Etsy admin please reconsider some handmade definitions

Report a post

Thank you for taking time to help Etsy! Please note that you will not receive a personal response about this report. We will review this post privately...

Why are you reporting this post?

Any additional comments?

Edit Post

Edit your post below. After editing, the post will be marked as edited and the date & time of the last edit displayed.

Close

What is this?

Admin may choose to highlight awesome community posts that are friendly, answer questions, and offer informative links.

What does it do?

Highlighted posts are placed at the top of each page in a thread for greater visibility.

Sign in to participate in this discussion.

Original Post

Ok, I think if you put a bunch of store bought things together and reassemble it it can be handmade, but I don't think it always is. Take for example the rampant practice on etsy of buying a mass produced charm and putting it on a mass produced finished chain and calling it handmade. Is that really handmade? I mean seriously one charm on one chain? If that is considered handmade, I think it makes Etsy look awfully bad.

Posted at 10:30pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

Responses

www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=5734671


That's essentially what I did with this piece. I hadn't seen the idea before, so I did it. That's half the idea behind 'making'. Having a unique idea. It may be simple, but it's different. Sure, there are things that I think shouldn't be here, but there's no way to blanket regulate the whole charm and chain thing you mentioned. :)

Posted at 10:35pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

Seriously, and for me personally, hear hear.

But be aware that this might be considered calling out, and might not go down well with a lot of forum users. This might be an opinion best kept to oneself, I'm afraid.

Posted at 10:35pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

odkins says

Though I completely (completely) hear you on this one, I'd say it's a waaaaaaaaaay too slippery slope to start saying just HOW handmade something has to be. Argh.

Posted at 10:35pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

odkins says

Well, and there.. see? gemmafactrix demonstrates a good example of why it'd be bad bad bad to start making that sort of declaration in a general sense. I hadn't even thought of it that way.

Posted at 10:36pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

On another note, I LOVE your stuff, and, damn, Lady, you are in every single on-line shop I'm sending stuff to right now ;)

Posted at 10:37pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

Hey Gemma I think those earrings are different, plus they are made with vintage components. I am talking about a made in china dodad that was simply plunked onto a chain and called handmade.
Hey paraphernalia thanks for the compliments!

Posted at 10:42pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

I've applied to shows where they would call that simple assemblage and not admit it to a show, but I do believe Etsy's view is that if you assemble something it is handmade. Previous posts are right, this could start a bru-ha-ha when you start to define levels of handmade.

Posted at 10:50pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

Sorry if this could start a squabble, I am not trying to be bitchy at all. I just feel frustrated when I search through the jewelry section and see this quite a bit. I mean seriously its like changing your shoelaces and saying you made your shoes.

Posted at 10:55pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT

When all of the stuff was going on about supplies and the handmade/commercial thing I emailed Etsy. I sell brass charms and findings but I put the finish on them myself. I didn't know so I asked, Rob told me since I did the finish they belonged in handmade....who knew?

Posted at 10:55pm Apr 11, 2007 EDT