New York State Sales Tax

Report a post

Thank you for taking time to help Etsy! Please note that you will not receive a personal response about this report. We will review this post privately...

Why are you reporting this post?

Any additional comments?

Edit Post

Edit your post below. After editing, the post will be marked as edited and the date & time of the last edit displayed.


What is this?

Admin may choose to highlight awesome community posts that are friendly, answer questions, and offer informative links.

What does it do?

Highlighted posts are placed at the top of each page in a thread for greater visibility.

Sign in to participate in this discussion.

Original Post

fairseason says

Hi Etsy sellers!

I did a little research because I wanted to clarify the new sales tax addition to checkout. I live in New York state and I sell vintage clothing, shoes, & accessories. If you live in NYS & sell clothing and shoes, & accessories, NEW or VINTAGE please read.

Maybe I missed it, but Etsy doesn't make it clear that you should only charge YOUR STATE'S sales tax when you are shipping to a customer who also lives in YOUR STATE.

In NYS these are the rules for clothing and shoes:


PURCHASES OF CLOTHING AND SHOES $110 or more the tax rate is 8.875%

PURSES & Other leather accessories GET THE WHOLE 8.875% no matter what the price

Again, these rules are for sales that happen within the state of New York. If you are in NY and your customer is in Montana, you don't have to charge sales tax at all.

Here is a helpful link. Download the PDF in the Tax Rates section. The link says "State website":

I know this is long, I apologize. I hope it's helpful though!

Posted at 11:43 am Aug 28, 2010 EDT


no, etsy doesnt make anything clear with taxes and laws, that is up to each business owner to know the laws that pertain to them

Posted at 11:47 am Aug 28, 2010 EDT

and also- for NY, you would charge everyone in NY one rate either. you have to charge the rate that applies to their address, when you are shipping goods to them.

Posted at 11:48 am Aug 28, 2010 EDT

Well that makes it darn near impossible to tax correctly using this system doesn't it. Sorry. :(

Not that you can calculate tax correctly for NYS anywhere anyway. Other than manually. I wish NYS would simplify it so at the very very least a zip code could be used to figure the tax rate. OK enough ranting.

Posted at 11:49 am Aug 28, 2010 EDT

GoTo says

It is up to each seller to know and follow the laws their business should, it's not Etsy's job to do that.

There's no way for them to know all the sales tax laws... even what you posted is inaccurate for all NY--what you quoted was for items sold in or shipped to NY City, not NY State.

In NYC clothes up to $110 may be exempt but where I am there is still local tax on those items, just no state tax, so I would still pay 3.75% sales tax on a $10 item here.

If you shipped a $10 clothing item to me, you'd need to collect that 3.75% sales tax from me because NYS has destination-based sales tax. That means the rate you charge is based on the buyer's location if it is shipped, not the sellers.

NY does make it tough...

Posted at 1:09 pm Aug 28, 2010 EDT

fairseason says

Hi everybody,

Thanks for all the input. I may be totally wrong and things are a lot more complicated than I think for those of us running an online business in New York State. I do come from a retail background and ran a very busy online store for a New York based handbag company. We had a bookkeeping staff and an accounting firm that reviewed our books every quarter and we never based our tax collections on the location of the customer. We went by the rates that applied to our business location which was in NYC. Those are the rates that I posted in my initial message.

I'll definitely look into what GoTo is saying about variable rates based on the customer's address.

Thanks again everybody.

Posted at 7:19 pm Aug 28, 2010 EDT

GoTo says

It's sad to hear that a company big enough to have bookkeeping/accounting firm doing their paperwork didn't know the state law, but I've mentioned in the forums before that those who deal with income tax by profession don't necessarily have experience with/knowledge of sales tax laws. They are totally different types of taxes and the rules for sales tax for mail order businesses are different than the rules for in-person sales in many states.

Posted at 11:15 pm Aug 28, 2010 EDT

Lol I have little hope that I'll eventually understand all these sales tax laws if professionals can't even keep them straight.

Posted at 4:35 am Aug 29, 2010 EDT

GoTo says

Boutique--they really aren't that bad, you'll understand them fine (start with the links above and you'll be well on your way).

Most likely those professionals didn't bother to see if the rules were different for the type of business they were working for which says a lot more about the quality of their work than about the laws.

Posted at 2:50 pm Aug 29, 2010 EDT

Unfollow username?

Are you sure you want to stop following this person?