We asked our readers to nominate their favorite candy-themed items, and now, my sweet-toothed friends, it’s up to you to pick a winner!
Remember when you and your siblings would come home after trick-or-treating? I want to know what candy you’d swap and what you’d swap for. Post in the comments below! Nom nom nom!
On Monday we’ll announce the winner of this vote, which, along with some of the top picks, will be featured in the Members’ Choice Gift Guide and here on the Etsy blog. Show your favorite sellers some love and get out the vote!
178 comments
Sign in to add your ownlovelygifts says:
Oh my goodness! What great treats!
2 years ago
SimpleJoysPaperie says:
Oh my.... such temptations this early in the morning!
2 years ago
vivikas says:
Voted and OH MY... sweet stuff!
2 years ago
IcingOnTheCupcake says:
I want it ALL!!! YUM!
2 years ago
sewhome says:
yum!!
2 years ago
sewhome says:
I'd swap Jaw Breakers (but who really likes those so its a hard trade) for gummy bears !!
2 years ago
meredithfenwick says:
yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
2 years ago
breadandroses2 says:
Lost my pure sugar sweet tooth a long time ago, thankfully, but it's a treat to look at so many fine picks! Voted.
2 years ago
thebestvintage says:
Makes me me want a chocolate!!
2 years ago
zombuki says:
I always swapped for those peanut butter toffee things no one likes ;3
2 years ago
DjinnGlass says:
I adore that cotton candy - he's too cute!
2 years ago
VintageEye says:
love the squirrel nut candy dish!
2 years ago
beautifulbridget says:
Love that Twisted Candy Cowl!!
2 years ago
zizzybob says:
OMG, picking just one is too hard.
2 years ago
Radness says:
fake candy vs real candy?! i dunno they all look so yummy!
2 years ago
KattyKinns says:
Oh wow coconut ice, I haven't had that in years! Going to have to treat myself to it one weekend :D
2 years ago
blinkonmynose says:
Yum! I'll take the coconut ice!
2 years ago
Aquanetta says:
asking the wrong girl, cuz i love sweets. cant they all win?! :)
2 years ago
Aquanetta says:
WHATS WITH THE LETRON IMPORT/EXPORT SPAM POST 3 up?!!! That's not cool, mr/ms "gfhdfh" . NBA Jersys? Timberlands?
2 years ago
AlchemicMuse says:
Thank you for including Candy Apple Sugar Polish along with all of these delectable items! Good luck to all! :)
2 years ago
RageHaus says:
I'm in love with that cotton candy!
2 years ago
michaelangela says:
Love the fused glass dish and the Romantic dress!
2 years ago
craftpile says:
Ok, we would have pillow cases full. My sister and I would dump it out on the floor and kinda section in piles wich ones we could trade from. The good stuff was in the safe pile. I remember wanting to get rid of my tootsie rolls, candy corns or cheapy suckers...lol. Chocolate was always a score. xoxo p.s. Love your selection!
2 years ago
sweetsmilesbaby says:
anything for butterscotch candies. yummy. No cavities holiday candies dress: http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?ref=vl_other_1&listing_id=33220135
2 years ago
LoreleisAtelier says:
the orange creme truffles most assuredly! http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=33126959&ref=em
2 years ago
poppyswickedgarden says:
Yummy!! I'm off to vote!
2 years ago
craftpile says:
Oh...if I had a chocolate stash, I would trade a snickers for some nerds :)
2 years ago
4TheSparrowsNest says:
This will be so fun!!! I'm sure I'll be wanting to binge on sugary things all day now; thanks a lot guys! ;-)
2 years ago
missindie says:
Thank you so much for putting my "Twisted Candy Cowl" in the Voter! Good luck to everyone! xo.
2 years ago
abacusbeadcreations says:
Ooooo, it was so hard to pick just one favorite!! Lots of goodies!
2 years ago
JulieWebb says:
Mmmm, candy! :)
2 years ago
girltuesdayjewelry says:
Y*U*M*!!!!
2 years ago
FrillyButts says:
Done! Now, if you'll excuse me, I have to go eat my candy necklace for breakfast.
2 years ago
KittyCityCreations says:
I'd swap Smarties with anything chocolate! And I'd usually end up still having some candy left over months later! I would hide my stash in my closet so my big bro wouldn't steal it. :-)
2 years ago
RubberStampPress says:
Love candy!
2 years ago
Iammie says:
Thank you so much for including my item in the voter! I'm so excited! ********************************************************* PLEASE VOTE FOR MY "77 Iron Atomic Ball Ornament" THANK YOU all. http://www.etsy.com/voter_list.php?ref=voter&room_id=76 ********************************************************* I also take custom order too. :D
2 years ago
worksofwhimsy says:
What a fun surprise to see my candy corn bean bags in the vote! They're all "sweet" selections.
2 years ago
KBShimmer says:
Yeah, thanks for including my candy corn bath bomb!
2 years ago
fantasybeader says:
I love seeing my bubble gum machine earrings in the voter :-) Thank you :-) tytyty. Wow I have about 6 favorites there.
2 years ago
bylynnkrestel says:
oh yum!! now i'm really hungry!!
2 years ago
mrswoowoo says:
yum!
2 years ago
upzndowns says:
Wow... I can almost taste some of these! We would swap anything with each other, and then steal it back plus interest at every chance until it was all gone. Twizzlers and KitKats were always fought over.
2 years ago
candythomasgourdart says:
Thanks Vanessa,I won't get any work done today because I'll be too busy eating chocolate!!!
2 years ago
candythomasgourdart says:
Thanks Vanessa-I won't get any work done today because I'll be too busy eating chocolate!!!!!!!!!
2 years ago
cinderellascache says:
What a delicious idea Vanessa. I'm going to be loving the Chocolates.
2 years ago
aromafields says:
The coconut ice looks fabulous!
2 years ago
BizzieLizzie says:
BLISS - Each and every single one of 'em! Voted! Even more bliss over there!!
2 years ago
Morado says:
Just voted! http://twitter.com/MoradoShop http://www.facebook.com/MoradoShop
2 years ago
ilovehearts says:
I love all things sweet... x
2 years ago
ThisCharmingCandy says:
That bubblegum and lollipops picture is beautiful!
2 years ago
sleepyking says:
I love the cotton candy plushies!
2 years ago
BlackStar says:
Just voted. That candy looks so good!
2 years ago
Waterrose says:
Thanks for including my Snow Candy Wrist cuff! Good luck to everyone!
2 years ago
VixVintage says:
yummy!
2 years ago
OrangeTwist says:
Delish! So excited to have my chocolate kisses card included. Thanks so much to theferngate for nominating me! I love the candy corn plush!
2 years ago
msmithlewis says:
fun!!!!
2 years ago
ArtisticIntentions says:
Bright yummy colors!! Fun!
2 years ago
appletreejewelry says:
they all look delishe!
2 years ago
BlueTerracotta says:
I used to try to get all my sister's Mary Jane candies (do they still make those?) and of course pixie stix, but she liked those too! My absolute favorite was and still is Three Musketeers.
2 years ago
paramountvintage says:
i like the pink cotton candy dress, but i'm partial to clothes ;)
2 years ago
seababejewelry says:
The sweets look so sweet! But the spam is unsavory!
2 years ago
soule says:
Everything is so wonderful! Thank you Etsy for choosing my cloud candy bowls in the voter! Please vote everyone!!! http://www.etsy.com/voter_list.php?ref=voter&room_id=76
2 years ago
HibouCards says:
Scrumptious Delight's Cotton Candies are the best!!!!!!! Go Scrumptious :)
2 years ago
JustForTheShellOfIt says:
love the yummy candy theme...hate all the spam comments this draws...go somewhere else spammers!!
2 years ago
luvnstitches says:
Oh yes! I love Caramels!
2 years ago
PunkUpBettie says:
They all look good enough to eat! Yummy...
2 years ago
Feuillantine says:
Super les Caramels ! j'adore !!!!
2 years ago
wristielove says:
i'm going to say the polaroid greeting card....so cute! thx vanessa
2 years ago
woollyduck says:
I'd choose the orange cream truffles, although I hope the box doesn't really include a half-eaten one!!
2 years ago
walkthetalk says:
GREAT SELECTIONS!!! Love them all but, Waterrose's Candy Cuff braclet is beautiful!!!
2 years ago
BabbidgePatch says:
voted ~ yummy choices! I'll trade you all my twizzlers for anything chocolate!
2 years ago
miaMallows says:
they all look delish! It was hard to vote! :)
2 years ago
photographicamy says:
This is a challenging one to vote on, they all are so wonderful!
2 years ago
RedFenyx says:
♥ ♥ ♥ What lovely collection! ♥ ♥ ♥ I'm in too! First time in the voter! SO happy! =^________^=
2 years ago
DalkullanJewelry says:
Hi Vanessa! When I was a kid I would swap anything without chocolate for anything with chocolate. I still feel the same way about it. Definitely those mini assorted chocolate bars, Mr. Goodbar, Hershey Bars, any chocolately goodness would get my attention. How about you?
2 years ago
felicitycrew says:
Sugar - exactly what I need right now :)
2 years ago
shesbattydesigns says:
mmmm sugar!
2 years ago
Janalovablehandknits says:
Voted and OH YES.......... I love sweet stuff!
2 years ago
mytangerinedream says:
yummy sweets!
2 years ago
sewlola says:
this looks yummy! i am off to vote! :)
2 years ago
tashascreations says:
Very yummy article, I love cotton candy :D
2 years ago
eclipse says:
gfhdfh rghtfgi8l nagai fdghfhr tdhvnjmu Spam-flavored candy is YUCK!
2 years ago
HandiworksbyJanice says:
Great selections of great artisians! Good job! Off to vote!
2 years ago
LondonParticulars says:
Mmmm...pink goth...love that cotton candy dress!
2 years ago
TeaWithIris says:
...eating a kitkat as i revel at this collection of sweet items!
2 years ago
bijouxdellostregatto says:
I'm happy!!!! My Yummy parure is here and I'm in the voter for the first time!!!
2 years ago
coolstuffforsale says:
They all look fun and yummy!
2 years ago
WickedDarling says:
OMG! I am in heaven!!!!!! :)
2 years ago
NovaScotiaBeachGlass says:
Wow , what a hard choice to make. They all looked yum. I love the colors.
2 years ago
mazedasastoat says:
Love the candy floss, although most of you probably call it cotton candy! It's always been my favourite thing about fun fairs!
2 years ago
cassidycay says:
I voted! YAY CANDY!
2 years ago
unatuna says:
I LOVE the cotton candy!!!!!! I want one!
2 years ago
birdie1 says:
I've never seen cotton candy look so cute!
2 years ago
trudiedavies says:
How beuatiful - I voted for the candy earrings in a glass bottle!!
2 years ago
pancakeandlulu says:
yum yum! I voted for the candy handspun, of course!
2 years ago
artwithallie says:
Yep, this post is what I'm into and it made me vote! Candy (or lollies here in 'Down Under' Australia) is an essential item in my studio! My biggest problem is trying to keep my kids (and my sister who we call the 'The Sugar Hoover' from eating all the good ones. Off to lighten my stash!!
2 years ago
lisaroy says:
mmmmm candy - my favorite food group!
2 years ago
Quiltville says:
yummy!!
2 years ago
zebracakes says:
I love faux candy jewelry!!! It's just soooooo much fun!
2 years ago
baboom says:
oh, so delicious!
2 years ago
BlueGremlin says:
lets see since i was an only child i didnt have to share ANY candy with anybody.....but i did have to keep an eye out for dad....i always knew the ones he said were yucky were the really good ones cause then he would swipe them! i live on sugar&love the article!
2 years ago
Vintage50sEyewear says:
I'm so hungry now!
2 years ago
YellowViolet says:
Wow that was tough to narrow it down to just one but I did. Love these contests! I never liked malted milk balls -still don't. My all time favorite is black licorice but no one gives that out for Halloween so I'd trade for Three Musketeers or Milky Ways.
2 years ago
ToScarboroughFair says:
Voted! Yummy!
2 years ago
wickedchilddesigns says:
what a yummy conconction we have here - just in time for trick or treating ! love the strat designs necklace :D and that squirrel is so cute ! xo
2 years ago
lealerjcreates says:
Can I have one of each?
2 years ago
BuckleUp says:
oooh, thanks for including my orange marmalade rainbow sprinkles belt buckle!
2 years ago
BuckleUp says:
looks like I'm in great company! :)
2 years ago
Vanessa says:
CHOCOLATE! I would trade especially mint for anything chocolate.
2 years ago
theaxx says:
one cotton candy would give me a crafty high!! those pink guys are just so cute... as for the sweet tooth... oh dear I embarrasingly could eat it all... thea. xx (www.forthevisionaries.tumblr.com)
2 years ago
ScribbleShop says:
HEHEHE...
2 years ago
GennaMcQuilkin says:
Espresso and Chocolate = YUM! I would have kept those in my plastic pumpkin bucket for sure! Least favorite treats = licorice, those were the first to go!
2 years ago
juazzi says:
push-push
2 years ago
baublestore says:
Love the candy sprinkle belt
2 years ago
LilaJo says:
I love the candy goodies!!!!! Holidays are uh coming perfect time :))
2 years ago
pandawithcookie says:
Candy! Thanks for featuring my candy corn pirate!
2 years ago
SweetVConfections says:
Thank you for featuring my orange cream truffles! I would've swapped pretty much anything for chocolate, especially pb cups.
2 years ago
foundling says:
I couldn't help myself--I've got a 1/2 lb. of BlissCandies sea salt caramels on the way to me!!!
2 years ago
KnockKnocking says:
I can pretty much see myself eating my way through every single choice on there. What fun!
2 years ago
reallybadkitty says:
I definitely have a sweet tooth and everything here is so great! Thanks for including my bouquet in this article.
2 years ago
theferngate says:
Yay OrangeTwist!! So excited your chocolate kisses card was included in the vote!! So fun!
2 years ago
vilte says:
love everything what is chocolate :)
2 years ago
SugarPink says:
AWESOME! too bad my WONKA GLOVES weren't part of this : (....hahahaha, I'm such a dork! but everyone here is AMAZING!!!!loved it
2 years ago
DucksInARowBoutique says:
These are all so fantastic! Love this!
2 years ago
RenatheSchneider says:
I voted and I love sweets : )
2 years ago
HotFudge says:
I voted - at least it's one way of not putting on weight!
2 years ago
craftedbylindy says:
Thanks so much for featuring my Sweet Stuff Polaroid Greeting Card! I love it all and yup, I would have switched anything for chocolate. Love the chocolate!
2 years ago
RubyStudios says:
Mmmmmm.....breakfast.....
2 years ago
krispybanana says:
I love the FallingStarLane necklace! Juicy!
2 years ago
FallingStarLane says:
I love this category, and i love sweets!! So cool to see my necklace on this page! :)
2 years ago
Brissonte says:
My sweet tooth knows no bounds. Even like my bath gel to smell like sweets. The coconut ice is my pick!!!
2 years ago
ReclaimedObjects says:
Trick or Treat! When tricksters pick up the Butterfinger they are surprised to see their reflection in my mirror. http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=30018769
2 years ago
bbrunophotography says:
You asked what's our favorite way to discover Etsy finds? I love Pounce because I always find a nice surprise waiting there. Second in line is Treasuries.
2 years ago
glasscircus says:
I Love Candy!! Thank you for featuring my fused glass candy dish!
2 years ago
cardinalhouse says:
Seriously, there has been a LOT of spamming on Etsy lately...... So I was addicted to Sweet Tarts. F a n a t i c! I coudln't stand candy corn (I know-I'm so weird, right)...but I l-o-v-e the plush candy corn with patch above! -Kat.
2 years ago
VellumCreations says:
Great sweet colletion!
2 years ago
VelveteenHabbit says:
OMG I just voted for the chocolate truffle looking art, because there is only ONE candy that I eat enough of to get a true SUGAR BUZZ-always forever CHOCOLATE!!! Cheryl at VelveteenHabbit@etsy.com
2 years ago
alittlecrazywithwax says:
Sugar oh my looks great
2 years ago
bananamiranda says:
One of lifes greatest joys, a very very very good caramel!
2 years ago
crochetgal says:
One of my favourite sweets was Smarties.. similar to the American M&M's but with a rich dark chocolate. Candy necklaces were always a favourite, along with ZabbaDabba and BB Bats! Do they even make those any more? I'd trade away my Pixie Stix, anything licorice and a few chocolates!
2 years ago
fantasybeader says:
Thank you Etsy for letting me be a part of this :-) It was fun. Heather
2 years ago
brownbunnybyiris says:
Yummy! All this goodies! http://www.etsy.com/shop/brownbunnybyiris
2 years ago
bstrung says:
I'm hungry now! I want one of each.
2 years ago