Sugar Cookie Cream Pie

Sugar Cookie Cream Pie

$24.95

Loading

In stock

Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Arrives by May 15-18 if you order today.
Nice choice! Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.
May 15-18

The estimated delivery date is based on your purchase date, the recipient's location (actual or inferred), the seller's processing time and location, and the shipping carrier.

Other factors—such as shipping carrier delays or placing an order on weekend/holiday—may push the arrival of your item beyond this date.

Learn more

Gift wrapping available.

See details

Gift wrapping by SladeGrove

Please let us know what occasion the gift is for and we'll select a coordinated gift wrap to match including bow.

  • Handmade
  • Materials: cream, whole milk, butter, cane sugar, pure vanilla

Sugar Cookie Cream Pie is another one of Slade's award-winning pies that are a hometown tradition. An incredibly buttery rich sugar cream filling topped with a crunchy sugar in the raw topping all baked in a buttery sugared pie crust. Please refrigerate this pie until ready to serve. We personally prefer this pie served cold or at room temp with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream. We do not recommend heating this custard style pie as they can “melt” when heated.

Rate this description

Did you find the above description useful? Let Etsy know.

Loading

Estimated arrival

The estimated delivery date is based on your purchase date, the recipient's location (actual or inferred), the seller's processing time and location, and the shipping carrier.

Other factors—such as shipping carrier delays or placing an order on weekend/holiday—may push the arrival of your item beyond this date.

Learn more

May 15-18

May 7

Order placed

After you place your order, SladeGrove will take 3-4 business days to prepare it for shipment.

May 12-13

Order ships

SladeGrove puts your order in the mail.

May 15-18

Delivered!

Estimated to arrive at your doorstep May 15-18!

There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Ships from Peoria, AZ
Slade Grove

Slade Grove

Owner of SladeGrove

Message Slade

This seller usually responds within 24 hours.

192 reviews

5 out of 5 stars
Loading

Auliya Go Feb 22, 2021

4 out of 5 stars

These pies made it to Texas just after the week-long Texas power outage! We’ve only tried the pecan. Even after the long wait and crazy weather we found the packaging was still almost airtight, only a little gooey on the outside—and the pie was pretty perfect! If the pie can be this good after a weather-based delivery hiccup like this, we can imagine what they’d be pretty amazing when delivered in the usual time! We recommend!

Purchased item:

leigha86 Nov 28, 2020

5 out of 5 stars

Absolutely incredible. SladeGrove was amazing in answering all of my questions, and making the perfect pie for our Friendsgiving tradition. I will not hesitate to reorder.

Purchased item:

Meghan Nov 15, 2020

4 out of 5 stars

Pie was very yummy. I thought I was ordering a sugar cream pie and it is a bit different but all of it was eaten! 🥰

Purchased item:

Gerry Toney Nov 3, 2020

5 out of 5 stars

Alright folks, listen carefully, I purchased the bourbon pecan pie and the sugar cookie pie. THEY ARE HANDS DOWN THE BEST PIES I HAVE EVER EATEN. I have lived in New Orleans and Los Angles, and I have had wonderful pies, but NOTHING compares to these. Hands down the best, you have a new lifetime customer.

Purchased item:

Disclaimer: Sellers are responsible for following applicable laws and regulations and disclosing what is in their products. Etsy assumes no responsibility for the accuracy, labeling, or content of sellers' listings and products. Always read labels, warnings, directions and other information provided with the product before using or consuming it. If you have questions, contact the seller by sending a Message. See Etsy's Terms of Use for more information.