Tooth Fairy Pillow

Tooth Fairy Pillow



In stock

Please select a style
Please select a color
Please select a quantity
Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Nice choice! Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

Gift wrapping available.

See details

Gift wrapping by KathleenLH

I'll happily wrap your item in tissue & include a handwritten note for free, just let me know. Fancy gift wrap with cards & bows is available too!

  • Handmade
  • Materials: Fabric, Felt, Stabilizer, Ribbon, Thread, Stuffing

Losing teeth is a milestone in any kid's life. Let your little darling deliver his or her tooth in style with a custom made Tooth Fairy Pillow!

You've got options! The kid(s) in your life are totally unique individuals and they deserve a totally unique tooth fairy pillow to make the exchange of tooth for cash. A small (4x4) organza gift bag (random color) will be included so the tooth fairy has a place to stash all those teeth with the parent(s) while the kiddo hangs onto the pillow or stuffie. After it's all done, you've both a keepsake!

Choose a straight up white tooth stuffie with a pocket on the back in the color of your choice. This little stuffie doesn't really have room for a name, but a custom embroidered fabric name tag on a ribbon hanger can be attached ($1 additional charge) if you like! Overall, he measures about 7.25" across and 7.5" high. He's lightly stuffed with allergen free polyfil. Back pocket is about 3.25" across and 2.5" deep.

You may also choose a cute little 3-eyed monster with a pocket on his tummy in the color of your choice -- you can choose the monster's color too! This little stuffie does not have room for a name, but a custom embroidered fabric name tag on a ribbon hanger can be attached ($1 additional charge) if you like! Overall, he measures about 5" across and a bit over 7" high. He's moderately stuffed with allergen free polyfil. His tummy pocket is about 2.5" across and 2" deep.

Or choose a pillow -- with or without a ribbon hanger -- in your choice of more than 30 different embroidered and/or appliquéd patterns on the fabric color(s) of your choosing.

You can even choose a boy or a girl monster head pillow with a pocket in its mouth! Want your monster on plush? Let me know & I'll hook you right up!

Both styles of tooth fairy pillows (regular pillows or monster pillows) are custom made and can be personalized with your child's name or short message directly onto the pillow. You can also opt for a custom embroidered fabric name tag on a ribbon hanger ($1 additional charge) instead!

Regular pillows measure about 4.75" tall and 6.5" wide. Monster pillows measure about 5" x 7" ... all pillow styles are lightly stuffed with allergen free polyfil. Front pocket on the regular pillow is about 2.25" across and 2" tall. (Helpful hint: The tooth fairy won't have to reach under the pillows of sleeping kids to retrieve a pillow that's hanging on the door knob or a stuffie who's perched on the nightstand keeping watch!)

PLEASE NOTE: If you do not specify designs and/or colors, I will pick for you and coordinate accordingly! :)

Contact me for PDFs which show the different designs (one for the tooth with different faces, another for the pillow designs).

Your Tooth Fairy Pillow is shipped to you in a large envelope via USPS first class mail. Teeth, change and paper bills not included.

Rate this description

Did you find the above description useful? Let Etsy know.


Estimated arrival

The estimated delivery date is based on your purchase date, the recipient's location (actual or inferred), the seller's processing time and location, and the shipping carrier.

Other factors—such as shipping carrier delays or placing an order on weekend/holiday—may push the arrival of your item beyond this date.

Learn more

Apr 16-28

Apr 10

Order placed

After you place your order, KathleenLH will take 1-10 business days to prepare it for shipment.

Apr 12-23

Order ships

KathleenLH puts your order in the mail.

Apr 16-28


Estimated to arrive at your doorstep Apr 16-28!



Exceptions may apply

There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Ships from Dayton, OH
Kathleen Helms

Kathleen Helms

Owner of KathleenLH

Message Kathleen

This seller usually responds within 24 hours.

93 shop reviews

5 out of 5 stars

Cindy Robinson Mar 31, 2014

5 out of 5 stars

This was made for my memere who is in a nursing home and that I am unable to visit. She absolutely Loved it. The stitching of the name in the font chosen was beautifully done and the angel in her purple gown which is my mems favorite color was absolutely gorgeous!! Such thought went into making this and it made someone very special to me very happy. This is why having a creative person like Kathleen do this for me made it even more perfect. Made with Love!!

Purchased item:

Jeanette Thompson Dec 3, 2015

5 out of 5 stars

Like everything she does, my tree skirt came out absolutely stunning. She managed to do exactly what I asked her to do and yet make it a thousand times better.

Purchased item:

caitlynpichette22 Feb 25, 2014

5 out of 5 stars

I was super excited to receive these personalized cup sleeves! Kathleen did an AMAZING job designing each one and picking out the perfect embellishments to complement the individual themes. I’m thrilled with the quality and cannot wait to present them to my friends! The price was great and shipping was fast! The only problem I have now is trying to figure out what to order next! I will definitely be a repeat customer!

Purchased item:

Janna Kramer Feb 22, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

Stunning masterpiece!!!!! Cannot wait to hang this up in my modern medieval themed apartment!

Purchased item:

Disclaimer: As with all children's products, adult supervision is required. Products that contain small parts may pose a choking hazard and should not be used by children under 3. Sellers are responsible for following applicable laws and regulations, including posting items with accurate labeling and warnings. Etsy assumes no responsibility for the accuracy, labeling, or content of sellers' listings and products. Always read labels, warnings, directions and other information provided with the product before using it. If you have questions, contact the seller by sending a Message. See Etsy's Terms of Use for more information