Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Baseball Mitt Cookies (1 dozen)

Like this item?

Add it to your favorites to revisit it later.
Favorite
Request a custom order and have something made just for you.

Description

***NOTE: Please check our shop front for unavailable dates for cookie orders! Orders placed for events/parties during our unavailable dates will be canceled. Thank you for your understanding!***

1 dozen hand-decorated Baseball Mitt Cookies! Great for team parties!

All of our cookies are made from-scratch with fresh ingredients and real butter in our licensed & inspected kitchen! Perfect for party favors, dessert tables, gifts, or just because.

This listing is for mitt/glove cookies, only.
**For larger quantities, please contact us prior for a custom order**

Cookies are vanilla with our fan-favorite citrus royal icing!

Each individual cookie is wrapped in clear bag for shipping. Please choose between heat sealed or wrapped with a twist tie and coordinating ribbon (See last photo for example of each packaging method). - - Custom party tags are available in separating listing for twist-tie packaging!
- Custom sticker labels are available in separate listing for heat sealed packaging!

Reviews

5 out of 5 stars
(392)

Payments

Secure options
  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • American Express
  • Discover
  • Paypal
  • GiftcardAccepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.
~~About Payment~~

Payment must be received before any order will begin. Unfortunately, a delay in payment will delay your order. We appreciate your prompt payment so we may begin to create your delicious treats!

Returns & exchanges

I gladly accept returns and cancellations
Contact me within: 3 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 7 days of delivery
Request a cancellation within: 7 days of purchase
I don't accept exchanges
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
Returns and exchange details
*No refunds for consumed items.*

Due to the nature of our custom made to order and perishable items, we cannot cancel orders or offer refunds after items have shipped or been picked up, unless items are returned (in full) to Storybook Bakery first. Refunds or future order discounts may be given at owner's discretion, only.

If you need to cancel or postpone your order, please let us know ASAP!

Shipping policies

~~SHIPPING~~
(For LOCAL orders, scroll down to the LOCAL section!)

All items are made to order. WE REQUIRE ALL ORDERS TO BE PLACED AT LEAST 2 WEEKS PRIOR TO YOUR EVENT/DELIVERY/PICK-UP DATE. Please include your event date (or date which you would like to receive/pick-up items) in the notes section during checkout.

We typically ship all orders Tuesday for estimated delivery on Thursday-Friday for weekend events. However, we may ship your order on a different day. We ship via USPS Priority 2-3 Day shipping, only. While this shipping method has proven to be extremely reliable, we cannot guarantee items will arrive on USPS estimated delivery date. Bad weather, remote locations, etc. can all affect delivery times.

NOTE: Shipping dates are entirely at our discretion, depending on our weekly schedule. If we are forced to delay shipping, we may decide to ship via Express (Overnight) at our expense, to make sure your items arrive in time for your event. Please do NOT leave a review stating your items are late, unless they are actually late: i.e. it's the day of your event and your items are not there. Often, our packages arrive the day before your event. For food items, this is common practice and completely on purpose. Thank you!

~~LOCAL ORDERS~~
Our licensed home bakery is located in Chesapeake, Virginia. We are NOT a retail store. Orders may only be placed online and picked up at designated times, which will be discussed after your order is placed.

**When placing a local order, use the coupon code LOCAL to eliminate the shipping charge. Then put your event date or desired pick-up date in the notes section during checkout. We will contact you a few days prior to your date to set a time for pick-up.**

We are available for pick-up Monday-Friday between the hours of 12:00 (noon) and 8:00 pm. ALL PICK-UP TIMES MUST BE CONFIRMED BY US prior to your arrival. We will not answer the door if we are not expecting you (for fear you may be a solicitor!), so please make sure that you arrive within your pick-up window or contact us for rescheduling.

LOCAL DELIVERY is only available for large/bulk orders and only to commercial addresses. Delivery charge depends on distance and size of order. For more information, please send us a message.
~~SHIPPING~~
(For LOCAL orders, scroll down to the LOCAL section!)

All items are made to order. WE REQUIRE ALL ORDERS TO BE PLACED AT LEAST 2 WEEKS PRIOR TO YOUR EVENT/DELIVERY/PICK-UP DATE. Please include your event date (or date which you would like to receive/pick-up items) in the notes section during checkout.

We typically ship all orders Tuesday for estimated delivery on Thursday-Friday for weekend events. However, we may ship your order on a different day. We ship via USPS Priority 2-3 Day shipping, only. While this shipping method has proven to be extremely reliable, we cannot guarantee items will arrive on USPS estimated delivery date. Bad weather, remote locations, etc. can all affect delivery times.

NOTE: Shipping dates are entirely at our discretion, depending on our weekly schedule. If we are forced to delay shipping, we may decide to ship via Express (Overnight) at our expense, to make sure your items arrive in time for your event. Please do NOT leave a review stating your items are late, unless they are actually late: i.e. it's the day of your event and your items are not there. Often, our packages arrive the day before your event. For food items, this is common practice and completely on purpose. Thank you!

~~LOCAL ORDERS~~
Our licensed home bakery is located in Chesapeake, Virginia. We are NOT a retail store. Orders may only be placed online and picked up at designated times, which will be discussed after your order is placed.

**When placing a local order, use the coupon code LOCAL to eliminate the shipping charge. Then put your event date or desired pick-up date in the notes section during checkout. We will contact you a few days prior to your date to set a time for pick-up.**

We are available for pick-up Monday-Friday between the hours of 12:00 (noon) and 8:00 pm. ALL PICK-UP TIMES MUST BE CONFIRMED BY US prior to your arrival. We will not answer the door if we are not expecting you (for fear you may be a solicitor!), so please make sure that you arrive within your pick-up window or contact us for rescheduling.

LOCAL DELIVERY is only available for large/bulk orders and only to commercial addresses. Delivery charge depends on distance and size of order. For more information, please send us a message.

Additional policies

COLOR CHANGES:
For simple color changes, you may use original listings and put color choice(s) in notes section during checkout.

CUSTOM ORDERS:
Please send us a message to inquire about a custom order or larger quantities than what is available on our shop.

For different quantities or designs we do not currently offer in our store, we will create a special listing specifically for your items and you will have 3 days to place your order. If order is not placed within 3 days, listings will be removed.
(Sellers are charged a fee to post ANY listing, so serious inquiries only, please.)

*******We are always up to new challenges and designs, however, we WILL NOT create copyrighted characters or logos without express permission from the copyright owner. ANY AND ALL characters you see on Etsy, or any other website for sale (without a license) were created ILLEGALLY. This includes all characters from Disney, Nickelodeon, Mattel, and so forth. Beware when ordering such items. We will not break the law, so please do not ask, but do feel free to ask about alternatives.********

BULK & WHOLESALE ORDERS:
We are available for bulk quantities and wholesale orders. We do have order minimums and do not offer discounts on all items as some are labor intensive and/or have shipping restrictions. Please message us for details.
COLOR CHANGES:
For simple color changes, you may use original listings and put color choice(s) in notes section during checkout.

CUSTOM ORDERS:
Please send us a message to inquire about a custom order or larger quantities than what is available on our shop.

For different quantities or designs we do not currently offer in our store, we will create a special listing specifically for your items and you will have 3 days to place your order. If order is not placed within 3 days, listings will be removed.
(Sellers are charged a fee to post ANY listing, so serious inquiries only, please.)

*******We are always up to new challenges and designs, however, we WILL NOT create copyrighted characters or logos without express permission from the copyright owner. ANY AND ALL characters you see on Etsy, or any other website for sale (without a license) were created ILLEGALLY. This includes all characters from Disney, Nickelodeon, Mattel, and so forth. Beware when ordering such items. We will not break the law, so please do not ask, but do feel free to ask about alternatives.********

BULK & WHOLESALE ORDERS:
We are available for bulk quantities and wholesale orders. We do have order minimums and do not offer discounts on all items as some are labor intensive and/or have shipping restrictions. Please message us for details.

Baseball Mitt Cookies (1 dozen)

Ask a question

$22.00+

Please select an option
Please select a quantity

Overview

  • Handmade item
  • Materials: flour, sugar, butter, vanilla, royal icing, salt, eggs
  • Made to order
  • Feedback: 392 reviews
  • Favorited by: 2 people
  • Gift message available
This shop accepts Etsy gift cards

Shipping & returns

Ready to ship in 2–3 weeks
From United States
Returns accepted
See return policy

What’s wrong with this listing?

The first thing you should do is contact the seller directly.

If you’ve already done that, your item hasn’t arrived, or it’s not as described, you can report that to Etsy by opening a case.

Report a problem with an order

We take intellectual property concerns very seriously, but many of these problems can be resolved directly by the parties involved. We suggest contacting the seller directly to respectfully share your concerns.

If you’d like to file an allegation of infringement, you’ll need to follow the process described in our Copyright and Intellectual Property Policy.

Review how we define handmade, vintage and supplies

See a list of prohibited items and materials

Read our mature content policy

The item for sale is…