Whoa! You can't favorite your own shop.

Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Whoa! You can't favorite your own item.

Whoa! You can't add your own item to a list.

Add this item to a treasury!

You don't have any treasuries yet. Enter a title below to create one.

This item has been added.

View your treasury.

Mystery Monster

Like this item?

Add it to your favorites to revisit it later.
Request a custom order and have something made just for you.


Can't decide what newborn monster to get? Love surprises? Hate choosing? Then this listing is perfect for you!

I'll send you a special, made-to-order mystery newborn monster.
Newborns are about 3 inches tall by 3 inches wide.

You can make small suggestions such as "make it happy/sad/angry" or a favorite color or two (Please note I dont have every color fur on hand) but for the most part it will be a complete surprise!


5 out of 5 stars
Reviewed by ncbenoit621
5 out of 5 stars
May 26, 2018
I was so excited to meet my new monster, this is such a fun idea. : )
Mystery Monster

Reviewed by teadrinker99
5 out of 5 stars
Mar 16, 2018
Very cute. I bought one for me and my cat. The one I bought for my cat is expressionless so a friend came over and asked why my cat was wrestling with a tribble. Lol.
Mystery Monster

Reviewed by Briana Alaniz
5 out of 5 stars
Dec 7, 2017
Mystery Monster

Reviewed by Jessica Friedrichs
5 out of 5 stars
Jun 1, 2017
Mystery Monster


Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Mystery Monster

Ask a question



Ships from United States
This will be made just for you! Prep time varies. Contact the shop to find out when it will ship.

What’s wrong with this listing?

The first thing you should do is contact the seller directly.

If you’ve already done that, your item hasn’t arrived, or it’s not as described, you can report that to Etsy by opening a case.

Report a problem with an order

We take intellectual property concerns very seriously, but many of these problems can be resolved directly by the parties involved. We suggest contacting the seller directly to respectfully share your concerns.

If you’d like to file an allegation of infringement, you’ll need to follow the process described in our Copyright and Intellectual Property Policy.

Review how we define handmade, vintage and supplies

See a list of prohibited items and materials

Read our mature content policy

The item for sale is…