One half of the Canadian design blog Poppytalk, Jan is constantly on the lookout for the latest and greatest in handmade and design. Jan loves collecting inspiration and is dedicated to promoting emerging design talent on her blog and online curated marketplace/exhibition site, Poppytalk Handmade, that she shares with her husband and business partner Earl. She also writes daily for Babble.com in their Family Style section and monthly at IKEA’s home and ideas website, Ikea Family Live.
There’s always been a bit of a stereotype around buying gifts for men, and I don’t really know where it comes from. I think men are super-easy to buy for — they usually have the coolest hobbies to draw from (like guitars or bikes) and are way easier to please. I actually find women harder to buy for and prefer shopping for men.
I subscribe to the Etsy Dudes newsletter and love checking out the finds there each week. (Whoever creates that newsletter does an amazing job!) I was super-psyched when I was asked to do a gift guide for men and had a lot of fun hunting down gifts for this mysterious species. I hope you’ll find the gifts to be helpful and maybe even surprising. Check it all out below, and a huge thanks to the Etsy folks for having me!
For the Gentlemen
[1. Boyfriend hankie from ChezSucreChez; 2. Wild man amber brown aftershave from WildRoseHerbs; 3. Shea butter shaving soap from cordeliajandco; 4. Striped suspenders from dapperdean; 5. Skinny handmade tie from quindp88; 6. German wool felt iPad case from Feruto Bags]
For the Music Man
[7. Vintage straw hat from dumpsterbarn; 8. Recycled record player clock from pixelthis; 9. 100-watt Landry guitar amp from Landry Amps; 10. Guitar pick from bliss in a teacup; 11. Vintage '60s Hofner red electric guitar from zapbananamusic]
For the Cook
[12. Men's plaid apron from Dear Edna; 13. Hand carved wooden spoons from Erina Garner; 14. Maple Oatmeal stout beer brewing brewing kit from TheBrewersMarket; 15. Upcycled barbeque mitt from undoneclothing; 16. Vintage rustic cast iron bottle opener from The Shabby Shak; 17. Pyrex mixing bowl set from SplendidJunk]
For the Urban Bachelor
[18. Bench made from recycled bicycle tubes from Retread Design; 19. iRetrofone classic deluxe from freeland studios; 20. Little black book iPhone case from PadandQuill; 21. Polaroid set from vitalina shop]


99 comments
Sign in to add your ownIvyVining says:
I'd even like some of these for myself! Especially everything under the Urban Bachelor section.
1 year ago
RossLab says:
It's a tough call! Thanks for sharing these amazing items.
1 year ago
MootiDesigns says:
Great post. Thanks for sharing!
1 year ago
SecondEditionJewelry says:
This article was much needed for me! So many great items, thanks!
1 year ago
sonyarasi says:
Great ideas! Yes my man would love the collection!
1 year ago
paramountvintage says:
so many great ideas!!!
1 year ago
CarryTheWord says:
Lots of great ideas here!
1 year ago
lulusnest says:
Love this blog post... Now if I could only figure out what type of man my husband is these days! He's a jack of all trades, a bit mysterious, into music, and definitely a little geeky.
1 year ago
peshka says:
Thanks for sharing!
1 year ago
KMalinka says:
Great gifts for man!
1 year ago
Crafts2Cherish says:
Its indeed pretty hard to pick the right gift for guys so Cheers Jan!
1 year ago
myvintagecrush says:
Nice!
1 year ago
natashaaloha says:
GREAT MANLY GIFTS!
1 year ago
naturalwooddesign says:
Nice article!! Great gifts! :)
1 year ago
maggiesraggedyinn says:
Interesting article and yes I woudl like some of these for myself as well !!
1 year ago
btaylorquilts says:
Thanks for the great ideas! This is easy!
1 year ago
KettleConfections says:
So classy! We just did a treasury for guys recently as well.. http://www.etsy.com/treasury/NTUyMjIyNnwxNDc3MzY3NjUy/what-do-guys-want-for-christmas?index=0
1 year ago
spicedish says:
What a fantastic roundup. I want most of these things for myself though!
1 year ago
wildfireatheart says:
A lot of good options Thanks!
1 year ago
loyalirisives says:
beautiful job! love love love these gifts...
1 year ago
RivalryTime says:
Great gifts. I want them all.
1 year ago
SneakyPoodle says:
Shopping for my hubby now :) Thanks! ~sneakypoodle
1 year ago
FluffyFlowers says:
yep, these goodies will satisfy him :)
1 year ago
TheBrewersMarket says:
Thanks for including us! What a great list.
1 year ago
thestapeliacompany says:
I love boy gifts. In fact, I may get half of this stuff for myself! Great article. :)
1 year ago
BingoBox says:
Fun collections - cheers !
1 year ago
rebeccasanchez says:
Cool stuff!
1 year ago
WhisperingOak says:
Great to see hankies coming back
1 year ago
cottonbirddesigns says:
Great finds!
1 year ago
Parachute425 says:
I love a guy who loves a good hankie! Great suggestions.
1 year ago
BlackStar says:
Etsy is full of gifts for dudes of all ages.
1 year ago
CestSuperbeLabels says:
What's not to love about The Mysterious Man! Or shopping for The Mysterious Man. Yeah, loving this. (but uh..between you and me, I think he holds no mysteries for you. ;) Great gift guide!)
1 year ago
accentonvintage says:
Great blog and terrific selections!
1 year ago
NoFrump says:
ah, excellent ideas! and perfect timing!!
1 year ago
fantasygarden says:
That's is for me very difficult to shop for men, but i try to make something for now i did good he liked it ....so if you can not by just make for him something
1 year ago
Mclovebuddy says:
love this!
1 year ago
jamiespinello says:
my bf wants waterproof and heated motorcycle gloves......boring! He always wants the practical things! I'll find some extra surprises on etsy for him like I do every year though...in addition to the gloves.
1 year ago
jantonevich says:
Of the choices listed, it looks like old stuff/ vintage style is the way to go? Sounds good to me. I like it!
1 year ago
ipanema says:
Super gift guide!
1 year ago
ipanema says:
Super gift guide...love!
1 year ago
elleestpetite says:
These are great choices, thanks for sharing.
1 year ago
FranceGallery says:
Some fun and interesting gift ideas!
1 year ago
breadandroses2 says:
Well done! May I suggest the addition of a warm ear flap hat for the logsplitting, woodsman guys out there?
1 year ago
ZenBrush says:
Great!
1 year ago
CuriousTuesday says:
Great guide!!
1 year ago
theroyal says:
guys are so hard to shop for.. thanks for the guide
1 year ago
mikiheather says:
I think my husband would love all these things (me too!)
1 year ago
WeeBindery says:
What a fantastic collection! Lots of new favorites for me!!
1 year ago
MishaGirl says:
I love the assortment!
1 year ago
jacki650 says:
LOVE these ideas! I am definitely going to have to add this post to the Ultimate Gift Guide for Men > http://www.skinnyscoop.com/list/larissa/holiday-2011-gift-ideas-best-gifts-for-him Loving the record player clock :)
1 year ago
QuirkMuseum says:
Good stuff there. I got some duck decoys in my shop that the guys might like. Also some beer advertising signs that I gotta dig out too.
1 year ago
foxegurl266 says:
Wonderful!
1 year ago
rugglesstitch says:
I purchased one of those hankies from chezsucrechez a couple years ago - it makes such a cute gift!
1 year ago
ikabags says:
Great finds ! Thanks for your time !
1 year ago
LisaFerinDesigns says:
I love all these cool finds. At dinner tonight my daughter and step-daughter were complaining about how hard my husband is to shop for while I was saying how EASY he is to shop for. I should forward this to them!
1 year ago
JennythingVintage says:
I've been wondering why more people don't do the junk-clock thing. Love the bike wheels!
1 year ago
Nonchalantfont says:
I was wondering where the beer brewing kits were on etsy, thanks for the great ideas!
1 year ago
TheBrewersMarket says:
We've been here for a while. Come see us!
1 year ago
farfelue says:
neato! sweet post thanks for sharing!
1 year ago
cheriehaney says:
nothing like shopping for a hot steaming young hunk or an old barely bucking buck. underwear, the flattering kind that they don't seem to purchase for themselves is my favorite.
1 year ago
Iammie says:
Cool items!
1 year ago
VonlenskaVintage says:
you make a great point about boys being less picky. at least those aged 18+ :-) my dad (who introduced me to Etsy), is an avid art and prints collector (so much that we have giant paper bags full of poster tubes with art waiting for frames and wall space hanging around his office and storage space), but i know he'd adore anything relating to pine trees or the classic rock n roll he's brought through the past three decades. i just find parents to be the hardest to shop for!!
1 year ago
EdwardsPotteryNYC says:
There are so many wonderful "Man" items on Etsy!
1 year ago
bedouin says:
These are great finds ~ love love the Skinny handmade tie from quindp88 and the top photo of the record player is dreamy!!
1 year ago
poppyshop says:
Thank you everyone for all your comments! So great to hear what you all think! Lulusnest - funny! Kettle Confections - nice picks! jamiespinello - crazy - i never heard of those!
1 year ago
saraink says:
great ideas, thank you!
1 year ago
ovationstudio1 says:
Perfect gift guide...thanks
1 year ago
ovationstudio1 says:
Perfect gift guide..
1 year ago
availdesign says:
Wonderful gift ideas. Thank you.
1 year ago
weatheredsilo says:
Brilliant choices Jan, of course! Cheers, Mandy
1 year ago
AlottaPatina says:
Thank you for the great ideas! Bought a few guitar picks for my favorite player!
1 year ago
spoolandsparrowshop says:
As always, Jan ferrets out great finds!
1 year ago
katrinaalana says:
Cool ideas. Still need to go shopping for guys.
1 year ago
mtpstudios says:
I'd like one from each category, please!! Great finds! ;)
1 year ago
KarolinFelix says:
recycled record player clock......awesome <:
1 year ago
pixelthis says:
Sweet! Great picks here. Thank you very much. Im getting a beer kit, for sure.
1 year ago
LittleWrenPottery says:
Great picks, there are some fab gifts for men on Etsy. I love checking out Etsy Dudes too, especially if like me your not much of a girly girl!
1 year ago
thebeadgirl says:
awesome picks! guys are so hard to find cool gifts for...you gave me some great ideas :) thank you!
1 year ago
driftforever says:
Really cool collection
1 year ago
myjewelrycloset says:
super cool stuffs! now i can also subscribe to "etsy dudes newsletter" (was not even aware this exists, thanks for sharing!)
1 year ago
WalterSilva says:
Nice Article!
1 year ago
JewelMeShop says:
I have difficulty in choosing the proper present for men. I can spend hours thinking what to buy.... Thank you for giving so many ideas!
1 year ago
vinskord says:
Really cool finds!!
1 year ago
delightfullydedicate says:
My husband is a well rounded man so he enjoys any gift, but it can be hard when he already has everything! Our library is always a topic of conversation for our guests!
1 year ago
FullCircleRetro says:
I am eyeballing the "Mr. Mustachio Shea Butter Shaving Soap"... Great post!
1 year ago
roberto76 says:
and women are so easy to shop for.... http://www.airbnb.com/rooms/12543
1 year ago
freelandstudios says:
Very cool, thanks for including us in such an incredible group!
1 year ago
PeachesNBerries says:
<3 FANTASTIC XOXOX
1 year ago
shazzasknits says:
Thanks Jan, a great post!
1 year ago
BanglewoodSupplies says:
I'm buying my beau the apron!
1 year ago
dapperdean says:
AMAZING! and an honor. Thank you!
1 year ago
baconsquarefarm says:
Awesome finds~ nice to see the pretty face behind poppytalk~
1 year ago
elemegibere says:
Wonderful!
1 year ago
ArtWhims says:
Very nice selections!
1 year ago
FiveSproutsStitching says:
Great choices. I consider myself a mans man and I would be happy to get any one of those gifts (especially the brewing kit). Give a man a beer and he drinks for a day... teach a man to brew beer and he drinks for a lifetime.
1 year ago
sherrymetz says:
why the large pix of the 33 1/3 record player? is it an item for sale or a poster or?
1 year ago
jesudee says:
unfortunately, very many people neither know what spiritual warfare really means nor how to wage the war. some even call it warfare prayer though prayer is very important, it has nothing to do with spiritual.if spiritual warfare. this explains why many pray so much and still experience lack. your needs unmet -because i believe you must have prayed very hart if spiritual warfare is not about prayer , what then does it not about prayer, what then does it mean?
1 year ago
artfulmusicianNY says:
we have even more gifts for the mysterious man at artfulmusicianNY , glad the men are starting to get their fair shake on etsy!
1 year ago
Jessica Luther says:
Wonderful gifts for a man. Nice blog ! I like this post very much because it have the different categories for the different kind of men. Waiting for some new gifts ideas.Gifts Australia
1 year ago