Etsy's Handmade Blog
Economics 101: Alchemy

JJMFinance, a Certified Public Accountant, sees the world through green-tinted glasses and he's out to help Etsy sellers with their businesses. He looks at Etsy site features and sees economic case studies. And we love it! Below you'll find his useful interpretation of Alchemy.

Do you remember your economics teacher and the way he could put you to sleep after lunch showing your graphs and blabbing about supply and demand? Maybe he could have kept your attention if he was talking about Etsy’s new system for requesting custom-made items — Alchemy. Alchemy is a great example to see a simple economic principal observed — supply and demand. Keep reading to learn more! Not only will you get a quick refresher course in economics, but you will also learn a few ways you can apply these principals to the way you run your Etsy shop.

Supply
Supply is what everyone offers for sale. These are the thousands of items listed on Etsy. There are over 14,000 different red earrings currently listed on Etsy — different varieties for different people. This is the supply of red earrings.

Demand
Right now there are many buyers surfing the pages of Etsy looking to make purchases. A few of those are actually looking for red earrings right now. They are browsing through the currently listed supply seeing if their demands have a matching supply in both design and price. This is the demand for red earrings.

Where Supply Meets Demand
There are a couple of options that can happen at this point. First, the buyer could find a pair of red earrings that are currently listed that meet their stylistic and price demands and a complete transaction could occur. The second option is where Alchemy makes its appearance.

Alchemy is just another point in the marketplace where supply and demand can meet and fall in love getting married in something called a transaction. This is really a new way for crafters and customers to meet in harmony — creating a more efficient marketplace where more buyers and sellers are both happy.

Application For Your Shop
You can actually look at the current requests and bids in Alchemy to get a mini picture of how supply and demand are interacting on Etsy.

You can use this to:
1. See potential market niches that you could fill with your business. If you consistently see people requesting yellow sweaters with green pickles appliquéd on the back, you can probably assume that if you started making these, you would pick up some of these sales before they reached Alchemy.
2. If you see no one bidding on a really low priced request, you can probably assume that this price is way under the true market price. You can then compare this price to your similar items.
3. If you see people consistently requesting a product for a much higher price than you offer it for — you can probably assume that your prices might be too low.

So the next time you browse through Alchemy, don’t just see what items you could bid on, but look for opportunities to learn about the Etsy market. Use these observations to then help you decide on new products to expand in your own Etsy shop and your current pricing strategies.

Learn more about Alchemy here.

Tags Alchemy, business, economics, JJMFinance, pricing, Seller Handbook, selling, site features
All articles in How-To
Related Items
This article was reported by:
JJMFinance

9 comments     Login to add your own!

April 8, 2008 at 3:01 p.m. avenuehandmade

Good tips, thanks JJM!

April 8, 2008 at 9:03 p.m. kreations

Methinks there are great markets for:
* Vinyl show banners
* Custom rubber stamps
* Avatar/Banner Design

This is a great article. Thanks!

April 8, 2008 at 11:41 p.m. ZestyB

I like you the perspective on Alchemy. Thanks JJM.

April 8, 2008 at 11:42 p.m. ZestyB

ugh - sorry
I like your perspective on Alchemy!

I bet I'd like you too :D

April 9, 2008 at 2:33 a.m. dancingcircle

You're right, JJM, it's about what the market will bear. I'd love to see more articles like this.

April 9, 2008 at 3:13 a.m. jillhannah

More! More! The ex-econ major in me wants Economics 102 and beyond!

I also totally understand that this is the 101 uber-simplified version, but I'm itching to scream and point at all the other complicating factors and such. Also, the way Alchemy is currently set up, I think the "ideal price" and bidding system goes much more to game theory than the demand curve, or maybe we can see little tiny demand curves in each Alchemy request as buyers weigh bid prices with item descriptions. But again, I know, it's reeeeeally simplified.

I may have to do a big fat econ blog post in the next few days. http://jillhannah.blogspot.com if you're interested.

Thanks for the article!

April 9, 2008 at 1:59 p.m. blackbird72

great article! as etsy and my photography are my full time job on top of being a mommie AND having MS. i need to make sales and budget more as well. but first i need to create more sales :)

April 9, 2008 at 2:31 p.m. castocreations

Very interesting article. I think alchemy is actually a little skewed since there are people on Etsy who are Hobbiest willing to work for pennies on the dollar. And people who are desperate for a sale and will do the work for practically nothing. It galls me to see some of the requests coming through - people wanting high quality (silver and gold) items for almost nothing. But again, if people are willing to do it for pennies then the market is working.

April 12, 2008 at 5:09 p.m. GuidingLightCandles

This is a wonderful article and JJM's suggestions would work beautifully for many of us IF people would stop abusing Alchemy.

Thanks JJM for your very optimistic view of Alchemy and your wonderful article!

Previous Page | Next Page