As a buyer on Etsy (and a one day shop owner, hopefully), how about the banner being divided in three: shop handmade, shop vintage, shop supplies? One could then click on a section, be led to said category and search specifically from there. For example, I am looking for a vintage Dooney and Burke purse, so I would click on "shop vintage" and take it from there. I cannot remember if the banner was ever this way. It may also satisfy some of those not happy with the "drop box" changes.