
Erin Boyle is a blogger and writer based in Brooklyn, New York. She shares a tiny apartment with her husband and an antique bottle collection, and she writes about all of those things on her blog, Reading My Tea Leaves.
According to my exceedingly un-scientific calculations, there are two camps when it comes to stockings: those who open their stockings first thing in the morning and then dive into the rest of their gifts, and those who save the best for last. Regardless of your particular habit, here’s a little roundup of stocking-sized gifts to consider for your nearest and dearest.
[UNDER $10. Clockwise from top left: Jotter Pocket Notebook by Wit and Whistle; Golden Ombre Twig Pencil by Ink Kit; Reusable Organic Tea Bags by Natural Linens; I Love My Family Sticker by Beau Champing; Bamboo Charcoal Soap Samples by Morning Calm; Wooden Needle Case by The Small Object.]
[UNDER $25. Clockwise from top left: Striped Feather Carved Stamp by extase; Pink Himalayan Bath Salts by Herbivore Botanicals; Mini Arrow Embroidery Kit in Turquoise by Miniature Rhino; Tiny Tin Collection from Every Eskimo; Leather Keychain by gildem; Set of Four Navy "Etoile" Coasters by Knife in the Water; Travel Tissue Cozy in Camel by Handmaiden BC; Nature Bookmark Set by Miles of Light; Flat Pack iPhone Stand by Tokyo Craft Studios.]
In my ideal stocking, there’d be a mixture of gifts that are useful and gifts that are totally luxurious. Key chains, coasters, and card cases would be welcomed as useful loot, while miniature vases, wooden games, and vintage harmonicas would be adored for their pure enjoyment value. Other stuffers, like a new pair of cozy mittens or a jar of bath salts, would happily cover both bases.
[UNDER $50. Clockwise from top left: Leather Pencil Case by Present and Correct; Magic Pen Cube Magnetic Pen Holder by Less & More; Tea Light Holder by Tokyo Craft Studios; Stacrobots by Board Games; Miniature Hand-Blown Glass Bottle by Kiva Ford; Leather Wallet in Natural by Ada Blackjack.]
[Clockwise from top left: Antique Opera Glasses from Bird in Hand VTG; Personalized Luggage Tag Set by HarLex; Barn Owl Medal by Handy Maiden; Mittens by Sarah McNeil; Vintage Hohner Harmonica from NachoKitty; Amethyst Crystal With Air Plant Garden by Earth Sea Warrior; Vintage Magnifying Glass Charm from True Vintage Charms.]
My favorite kinds of stocking stuffers tend to be sweet and simple, but I’m warming to the idea of slipping something extra-special in among the chocolates and honey sticks. A tiny pair of antique opera glasses or a pair of custom leather luggage tags are special enough to wrap up and put under the tree, but small enough to tuck into a stocking. A foil-wrapped chocolate Santa will disappear almost immediately, but a vintage harmonica will stick around forever.

100 comments
Sign in to add your ownSusan Faye from SusanFayePetProjects says:
I can see I'll need to get a much bigger stocking...
177 days ago
Natallia from econica says:
excellent ideas! looove the Barn Owl medal! :)
177 days ago
AlisaDesign from AlisaDesign says:
Beautiful products!
177 days ago
Josie from PeonyKnits says:
Great selections! Love this :-)
177 days ago
Liz from greengrass2 says:
These are awesome stocking stuffers!!
177 days ago
Nazima Banka from nazimabanka says:
lovely examples, a wider range of talented etsians out there!
177 days ago
Lindsay from SweetThreesBoutique says:
I love filling a stocking with unique gifts! Love the mittens! :)
177 days ago
Becky from sojoshop says:
Lovely ideas!
177 days ago
maggiesraggedyinn from maggiesraggedyinn says:
This one made me smile and happy. I also love the mittens!!!!
177 days ago
Meaghan from ExLibrisJournals says:
super cute ideas! I bet my sister would love a few of these in her stocking!
177 days ago
WeeBindery from WeeBindery says:
You have good taste!
177 days ago
Meredith Schwab from DittyDrops says:
great finds Erin, thanks for sharing
177 days ago
ZOUi from XZOUIX says:
amazing ideas, believe me or not, i feel so inspired! can't wait to get back to my sewing machine tmrw :::-)
177 days ago
Tracy from 4EnvisioningVintage says:
Great list of stocking stuffers! Love those Stracobots and seeing some vintage pieces as well :)
177 days ago
Laurie from BirdinHandVTG says:
Fabulous, creative ideas! Thrilled to have my Antique Opera Glasses featured here - thank you, Erin :)
177 days ago
accentonvintage from accentonvintage says:
Great picks!
177 days ago
Sonya Rasi from sonyarasi says:
Great finds!
177 days ago
Marblry from Marblry says:
Lovely!!!!
177 days ago
Danielle Pedersen from HandyMaiden says:
Opening the stocking is the best part! Thanks for including me:)
177 days ago
Denise Vining from kadydesigns says:
Wonderful items!! Love the mittens!! I love putting the stockings together on Christmas eve!! My favorite! :)
177 days ago
Amber from BambuEarth says:
LOVE those mittens..
177 days ago
Patrick from EdelweissPost says:
Opera glasses are a wonderful holiday gift. A few years ago, I bought a pair for my friend Tracy, as we are both avid musical theatre goers. It's the gift that keeps on giving!
177 days ago
LivingVintage from LivingVintage says:
Great picks! Love the luggage tags.
177 days ago
OuterKnits from OuterKnits says:
Wonderful ideas. Love the mittens!
177 days ago
lovelygifts from lovelygifts says:
Cute ideas
177 days ago
Dawanna Young from peacesofindigo says:
You can stuff my stocking anytime! :) I love your finds~
177 days ago
IKA PARIS from ikabags says:
Lovely ideas and great picks ! Merci !
177 days ago
Kara M from HeirloomModern says:
Man, I could really use that needle case!
177 days ago
vesna from mycherrytree says:
beautiful!
177 days ago
Amanda Gynther from CafePrimrose says:
Oooh! So nice!
177 days ago
mazedasastoat from mazedasastoat says:
Miniatures from Kiva Ford... that's the kind of gift stockings were invented for!
177 days ago
Erin Boyle says:
thanks for all of your kind notes! i'm so glad that you guys are enjoying these selections!
177 days ago
Nicole from art2theextreme says:
Love these picks!
177 days ago
Kelly Hendershot from kellydesigns says:
Thank you for the awesome gift ideas, Erin! This is so helpful!
177 days ago
Maria S. from TheNorthWayStudio says:
Adore those mittens! May have to pick up a pair for myself:)
177 days ago
cait lucas from inkkit says:
Wonderful blog, great gift ideas and thanks for including my golden ombre pencil.
177 days ago
Kathy from krjewelrydisplays says:
Great stocking stuffers!
177 days ago
Laurie from metrocottage says:
These are all awesome stocking stuffers! I think I need to add a "stocking stuffer" section to my shop...
177 days ago
bellasparty from bellasparty says:
Great products!
177 days ago
Marta DQ from tribomo says:
Lovely finds! Thanks for sharing!
177 days ago
Janet from PottyMouthGems says:
We save the best for last here. Love the loot! Does anyone know my hubby? Please tell him I would be utterly smitten with the miniature glass vase and the opera glasses.
177 days ago
Penny Birch-Williams from PennyBirchWilliams says:
Stockings were such fun when I was a kid...we could open them right away when we got up in the morning, which made it easier to wait until our parents were up. Now, my kids are in college but we still enjoy the little treasures in our stockings on Christmas morning, which we open as a family (still in our pj's), and save the big gifts under the tree for when extended family comes over for brunch. I think the little rituals we develop are more meaningful and memorable than the gifts themselves. But finding the special little stocking stuffers is like a treasure hunt!
177 days ago
Jane Priser from JanePriserArts says:
Great picks and ideas.
177 days ago
Mingta Li from mingtaphotography says:
Wow wow wow!!! Lovely art works! Congrats!
177 days ago
Lana Manis from SimpleJoysPaperie says:
Fantastic finds! Love those mittens, opera glasses and hand-blown bottle! :)
177 days ago
Stacey from vintagejane says:
LOVE 'em all!
177 days ago
BonTons from BonTons says:
Nice ideas
177 days ago
Rebekah Hemmer from burnish says:
Oh, fun!
177 days ago
France Gallery from FranceGallery says:
The mini hand blown bottle is really sweet!
177 days ago
RetroRevivalBoutique from RetroRevivalBoutique says:
Oooh, I know someone that that amethyst geode would be perfect for! *Makes note* Thanks for all the sweet picks! :)
177 days ago
Martha M from LadyGatsbyLuxuryBath says:
great selection - thank you for sharing
177 days ago
Scott from vinylclockwork says:
Great Post thanks for the insight
176 days ago
VaLon Frandsen from thevicagirl says:
What a fun little collection.
176 days ago
steph from extase says:
thanks for including one of my stamps! great picks.
176 days ago
ursmama says:
superr sweeeet and cozzzy! Erin, thank you for including EarthSeaWarrior's Amethyst Crystal Air Plant Garden.... I'm honored ❤)))* Happy Holidayz & Cheerz to everyone! lov❤, ESW *ㅅ,ㅅ* (for whatever reason I couldn't leave a comment with my shop account so Im using my personal:)
176 days ago
Matejka Max from NattyMatty says:
Super cute!
176 days ago
Tom's Grossmami from tomsgrossmami says:
Great collection!
176 days ago
cylene from TheLovelySmith says:
fantastic choices - thanks so much for this! i am going to start the tradition of stockings with my two girls and the husband this year - we never had them as kids - because the whole idea of putting together little special gifts appeals to me so much! it's so easy to lose the spirit of giving among the glizty commercials and big box sale campaigns, so i'm hoping to bring a little handmade charm to our holidays! xoxoxoox
176 days ago
Natalia from Nikifashion says:
Awesome:O)
176 days ago
creativeclassics from creativeclassics says:
These are really cute, some of them would be great for Secret Santa gifts as well!
176 days ago
Victoria Baker from LittleWrenPottery says:
I always love little gifts they can be so thoughtful and end up getting more well used than big gifts because they can be stuffed away in pockets!
176 days ago
Liesl Carlson from lcarlsonjewelry says:
I am a stocking lover as well, and I think that your picks are perfect. Thank you
176 days ago
Kelly Engel from GrowingUpWild says:
Such unique finds. Now if only I can finish knitting our newest arrivals stocking in time. I love the needle holder and tissue cozie!
176 days ago
Christine from FineArtWithaTwist says:
ooh, those opera glasses are so neat!
176 days ago
Abby from SimpleBrightMoon says:
Very inspiring, lovely items!
176 days ago
The Royal from theroyal says:
i like that barn owl medal.
176 days ago
Jeniffer Inocente from LoveFatimaJewels says:
absolutely in love : )
176 days ago
FreakyPeas from FreakyPeas says:
that miniature bottle is amazing
176 days ago
Rhonda from optic says:
Stocking are so much fun. You can add so many tiny treasures. I love to add a fun gag gift. Great choices.
176 days ago
iammieCLAYshop from iammieCLAYshop says:
So cute!
176 days ago
victoriaenglishcharm from VictoriaEnglishCharm says:
a wonderful part of Christmas Day is watching my children emtying their stockings..... then come the sacks! so exciting!
176 days ago
Bunny Hipps from MimosaMornings says:
Great ideas - love them!
176 days ago
Monica from ThreeBarDGifts says:
So many great ideas! Thanks for the post!
176 days ago
minipotterybyanita from potterybyAnita says:
I ♥adore♥ tiny things--all my life now! I guess that's why I had this ability inside myself, just waiting to come out, 25 years ago! Lovely picks chosen here, too! ♥♥♥
176 days ago
Becky from BLintonPhotography says:
Santa can leave me any of these wonderful finds!
176 days ago
Marie Cashin from MEmbroideries says:
Can't have too many little treasures at this time of year!!!!!!!!!!!11
176 days ago
Darlene Jones from RomanceCatsAndWhimsy says:
Nice picks! I like the arrangement by price. I think I see some things I might want! :)
176 days ago
Pamela from Frecklesoriginals says:
I love mittens they remind me of junior school (56 years!!) they were the first thing we were taught to knit it took a whole term for me to finish mine. Hence me buying mine on etsy this week from LittleButtonsAndbows.
176 days ago
Clarice Booth from RECCIEatETSY says:
Love, Love, Love these! I really like the bamboo needle case, and the Travel Tissue Cozy. I personally would love to have the tissue cozy in a full box size....I mean who really wants to cozy up to a rigid box of tissues when they are sick in bed. Awesome suggestions. Blessings.
176 days ago
Prayer Notes by Cynthia from PrayerNotes says:
Wonderful collection of stocking stuffers! I am in-love with the golden ombre twig pencil. Thank you, for the wonderful finds. I'm off to shop! ~Cynthia
176 days ago
Whitney Watson from whitneysdesigns says:
Awesome ideas! Thanks for sharing them with us!
175 days ago
Canda Mitchell from FickleCrafts says:
Erin thank you for helping all shoppers find last minute gifts. I hope my mini Christmas stockings will end up here sometime:) new etsy shop FickleCrafts
175 days ago
Canda Mitchell from FickleCrafts says:
Erin - thank you for the great last minute ideas. - Canda from FickleCrafts
175 days ago
Canda Mitchell from FickleCrafts says:
Erin thank you for sharing. Canda from FickleCrafts
175 days ago
Suzi from ThePillowStudioShop says:
Great ideas. I think I will fill my own stocking this year. : )
175 days ago
lunaessence from LunaEssence says:
Super Ideas !!
175 days ago
s from knifeinthewater says:
so beautiful and carefully picked items....loved them all and enjoyed reading your story as well :) thank you.!
175 days ago
asmina fotos from asmina says:
Beautiful ideas!
175 days ago
Sandro Stumpo from GalleryDiModa says:
Nice stuff, how about instead of waiting for people to read my mind I go ahead and stuff my own stocking full great Etsy gifts. Seriously I think this year I am going buy myself a gift.
174 days ago
DewyMorningVintage from DewyMorningVintage says:
Great ideas for Etsy stocking stuffers! If my stocking had these great items I may forget to open my other presents!
174 days ago
Nadin Sandler from NadinArtGlass says:
amazing! Nadin
172 days ago
Shelley McElhiney from samsstuff says:
So many sweet little gifts! Thank you for the great ideas
172 days ago
Eleanore from FiberBeads says:
Helpful article!
172 days ago
Leslie from TheMudPlace says:
Wonderful finds! I love your picks!
172 days ago
Julia and Alex Wills from HerbivoreBotanicals says:
very nice, thank you Erin! : )
172 days ago
Antonina from feltancrochet says:
excellent ideas. love the picks
172 days ago
Paulina Rzeszutek from cinnamonandmint says:
I just love it! Barn Owl Medal is amazing :)
171 days ago
Regina from ChainAndCluster says:
Thanks Erin! Really lovely gift ideas :)
171 days ago
Sam's Natural from SamsNatural says:
I guess men were forgotten here
168 days ago
Hendri . from butikonline83 says:
How cool! I love the history lesson too!
159 days ago