Whoa! You can't favorite your own shop.

Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Whoa! You can't favorite own item.

Whoa! You can't add your own item to a list.

Add this item to a treasury!

You don't have any treasuries yet. Enter a title below to create one.

This item has been added.

View your treasury.

Like this item?

Add it to your favorites to revisit it later.
Request a custom order and have something made just for you.
My unique and one-of-a-kind puppets and plush toys are made with 100% wool felt and are hand cut and sewn by me, each critter will be unique and made according to my whim unless you specify details. They are sure to be the inspiration for a lot of imaginative play or story telling fun for children or adults. The cute little monster is just the thing to keep your child's tooth safe until the Tooth Fairy arrives. He has a small pocket to keep the tooth in. I could put a pocket on any critter and any simple symbol on the pocket like a heart, a star, an initial, or something personal, convo me to discuss.

This listing is for one MADE TO ORDER finger puppet or stuffed plush toy that will be similar in size and detail to the ones shown here but designed for you. Choose one of the characters in the photos above, ask for variations on these or request a unique design of your own. You may request specific details like colors, type of critter and facial expression but you must let me know at the time of purchase (colors will depend on my current inventory, if I need to order materials it will increase turnaround time).

These toys are approx. 5-6 inches tall and 3-4 inches wide. Depending on the item you request all or part of the toy will contain wool stuffing or a poly-fil material (please let me know your preference) to make it extra cuddly and a bit more three-dimensional.

I can also make a set of mini puppets or plushies that would be excellent for a child’s birthday party. They could be given away as party favors, mounted on wooden sticks and used as (cup)cake toppers, or simply given as a gift. My plush characters also make excellent props for teachers, librarians, parents, and caregivers to extend learning activities or to enhance playtime. Please contact me to find out more about the sets that I can create and pricing.

Although I do list this item as a toy please be careful because these could pose a choking hazard for very young children. My plush felt critters are generally suitable for children over 3 (unless otherwise indicated) as they are carefully hand sewn. However, pieces can be detached if handled too much or roughly-supervision is always suggested for younger children.

Due to demand, most of my felt items are now made using 100% wool which is a very high quality and long lasting material perfect for children's toys and those seeking natural materials. I can however still make most any of my items out of wool blends and even synthetic felt for customers seeking a more budget friendly version.
Contact me with questions about pricing or for more information about these materials.

It generally takes me 1-2 weeks to complete one of these critters depending on my current workload. If you need your item by a particular date I would be happy to try to meet your deadline if possible. I can also send photos via email of the item before shipping to ensure that you will be satisfied with your purchase.

I ship via USPS with tracking when possible and please remember I do not begin or ship any orders until payment is received.

Thanks for supporting the handmade movement and Artsy Mommas!

100% Wool Plushie-Tooth Fairy Friend, Finger Puppet, or Simple Toy - Made to Order

$35.00 USD
Please select an option
Please select from the available options


  • Handmade item
  • Type of Critter: Request
  • Materials: felt, plush, sewn, embroidery, thread, stuffing, pocket, heart, monster, stich, red, wool, blend
  • Made to order
  • Ships worldwide from California, United States
  • Feedback: 40 reviews
  • Favorited by: 24 people