Spend $50 on your first-ever purchase and get $10 towards your next one. Ends 12/12. A welcome gift: Spend $50 or more on your first-ever purchase and get $10 towards your next one. Ends 12/12. See details

Darn. This item is no longer available.

Browse more items from Etsy

Peanut Butter Blossoms - 1 Dozen
$18.00
Bakeosaurus
Peanut Butter and Chocolate
$18.00
LilMMsCupcakes
Peanut Butter Fudge 1/2 lb.
$8.00
gabbyssweets
Pies!
$3.31
SilviaFimoCreations
Peanut Butter Cookies
$16.00
HomeMadeSweetShop
Pies
$15.00
Erikasbakery
Peanut Butter Oreo Fudge
$13.00
NudgeShoppe
Pies Soap
$4.96
Historiasdapele
Whoppie Pies
$35.00
VintageMetalGalaxy
Caramel Apple Fried Pies
$20.00
HalfBakedNC
Chocolate Pie
$20.00
gretelsoven
Three Pies
$12.50
GeorgiaPeachCrochet
Candle pies
$12.00
RitasRingsThings