Custom and personalized orders

Yes! Send us a message! We gladly create designs just for you!

Gift wrapping and packaging

We do! Send us a note so we can add a reminder to wrap your item!

My item was mailed to the wrong address

While this does not happen often, it is very important to check your current address saved on your account. We are happy to adjust the address before shipping but cannot be responsible for the shipping fees to resend package once returned back for insufficient address, wrong address, unable to deliver, forwarding expired, etc. We will reach out to the buyer if a package is returned to review options to resend.

Is it possible to rush the order?

We have a “rush order” which subtracts 5 days from the estimated shipping date available. Please include the listing below within the same order. Once the order is received you will receive a confirmation email with the shipping date adjustment. The rush order fee is per item and cannot be used for an entire cart. Please let us know if you have any questions! https://etsy.me/3uKgXBV

Report this item to Etsy

Annual Cookie Exchange Party Favor | 2026 Cookie Swap Party Favor | Annual Cookie Exchange Ornament Prize | Cookie Exchange Favor

Name: Annual Cookie Exchange Party Favor | 2026 Cookie Swap Party Favor | Annual Cookie Exchange Ornament Prize | Cookie Exchange Favor
Brand: HomeSweetSignsNH
SKU: 1073582950
Price: 43.29 NZD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5.0 (42 reviews)

Only 7 left and in 3 baskets

Price:NZ$43.29+

* Seller GST included (where applicable). Additional GST may be applied by Etsy at checkout

HomeSweetSignsNH

Package Type

Please select an option

Personalization

Top Arch: Please let us know 1st, 2nd, 3rd Annual, etc or we can put a name at the top like "Kate's Annual." "Cookie Exchange" will be used as the default as shown in the center. The banner can be personalized as well instead of "Baked with Love in"

0/256

Quantity

You can only make an offer when buying a single item.

Star Seller. This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, dispatched on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.

Highlights

Made by HomeSweetSignsNH
Materials: maple wood, love
Width: 3.5 inches

Height: 3.5 inches
Gift wrapping available

Let’s get ready for the best holiday Christmas cookie exchange! This is our original 3.5 inch maple wood round ornament engraved with “1st Annual Cookie Exchange / Baked with love in 2026” (You choose 1st Annual, 2nd, etc. Add this to the personalization field.)

Choose the “Baked with love in 2026” as party favors for all guests or bundle with our 6 cookie prize winner ornaments. Add our printed Ballot Cards to help with your party planning (link below.)

Prize Ornaments included in bundle:

Prettiest Cookie
Most Festive
Best Tasting
Most Unique
Prettiest packaging
Best Overall

Printed (Mailed to you) Ballot Cards in 4x6 inch size card-stock found here: https://etsy.me/3BHypKM

Ornaments are made in Londonderry, NH. Follow our shop at the links below to see our newest creations!

Add our shop as Favorite ❤️ Etsy shop: https://etsy.me/2EfKXue

Instagram: @homesweetsigns

Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/HomeSweetSigns/

Dispatches within 6 business days
Returns & exchanges not accepted
Sent from: United States

Sorry, this item doesn’t deliver to New Zealand. Contact the shop to find out about available delivery options.

There was a problem calculating your postage. Please try again.

Country

Post code

Please enter a valid post code.

Etsy Purchase Protection
Shop confidently on Etsy knowing if something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases — see programme terms

Etsy invests in climate solutions like electric trucks and carbon offsets for every delivery. See how