FirstandFinestCo

Pennsylvania, United States

458
 Sales

4.9 (113)

1 year
on Etsy

4.9 (113)

458
 sales

1 year
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

458
 Sales

4.9 (113)

1 year
on Etsy

4.9 (113)

458
 sales

1 year
on Etsy

All 59
On sale 59

Contact shop owner

458 Sales

37 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Reviews

4.9 (113)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Isabel on 18 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

completely met my expectations, exactly what i ordered in very nice quality.

Katie responded on 18 May, 2026

Looks great!! Thank you!

Personalized Crate Sign

Personalized Crate Sign
Etsy buyer on 10 Mar, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great quality, responsive service and on time Shipping. Great experience and will use them again in the near future. Thank you!!

Katie responded on 10 Mar, 2026

Thank you! Enjoy!

Philadelphia Phillies Slate Coaster

Philadelphia Phillies Slate Coaster
Kaileen on 11 Jan, 2026

4 out of 5 stars

It was a great family gift exchange.

Katie responded on 11 Jan, 2026

Thank you! Go Irish!

Notre Dame Wooden Clock

Notre Dame Wooden Clock
Pam on 18 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Working with Katie was a breeze! The shipping was so fast and it was for a gift so the quick ship was great! Highly recommended!

Katie responded on 18 Jun, 2026

Thank you! Glad we were able to make the coasters personalized the way you wanted! Enjoy!

Dallas Cowboys Slate Coaster

Dallas Cowboys Slate Coaster
Matt on 08 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Wonderful seller and great product. It was everything I’d hoped for

Katie responded on 08 Jun, 2026

Thank you! Go Bills!

Handmade Buffalo Bills 3D Wood Sign

Handmade Buffalo Bills 3D Wood Sign
Michelle on 19 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These I swear shipped the same day! they are great quality and beautiful! They'll be great on the patio!

Katie responded on 19 May, 2026

Happy to hear! Go Bills!

Josh Allen MVP Quote Slate Coaster

Josh Allen MVP Quote Slate Coaster
Marcus on 11 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great product and arrived fast. Perfect addition to my fan cave.

Katie responded on 12 May, 2026

Looks great! Enjoy!

Las Vegas Raiders Slate Coaster

Las Vegas Raiders Slate Coaster
David on 01 Apr, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

this product was of high quality and came out great. The only down fall was not having a hanger on the back to put up on the wall.

Katie responded on 01 Apr, 2026

Thank you for the kind review! As stated in the listing, the sign does not come with any kind of backing. However, it can easily be hung with command strips.

Handmade Atlanta Braves 3D Wooden Sign

Handmade Atlanta Braves 3D Wooden Sign
Janet on 19 Mar, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Absolutely awesome! So very much more than perfect! Fantastic, generous Seller!!! I cannot thank you enough

Katie responded on 19 Mar, 2026

Thank you!

Villanova University Slate Coaster

Villanova University Slate Coaster
James on 15 Mar, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great quality, and no problems at all.

Katie responded on 15 Mar, 2026

Thank you!

Miami Dolphins Slate Coaster

Miami Dolphins Slate Coaster