Deluxe 5 Sugar Cat Toy Set

Deluxe 5 Sugar Cat Toy Set



In stock

Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Hooray! This item ships free to the US.



paper, cotton, organic catnip, fiberfil


How many sugars does your kitty use in her tea or coffee? One? Three? How about five?!

Well, you're in luck! This wonderful sugar cat toy set comes with one of each of our sugar packet cat toys.

You will receive:
1 White Sugar Cat Toy
1 Blue Sugar Substitute Cat Toy
1 Pink Sugar Substitute Cat Toy
1 Yellow Sugar Substitute Cat Toy
1 Brown Natural Sugar Cat Toy

Best of all, all five toys come packaged in an authentic New York City Coffee Cup!

Please see my shop polices for complete information.

All Polydactyl Cat Toys are protected under copyright law.
Copyright © 2010 Randi Warhol

Great care is used when sewing our toys: from using professional sewing machines to careful hand stitching. This fabric is custom designed specifically for Polydactyl. Many steps go into completing just one toy, making a Polydactyl toy a very unique toy!

★★★ Would you like to carry Polydactyl Brand toys in your store? We do wholesale! Contact us for more information: polydactylcats [!at] ★★★

Ready to ship in

1–2 business days


United States

Cost to ship


There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Returns and exchanges accepted
Exceptions may apply.

Meet your seller

Randi Warhol

Randi Warhol

Owner of PolydactylCats

Message Randi

916 reviews 5 out of 5 stars


Jillian Jun 28, 2019

5 out of 5 stars
Ordered these adorable sugar packets for my kitten and a pickle. Item took a couple of weeks to ship and once I contacted the seller they were shipped out right away. Upon arrival my package had an extra item in it which was a pack of peanuts toy. Very thoughtful of the seller to include an extra toys since the shipping took forever. Thank you and will look forward to purchasing from you again!!

Purchased item:

Scott Dlouhy Apr 6, 2019

5 out of 5 stars
Adorable and well made. These were lost in my incoming mail at my apt complex, and when I asked the seller she happily provided all the necessary info and helped track it.
I’ll get more once my kitten gets an affinity to catnip!

Purchased item:

Judy Mar 18, 2019

5 out of 5 stars
This is adorable! Cute catnip sugar set and a cup in purrfect condition. Well packed for shipping. I will be ordering more from this shop for sure.

Purchased item:

sudsappeal Jan 10, 2019

5 out of 5 stars
Could a catnip toy get more clever than a 5-pack in a classic takeout coffee cup??? NO! Great quality and even the crimped edge detail is captured. I may give this one as a gift. Thanks so much!!

Purchased item:

Explore related categories & searches