| 1,687 sales | 5 out of 5 stars

Calvin Coolidge Cookie Cutter

$10.00

Loading

Low in stock

Selling fast! Only 2 left, and 1 person has it in their cart.

Star Seller. This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.

Arrives by Dec 9-17 if you order today.
Hooray! This item ships free to the US.
Dec 9-17

The estimated delivery date is based on your purchase date, the recipient's location (actual or inferred), the seller's processing time and location, and the shipping carrier.

Other factors—such as shipping carrier delays or placing an order on weekend/holiday—may push the arrival of your item beyond this date.

Learn more

  • Handmade

Calvin Coolidge Cookie Cutter is a pretty sweet alliteration. As an actual likeness of Calvin Coolidge, though, it's ok. Not great, but ok.

**Please note: color may vary**

-

COOKIE CUTTER INFO:

- Our cookie cutters are 3 1/2 inches in diameter, which makes a pretty big cookie. (But not TOO big. If we ever come across a cookie that is too big, we’ll let you know.)

- Our cookie cutters are 3D-printed from plant-based PLA plastic, which means they're not dishwasher safe. (The dishwasher gets too hot.) That's good news, because it means you get to spend time hand-washing your cookie cutter with warm water and antibacterial soap. Just like in the pioneer days!

- If you would like to use this cookie cutter (rather than simply admire it), you will have to bake cookies. Sorry! You should use a recipe that doesn't spread or expand, because spreading and expanding are the enemies of cookie legibility. We've included a sample recipe below. But please note that we are professional cookie cutter craftspeople, not professional bakers.

2 sticks unsalted butter
1 c granulated sugar
1/2 c cornstarch
2 eggs (chicken eggs)
2 tsp vanilla extract
1 tsp lemon extract
3/4 tsp Kosher salt
3 1/2 c flour

1) Preheat oven to 375 degrees. (Importantly, we mean 375 Farhenheit. Please do NOT preheat your oven to 375 degrees Celsius.)

2) Cut butter into small cubes, then whip it with the sugar. Unless you're super strong and fast, you'll probably want to use a mixer for this.

3) Add eggs and vanilla and mix some more.

4) Add the cornstarch, flour, and salt, and mix EVEN MORE. Like, for four or five minutes, until the dough pulls away from the sides of the bowl and clumps into something that resembles spaetzle (look it up). You’re going to start thinking, “Why do we call these things COOKies when really we should call the MIXies,” and you will be absolutely correct.

5) Roll out dough on an ungreased cookie sheet to a 1/4 inch depth, and then (finally) you get to use your new cookie cutter. If you have problems with the dough sticking in the cookie cutter, try dusting it and the dough with flour, although you should avoid this if possible, because too much flour will dry out the dough.

6) Bake for as long as you can stand to wait, which will be 15 minutes-ish.

Loading

The estimated delivery date is based on your purchase date, the recipient's location (actual or inferred), the seller's processing time and location, and the shipping carrier.

Other factors—such as shipping carrier delays or placing an order on weekend/holiday—may push the arrival of your item beyond this date.

Learn more

Dec 9-17

Dec 4

After you place your order, PoisonCookieShop will take 3-5 business days to prepare it for shipment.

Dec 7-9

PoisonCookieShop puts your order in the mail.

Dec 9-17

Estimated to arrive at your doorstep Dec 9-17!

Cost to ship

Free

Etsy offsets carbon emissions from shipping and packaging on this purchase.
Etsy offsets carbon emissions from shipping and packaging on this purchase.
Returns & exchanges
Return & exchange window

Etsy Purchase Protection: Shop confidently on Etsy knowing if something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases — see program terms

There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Ships from Saint Louis, MO

Kate

Kate

Owner of PoisonCookieShop

Message Kate

This seller usually responds within a few hours.

305 shop reviews

5 out of 5 stars
Loading
5 out of 5 stars

Huzzah for the obscure presidents!

Purchased item: 

Calvin Coolidge Cookie Cutter

Callie Smith Feb 12, 2022

5 out of 5 stars

Purchased item: 

Calvin Coolidge Cookie Cutter

Izzi Jan 26, 2021

5 out of 5 stars

Can't wait to make some Calvin Coolidge Christmas Cookies.

Purchased item: 

Calvin Coolidge Cookie Cutter

Jason Esper Dec 14, 2021

5 out of 5 stars

The item shipped quickly and was just as expected! It was easy to wash and even has a little bag for me to keep it in, which I appreciate since I don’t want the cookie cutter to get bent/broken/et cetera. I used the included cookie recipe and made an entire batch of Grant cookies (which my friends all insist on calling Grookies, for…some reason). Definitely a great purchase, and I hope to buy some more cookie cutters in the future!

Alyssa Levin Jun 10, 2022

Disclaimer: Sellers are responsible for following applicable laws and regulations and disclosing what is in their products. Etsy assumes no responsibility for the accuracy, labeling, or content of sellers' listings and products. Always read labels, warnings, directions and other information provided with the product before using or consuming it. If you have any questions, message the seller. See Etsy's Terms of Use for more information.