buy it online. =)
2 years ago
BlackStar says:
We have two ice cream makers and use them all the time. Did you know that July is 'National Ice Cream Month'? Last day to get out and celebrate! :)
2 years ago
LoveAppleBoutique says:
Great post, yummy
2 years ago
Tina669 says:
look delicious :D
2 years ago
MyJunkyTrunk says:
MMMMMMM! Really yummy pics and items!!!
2 years ago
designfabulous says:
yum!!
2 years ago
SimpleTraditions says:
that sounds so good!!!! My son has been asking for an ice cream party.
2 years ago
babook says:
Soooooo lovely the ice cream Tag : )
2 years ago
EarthenTreasures says:
Homemade vanilla ice cream is the best!
2 years ago
shopgoodgrace says:
sooooo much fun!!!
2 years ago
girltuesdayjewelry says:
That top photo of the ice cream did me in! Looks so delicious!
2 years ago
mykonos says:
I love ice-cream!!
2 years ago
abotslife says:
Can i leave work early please- I have a sudden urge to go home and make ice cream. I'll share...
2 years ago
bugbitesplayfood says:
Wow, pass me the banana split please! Homemade ice cream is the best!
2 years ago
TheQuietOwl says:
Yummy!!! Wonderful items for an ice cream party!!!
2 years ago
mythunderstood says:
Wonderful story and theme!
2 years ago
tinycharm says:
mmm so delicious
2 years ago
hyvamax6 says:
Wonderful selections! I love abstract art,too. I am glad you wrote an article about it! http://www.antlala.com/ sincerely good oil painting art! great artist!
2 years ago
AzitasSurprises says:
i love the banana boat set. wonderful theme!
2 years ago
brownbelly says:
such cute collection!
2 years ago
PipocaHandmade says:
Great idea and picks for a summer party! Yum!
2 years ago
amandaatkins says:
I've always wanted to have an ice cream party!
2 years ago
RubberStampPress says:
Ice cream?! Yes, please.
2 years ago
artwithallie says:
Love it! Here at artwithallie's studio ice cream is essential... ...even in the middle of winter here in Australia!
2 years ago
stuffbykate says:
mmmmmmmm i want ice cream.
2 years ago
bijouxdellostregatto says:
Yummy!!! Very nice finds!
2 years ago
poppyswickedgarden says:
OOOOH this makes me hungry:)
2 years ago
OwlandMouse says:
What an adorable idea!!!
2 years ago
riorita says:
My cat and me would like to sample some!
2 years ago
1AEON says:
oh.. don't even get me started!
2 years ago
junkyjunk says:
Amazing! Nothing says summer like ice cream!
2 years ago
capitalcitycrafts says:
great story! pass me the chocolate chip please!
2 years ago
BizzieLizzie says:
Oh, yeah - ice cream party?? Don't start without me! OR, at least save a bit of strawberry in one of those awesome vintage waffle cone cups! That'll work! Love your choices!
2 years ago
Pool Tour says:
Have you considered using glass straws? They're super classy and toxin free. I've seen a few brands out there. my favorite is simply straws, i love the travel case each straw comes with http://bit.ly/simplystraws
45 days ago