Whoa! You can't favorite your own shop.

Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Whoa! You can't favorite your own item.

Whoa! You can't add your own item to a list.

Add this item to a treasury!

You don't have any treasuries yet. Enter a title below to create one.

This item has been added.

View your treasury.

Like this item?

Add it to your favorites to revisit it later.
Request a custom order and have something made just for you.
Vanilla Fudge topped with Butterfinger candy pieces, pushed down in so that every bite has that Butterfinger crunch!

This listing is for one and a half pounds. Small piece shown in the photo is approximately 1/2 pound. It will come in plastic wrap to retain moisture, packed in a small priority mail box. (As we don't use preservatives, once you receive your order, it is best to store fudge in a more open manner to prevent molding, ... that is, if you think it will stay around for more than a couple of weeks!)

We've been making fudge since 1989, and the over 30 tons we've made is testimony to our belief that there is no better fudge anywhere! We make around 75 pounds of fudge a week, so it's always fresh.

Since we fill our orders from our store inventory, usually orders ship the same or next day. In the rare instance that we are out of a flavor, it may be 3-4 days before shipping as we will have to make it and give it time to set up. Please let us know if time is a concern.

While we try to be consistent, since each batch is made by hand, no two pieces look exactly alike.

We can ship up to 4 flavors of fudge in one box for the same $7 shipping price. Please order our 2 pound sampler and choose your flavors!

Ingredients: Sugar, milk, butter (cream, salt), corn syrup solids, partially hydrogenated palm kernel oil with soy lecithin, brown sugar, non-fat dry milk solids, cream (milk) powder, sorbitol, salt, natural and artificial flavors. Butterfinger pieces also have ground roasted peanuts, cocoa, molasses, and less than 1% of whey (from milk), confectioner's corn flakes, lactic acid esters, soybean oil, cornstarch, ctiric acid, yellow5, red 40.

ALLERGY: Contains milk, soy, peanuts.

Butterfinger Fudge, 1 1/2 pounds, Old-fashioned Cream & Butter Recipe loaded with Butterfinger pieces



  • Handmade item
  • Materials: butter, sugar and brown sugar, cream
  • Only ships within United States.
  • Feedback: 230 reviews
  • Favorited by: 46 people