Buttons or no buttons?

Report a post

Thank you for taking time to help Etsy! Please note that you will not receive a personal response about this report. We will review this post privately...

Why are you reporting this post?

Any additional comments?

Edit Post

Edit your post below. After editing, the post will be marked as edited and the date & time of the last edit displayed.


What is this?

Admin may choose to highlight awesome community posts that are friendly, answer questions, and offer informative links.

What does it do?

Highlighted posts are placed at the top of each page in a thread for greater visibility.

Sign in to participate in this discussion.

Original Post

usafwife08 says

I have been thinking about the buttons on my booties, and wondering if they are safe. There are buttons on children's shoes and I have seen other booties with buttons on here. Thoughts? Thanks!

Posted at 6:39pm May 2, 2010 EDT


moandozzy says

Unless you obtain the CPSIA ccompliance certificate from the company that manufactures the buttons, you'll have to have the buttons independantly tested. SUPER expensive. I contacted the company that makes the buttons I use and they confirmed that the specific line I use is in compliance and emailed me their certificates. (I use buttons from Blumenthal Lansing.) They were VERY easy to work with, but I've heard others are not so friendly. A phone call or two and an e-mail tomorrow *should* get you what you need to use buttons.

Posted at 6:50pm May 2, 2010 EDT


Thanks for sharing your button source, I quit putting buttons on items because of this.

Posted at 7:07pm May 2, 2010 EDT

moandozzy says

I was going to . . . . and it was really making me sad! Then I realized, ifmajor clothing companies can still use buttons, there must be a way. :) You'll need a small parts warning for buttons on toys if they're small, but clothing is ok.

Posted at 7:09pm May 2, 2010 EDT

moandozzy says

Oh, and Blumenthal Lansing buttons are EVERYWHERE . . . very easy to get and reasonably priced. You may want to visit their website and pick some favorites, then call and make sure they comply, and then go purchase. I emailed the rep for my state and they emailed back the certificates within 12 hours.

Posted at 7:10pm May 2, 2010 EDT

Wow better than most places I have tried to get info from

Posted at 7:14pm May 2, 2010 EDT

Currently under the CPSIA if you can get test results from a supply's manufacturer with the lead listed in PMM (& dependant on the age group the finished product is for the phthalate levels im PPM) and link the test results to which of the finished products you make then you're good to go for issuing your GCC for your products. Remember that the component testing format or requirements can be changed at any time by the CPSIA committee or even rescinded, so check the CPSIA website frequently.

Just keep in mind that the exclusion from the small parts warnings only apply to clothing if the small part in question is part of the functionality of the clothing. If the small part is an embellishment or for decorative purposes only then it my need the small parts testing / warnings. So a button used to secure two sides of clothing together is exempt from the small parts testing and having warnings but a button used to add pizazz to a piece of clothing may need to go through laboratory testing, have correctly formated warnings directly attached to the product, and have an appropriately worded warning in the listings.

Posted at 10:15pm May 2, 2010 EDT

kirstenann says

Not sure on that one I guess people buy at their own risk.

Posted at 2:07am May 3, 2010 EDT

Patchtique says

Although I like the look of buttons for eyes on my bears, I only use felt, because of CPSIA and because of the choking hazard.

Posted at 10:48am May 3, 2010 EDT

I use buttons as eyes on my sock creatures but I list that they are unsuitable for children under 3 yrs.

Posted at 10:58am May 3, 2010 EDT

Unfollow username?

Are you sure you want to stop following this person?