Whoa! You can't favorite your own shop.

Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Whoa! You can't favorite your own item.

Whoa! You can't add your own item to a list.

Add this item to a treasury!

Close
You don't have any treasuries yet. Enter a title below to create one.
Close

This item has been added.

View your treasury.

Like this item?

Add it to your favorites to revisit it later.
Request a custom order and have something made just for you.
I know what you’re thinking. Do these cookies taste as good as they look?

ABSOLUTELY! And here’s why:

I’ve been making cookies since 2011 and one of the things I hear the most is how surprised people are with how great my sugar cookies taste. Unfortunately, us cookie eaters have been jaded by the unsavory treats that are mass produced and sold in big-box stores and vacation resorts. I have tried them, and you’re absolutely right, they’re not yummy at all. Which is why I can say that this is not the case with my sugar cookies. Not even close!

All of my cookies are baked fresh to order with homemade cookie dough and decorated by hand. There is no skimping out on ingredients and my cookies are baked just long enough so that they stay moist and chewy. The cookie dough itself has a delicious butter flavor that pairs up very nicely with the sweetness of a soft royal icing. When my royal icing dries it has a thin crunchy shell on the outside yet remains soft on the inside. This makes my sugar cookies the perfect treat for people of all ages; whether they have delicate teeth, a few teeth, no teeth — no problem!

We can all agree that party favors are a favorite for guests of all ages, but when it comes to picking out the perfect favor that won’t get lost or thrown in the trash my sugar cookies are guaranteed to do 2 things: make a memorable impression and get eaten.

Each listing comes with the following cookies:
- Qty (12) number "5" cookies [2" tall x 2" wide]
- Qty (12) number "0" cookies [2" tall x 2" wide]

Cookies will be wrapped by pairs in clear plastic bags for protection in the shipping transit and flavor preservation. The plastic bags comply with FDA regulations for food packaging and can be reused if you wish to add your own gift tags/ribbons.

All orders and ingredients are processed in a facility where all types of nuts, dairy, sesame and wheat products are handled. If you have any other food allergy concerns please do not hesitate to contact me. I can also provide a very detailed list of ingredients if needed.

Frequently asked questions about GuiltyConfections

My cookies are available in a variety of sizes. Be sure to check each listing's description for cookie measurements. Please note that the measurements of the cookies you receive might be a smidge smaller or larger.
All cookies will be wrapped in FDA approved bags that can be reused if you wish to add your own gift tags/ribbons. Some smaller cookies will be wrapped by pairs or three's, so if you need the cookies individually bagged let me know.
Wholesale/discounted pricing is not available.
I am unable to offer gluten-free cookies.
Each order is made in a kitchen that processes foods with eggs, all types of nuts, dairy, sesame and wheat products. If you have any questions about a particular ingredient please contact me.
Orders should be placed away to reserve a later ship date. My availability is limited and it is reserved on a first come first serve basis after payment has been received. If you have a very large order ($500 or more) I will accept a 50% downpayment to hold a reservation.
The minimum order quantity is 12 cookies but customers may purchase any even/odd number of cookies after the minimum.
All customers from Marietta requesting product pick up can meet me at a pre-determined location by the Marietta Square. Local pick-up orders will initially be charged shipping. Should the customer not arrive at the specified and agreed upon time within 15 minutes the cookies will be taken to the post office. Shipping will not be refunded and Guilty Confections will not be responsible for late delivery. If the customer arrives within 15 minutes of appointment time the shipping cost will immediately be refunded to the customer's original payment method.

Over the Hill Gifts / Over the Hill Party Favors / Gifts for Him / 50th Birthday Sugar Cookies - 12 paired sets

$27.00

Overview

  • Handmade item
  • Materials: unsalted butter, white granulated sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, baking powder, salt, all purpose flour, meringue powder, water, confectioners sugar, gel food coloring
  • Made to order
  • Only ships within United States.
  • Feedback: 454 reviews
  • Favorited by: 162 people