Whoa! You can't favorite your own shop.

Whoa! You can't buy your own item.

Whoa! You can't favorite your own item.

Whoa! You can't add your own item to a list.

Add this item to a treasury!

You don't have any treasuries yet. Enter a title below to create one.

This item has been added.

View your treasury.

Like this item?

Add it to your favorites to revisit it later.
Request a custom order and have something made just for you.
Meet Sherman the Tooth Fairy Pillow. Sherman has his degree in Criminal Justice. He was head of security at the Emerald Square Mall for 6 years before he took his current position as Tooth Fairy Pillow. He takes his new role very seriously; you can be sure that your tooth as well as the treasure the tooth fairy leaves behind is safe with Sherman!!

Sherman's mouth is a pocket that will carefully keep that tooth and the treat left by the tooth fairy safe for your little one.

This Sherman will be personalized or monogrammed for you; please be sure to add the name to the notes section at check out.

My tooth fairy critters are approximately 5 by 6 inches, made with blue and green anti pill polar fleece, button eyes and stuffed with poly fill. Each one is hand made especially for you. His eyes are buttons, so not safe for those little ones 3 and under. A button free version can be made for you if requested.

Personalized Critters can be made in a variety of colors. Please see my other listings for colors available.

All Kooky Critter Tooth Fairy Critters now come with an adorable Tooth Fairy Chart so you and your little one can keep track of when baby teeth fall out!

They are made in my smoke free studio.

International shipping rates are available upon request.

Kooky Critters are a proud member of Etsykids team. :)

All Critters are one of a kind and handmade by me. The designs are my own and protected by Copyright © Holly Sennott 2010-2016.

Thanks for looking!

Personalized Sherman the Tooth Fairy Pillow and Tooth Fairy Chart by Kooky Critters KCPOO2

Only 1 available
Please select from the available options


  • Handmade item
  • Materials: poly fill, buttons, polar fleece, embroidery thread
  • Made to order
  • Ships worldwide from United States
  • Feedback: 291 reviews
  • Favorited by: 134 people