ButFirstCustom

Utah, United States

3.8k
 Sales

4.9 (754)

2.5 years
on Etsy

4.9 (754)

3.8k
 sales

2.5 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

3.8k
 Sales

4.9 (754)

2.5 years
on Etsy

4.9 (754)

3.8k
 sales

2.5 years
on Etsy

Request Custom Order

Contact shop owner

3849 Sales

157 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

All items

Christian Gift For Christian, Religious Gift, Scripture Mug Gift For Sunday School Teacher, Fearless Christian Cup Bible Verse Christian Mug

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

Funny Mom Mug For Coworker Crazy Cat Mug Gift For Cat Lover Chaos Mug For Boss Birthday Gift Coworker Cat Lover Coffee Cup Boss Appreciation

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

Personalized Book Lover Gift For Fall Lover Bookish Gift For Reader Coffee Cup For Fall Lover Autumn Gifts For Coworker Girl Who Loves Books

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

Nurse Gifts For Nurse Funny Gift For RN Cat Lover Nurse Coffee Cup From Patient Custom New Nurse Life Gift Mug Nursing School Graduate Gift

Sale Price $9.59

Original Price $15.99 (40% off)

Personalized Floral Coffee Mug For Mom Custom Mom Mug With Kids Names Cute Flowers Mama Mug Mothers Day Gift For Mama From Kids Gift For Mom

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

New Mom Mug Gift For Mom Candy Mug Funny Parent Cup For First Time Mom Gift Future Mother Gift For Mothers Day New Baby Gift For Mother

Sale Price $16.19

Original Price $26.99 (40% off)

First Time Mom Gift Mug For New Moms Mug For New Parents Gift For Mama Christian Gift Idea For New Mother Personalized Baby Shower Gift

Sale Price $12.59

Original Price $20.99 (40% off)

Personalized Journal With Name Notebook Gift For Her Hardcover Lined Women's Diary Custom Mom Memory Journal For Daughter Figureoutable

Sale Price $18.34

Original Price $30.57 (40% off)

Personalized Wildflower Journal Custom Notebook Gift Idea For Woman Hardcover Diary Floral Gratitude Journal Bridesmaid Gift Mothers Day

Sale Price $18.34

Original Price $30.57 (40% off)

Personalized Bendiciones Diarias Journal With Cross For Religious Mexican Mujer Daily Blessings Floral Diary For Abuela Spanish Memory Book

Sale Price $17.14

Original Price $28.57 (40% off)

Personalized First Journal For Girls Custom Notebook Lined Journal For Girl Gift Idea For Daughter Granddaughter Notebook Hardcover

Sale Price $18.34

Original Price $30.57 (40% off)

Personalized Journal For Girls Custom Initial Notebook Lined Journal For Teen Girl Gift Idea For Daughter Young Kids Notebook Hardcover

Sale Price $18.34

Original Price $30.57 (40% off)

Baby Loss Gift, Custom Miscarriage Gift, Custom Infant Loss Remembrance, Baby Memorial Ceramic Ornament, Miscarriage Memorial For Angel Baby

Sale Price $11.99

Original Price $19.99 (40% off)

Custom Office Gift Exchange Christmas Ornament For Employees Funny Coworkers Ornament Office Gift For Office Staff Appreciation Ornament

Sale Price $11.99

Original Price $19.99 (40% off)

Personalized Bonus Mom Ornament Gift For Bonus Mom Gift Idea For Christmas Ornament For Step Mom Mothers Day Gift For Bonus Mom Wedding gift

Sale Price $11.99

Original Price $19.99 (40% off)

Custom Design Ornament With Company Logo Ornament For Coworkers Your Design Here Ornament With Personalized Text Logo Ceramic Ornament

Sale Price $11.99

Original Price $19.99 (40% off)

Custom Therapist Gift Idea For Doctor Coffee Cup Future Therapist Coffee Cup For Therapist Appreciation Gift For Doctor Graduation Gift

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

Personalized Grandma Glass Tumbler With Grandkids Names Gift Idea For Grandma Iced Coffee Cup Gift For Grandma Gift For Nana or Mimi Cup

Sale Price $5.76

Original Price $9.60 (40% off)

Sausage Dog Mug Gift For Dachshund Dog Coffee Cup Cute Gift For Doxie Lover Gift Idea Weiner Dog Coffee Cup Gift Mug Dachshund Lover Gift

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

Custom Cheerleader 40oz Tumbler With Handle Personalized Cheerleader Water Bottle With Name & Team Gift Idea For Cheer Coach Cheer Mom Gift

Sale Price $22.20

Original Price $37.00 (40% off)

Custom Cheer Mom 40oz Tumbler With Handle Personalized Gift Idea For Cheer Mom Water Bottle With Name & Photo Gift For Cheer Coach Gift

Sale Price $22.20

Original Price $37.00 (40% off)

Custom Physical Therapist Glass Tumbler Physical Therapist Gift Idea For PT Iced Coffee Cup Personalized Physical Therapist Glass Cup

Sale Price $5.76

Original Price $9.60 (40% off)

Personalized NICU Nurse Tote Bag Custom NICU Nurse Gift Idea With Name For NICU Department Tote Bag Nurse Appreciation Gift From Patient

Sale Price $12.59

Original Price $20.99 (40% off)

Custom Retro Pickleball Tumbler With Handle 40oz Pickleball Water Bottle Personalized Retro Gift Idea For Pickleball Player Cup With Name

Sale Price $22.20

Original Price $37.00 (40% off)

Custom Cheerleader 40oz Tumbler With Handle Personalized Cheerleader Water Bottle With Name & Team Gift Idea For Cheer Coach Cheer Mom Gift

Sale Price $22.20

Original Price $37.00 (40% off)

Personalized Girls Christmas Ornament Gift, Pink Christmas Tree Ornament, Ornament For Daughter, Baby First Christmas, Granddaughter Gift

Sale Price $11.99

Original Price $19.99 (40% off)

Christian Mug Gift For Christian Women Religious Gifts For Her Gift For Christian Gift Idea for Pastor Scripture Mug Christian Inspiration

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

40th Birthday Gift Custom Name Mug 40 Years Old Gift Turning 40 Glass Mug For Her Personalized Birthday Coffee Cup Gift Friend In My 40s Era

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

Personalized Pumpkin Glass Tumbler For Thanksgiving Custom Pink Pumpkin Ice Coffee Glass Fall Season Pumpkin Cup Gift Tumbler With Name

Sale Price $5.76

Original Price $9.60 (40% off)

Personalized Fall Tumbler, Custom Pumpkin Spice Ice Coffee Glass, Pumpkin Spice Glass Can, Autumn Glass Tumbler With Lid, Thanksgiving Gift

Sale Price $5.76

Original Price $9.60 (40% off)

Personalized Scripture Verse Glass Tumbler, Custom Bible Verse Flower Iced Coffee Cup, Gift For Christian Tumbler, Religious Glass Cup

Sale Price $5.76

Original Price $9.60 (40% off)

Personalized Gift For Mom With Kids Names Kids Gift For Mom Gift From Kids Personalized Mom Mug Mother Coffee Cup For Mama From Husband

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

Personalized Pomsky Ornament For Pomsky Owner Custom Pomsky Picture Ornament With Name Christmas Pomsky Gift Idea Gift For Pomsky Lover

Sale Price $11.99

Original Price $19.99 (40% off)

Personalized Thank You Gift For Teacher Thank You For Helping Me Grow Gift Ornament For Therapist or Teacher Ornament Keepsake From Student

Sale Price $11.99

Original Price $19.99 (40% off)

Custom Promoted To Grandma Mug Mothers Day Gift For New Grandma Pregnancy Announcement Personalized New Grandmother Coffee Cup For Grandmom

Sale Price $12.99

Original Price $21.65 (40% off)

Personalized Witch Ice Coffee Cup, Spooky Witchy Woman Glass, Witchy Woman Glass Can, Gift For Halloween Glass Tumbler With Witch Hat Bats

Sale Price $5.76

Original Price $9.60 (40% off)

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Dec 11, 2025

HOLIDAY ORDERING DEADLINES! Please place all your orders by December 10 with regular shipping and December 12th with priority shipping. You still may get your order if ordered a day or two after these deadlines, but better to be safe than sorry :)

Welcome to But First...Custom, the place to find personalized, unique gifts that are perfect for gifting to friends and family.

📦 Our products usually ship out between 2-5 business days from when we receive your order.
🎄Cutoff date for Christmas arrival: December 8th, 2025.
💡We are always innovating and coming up with new products so please watch out for our new launches!

Here are our main product categories, but if you can't find something you are looking for just message us!

SKINNY TUMBLERS:
https//www.etsy.com/your/shops/me/tools/listings/section:44644664,stats:true

ORNAMENTS: https://www.etsy.com/your/shops/me/tools/listings/section:46162368,stats:true

FROSTED GLASS CUPS: https://www.etsy.com/your/shops/me/tools/listings/section:49153367,stats:true

CERAMIC & GLASS MUGS: https://www.etsy.com/your/shops/me/tools/listings/section:53173864,stats:true

40oz. TUMBLERS WITH HANDLES
https://www.etsy.com/your/shops/me/tools/listings/section:53891734,stats:true

Contact shop owner

But First...Custom

Reviews

4.9 (754)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Veronica on Jul 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

My sister loved her new cup!

Funny Mug For Coworker Chaos Coordinator Raccoon Mug Gift For Coworker Sarcastic Coffee Cup For Coworker Birthday Gift For Coworker Work Mug

Funny Mug For Coworker Chaos Coordinator Raccoon Mug Gift For Coworker Sarcastic Coffee Cup For Coworker Birthday Gift For Coworker Work Mug
Amy on Jun 23, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great gift for a ballet teacher! Super cute!

Ballet Teacher Gift, Dance Teacher Ice Coffee Cup, Ballerina Glass, Gift For Dance Teacher, Ballet Dance Coach, Dance Studio Owner Gift

Ballet Teacher Gift, Dance Teacher Ice Coffee Cup, Ballerina Glass, Gift For Dance Teacher, Ballet Dance Coach, Dance Studio Owner Gift
Melora on Jun 8, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Everything went perfectly with the personalization and shipping.

Lawyer Mug For Attorney Funny Gift For Lawyer From Client Esquire Gift Custom New Lawyer Gift Attorney Mug Law School Graduate Gift Advocat

Lawyer Mug For Attorney Funny Gift For Lawyer From Client Esquire Gift Custom New Lawyer Gift Attorney Mug Law School Graduate Gift Advocat
Anne-Barbara on May 31, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great gift for a new job

Lawyer Mug For Attorney Funny Gift For Lawyer From Client Esquire Gift Custom New Lawyer Gift Attorney Mug Law School Graduate Gift Advocat

Lawyer Mug For Attorney Funny Gift For Lawyer From Client Esquire Gift Custom New Lawyer Gift Attorney Mug Law School Graduate Gift Advocat
Mary on May 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

DIL loved it and the color was perfect

Bonus Mom Coffee Mug Bonus Mom Gift For Mothers Day Gift For Bonus Mom Cup For Bonus Mom Personalized Gift From Bonus Daughter Step Mom Gift

Bonus Mom Coffee Mug Bonus Mom Gift For Mothers Day Gift For Bonus Mom Cup For Bonus Mom Personalized Gift From Bonus Daughter Step Mom Gift
Tee on May 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Really love everything I have bought from this store and the seller is amazing!

Spooky Vegan Shirt

Spooky Vegan Shirt
Connie on May 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Very cute mug! Owner was quick to respond to questions.

Lawyer Mug For Attorney Funny Gift For Lawyer From Client Esquire Gift Custom New Lawyer Gift Attorney Mug Law School Graduate Gift Advocat

Lawyer Mug For Attorney Funny Gift For Lawyer From Client Esquire Gift Custom New Lawyer Gift Attorney Mug Law School Graduate Gift Advocat
Marjorie on Apr 28, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Bought it as a gift and she loved it

Best Friend Ornament, Personalized Gift For Best Friend Moving Away, Friendship Christmas Gift For Best Friend, Bestie Gift, BFF Gift

Best Friend Ornament, Personalized Gift For Best Friend Moving Away, Friendship Christmas Gift For Best Friend, Bestie Gift, BFF Gift
Shivani on Apr 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

The owner is extremely nice and accommodating. Loved the mug as well! Will definitely from here again!

Lawyer Mug For Attorney Funny Gift For Lawyer From Client Esquire Gift Custom New Lawyer Gift Attorney Mug Law School Graduate Gift Advocat

Lawyer Mug For Attorney Funny Gift For Lawyer From Client Esquire Gift Custom New Lawyer Gift Attorney Mug Law School Graduate Gift Advocat
Tee on Apr 13, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Very cute shirt and feels high quality ! Love that the seller was able to create what I wanted.

Unisex Jersey Short Sleeve Tee

Unisex Jersey Short Sleeve Tee

About ButFirstCustom

We create personalized products perfect for gifting!

Sales 3,849

On Etsy since 2023

We create personalized products perfect for gifting!

Hi, I’m Flory – welcome to my shop!

🌄 I live in beautiful Utah, where the mountains are always just a short drive away. My husband works in construction, and after moving around quite a bit during our 35 years of marriage, we’re finally happy to call this place home. We have five amazing grown kids -- and not enough grandbabies -- and while most have flown the nest, our son Glen (who has Down syndrome) keeps life joyful and full of love right here with us. He’s the heart of our family and adores spending time with his four sisters.

💝 I started this Etsy shop as a way to support my family while staying home to care for Glen. Creating has always brought me joy, and I wanted to pour that energy into designing keepsake gifts that make your life easier and more meaningful. My goal is to offer quality, personalized pieces that feel special, thoughtful, and one-of-a-kind gifts you’ll be proud to give and treasures that can’t be found in big-box stores.

🎨 I absolutely love working on custom requests, so if you have something special in mind, just reach out! I typically reply within a couple of hours (Etsy messaging is the fastest since it pings me right away).

🌸 I’m so grateful for my wonderful customers who trust me with their gifts, and I’d love for you to peek at the reviews to see their experiences. Thanks for being here—I can’t wait to create something memorable just for you!

🔥 Here are links to a couple of my bestsellers if you'd like to take a gander:
https://www.etsy.com/listing/1769445627/personalized-new-grandparents-ornament
https://www.etsy.com/listing/1799386566/personalized-girls-christmas-ornament
https://www.etsy.com/listing/1734121871/christian-affirmation-iced-coffee-cup
https://www.etsy.com/your/shops/me/listing-editor/edit/4333952406

🙏 Psst… you made it all the way to the end! As a little thank-you for stopping by and taking the time to get to know me, I’d love to give you a special discount code to use in my shop. Because who doesn’t love a sweet surprise? 🎉

🎁 https://butfirstcustom.etsy.com?coupon=HAPPY60

Shop members

But First...Custom

Owner

Hi! I am a mom of 5 and grandma of 5 :) I have a love for grandbabies and dogs!

Production partners

Inner Circle Prints

WA, United States

They help me with printing my design on the prodcut.
NS ECommerce

Las Vegas, NV

Prints my products

More production partners

Printify

United States

Does all of my printing

Shop policies

Last updated on Nov 26, 2023

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 2 hours of purchase

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Do you accept custom or personalized orders?

Of course! Got an idea or a logo? Let’s make it real! We’ll whip up a mock-up just for you and tweak it ’til it’s perfect. During busy seasons we just ask for a quick 24-hour thumbs-up so we can keep your order on track.

During peak seasons, we reserve the right to enforce a 24 hour review period. When we send a mockup, we will kindly ask that you respond within 24 hours. If we do not hear back, we will proceed with our best option.

Do you accept returns or exchanges?

Since everything we make is custom just for you, we’re not able to take returns or exchanges. If you’ve got special requests, just drop us a message while ordering—we love making it exactly how you want it!

Do you offer Priority Shipping?

You bet! Just choose Priority Shipping at checkout if you need your order by a certain date. We will hustle hard to get your order to the printer and regular processing times still apply here, but once it’s in USPS hands, delivery speed is up to them.

What if I receive my product damaged?

If you receive your item(s) damaged due to shipping, please contact us right away! We are happy to send you a new product free of charge. We will just ask that you provide us a picture of the damaged item(s).

Do you provide gift messaging?

We don’t offer gift messages just yet—so leaving a “note to seller” won’t make it into the package. If you’d like your recipient to know something special is on the way, we suggest reaching out to them directly.

Hopefully we’ll have gift messages as an option soon!

What are your processing times?

We do our best to keep processing times at just 1–2 days year-round! During busy holidays (like Mother’s Day & Christmas), it may take a little longer.
For the latest updates, be sure to check our shop announcements or the estimated delivery date in your cart.

What if my package is delayed/lost in transit, or stolen, or returned to sender/seller after it's shipped?

But First...Custom is not liable for packages that are delayed in transit, lost by the
shipping carrier, or stolen-- all circumstances which are beyond our control. Once we
hand your item over to the shipping carrier it is their responsibility to deliver the
item-- please contact the shipping carrier directly regarding delays or lost packages.
If a customer's order is returned to the sender/seller for ANY reason the customer is
responsible for paying for re-shipment.

If a sale starts after I place my order will you refund the difference?

The price paid is the price of the item at the time of your order. For example, if the item is in a 10% off sale a week after you order we do not go back and refund all previous customers that 10% off amount.