On January 24, 2015, Cameron and I went into business together and opened up our very own Etsy store! It took about 48hrs to come up with a name that utilized two “C” words (mirroring our names) that hadn’t already been taken. After much pondering and racking of the brain, the result was “CreatedCococtions” by Cameron and Caitlin Neace. We launched CreatedConcoctions on a Saturday evening and sold our first item that very same day!

We were greatly encouraged to open our store and we’re so happy we did. After all, if we were making these creations anyways, why not try and sell them? We started out with knitted baby hats and earmuff headbands, then added Scrabble magnets, had a brief dabble in watercolor pieces and downloadable cards, added burlap signs and ended with embroidered aprons. But our shop really took off when Cameron discovered woodburning! I can’t tell you how many evenings were spent woodburning, staining, and sealing signs! 😊

CreatedConcoctions helped us make ends meet while we were at the Missionary Training school in Missouri and supplied Christmas funds both years we were in Indiana! It was truly a blessing!

As our lives have continued to change and different priorities have arisen, we feel it best to close this chapter for Created Concoctions and what better time than at the start of a brand-new year.

Your support and encouragement these last five years with Created Concoctions has meant so much to us!

Contact shop owner

Cameron and Caitlin Neace

Reviews

5.0 (143)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Kathy on 26 Jan, 2020

5 out of 5 stars

Just the perfect little hat for a new baby! Fast delivery ..!

READY TO SHIP Baby Hat Knitted “Dusty Denim ” in Blue with Rolled Brim, newborn photo prop pompom, knit newborn, newborn props, baby shower

READY TO SHIP Baby Hat Knitted “Dusty Denim ” in Blue with Rolled Brim, newborn photo prop pompom, knit newborn, newborn props, baby shower
Dana on 29 Dec, 2019

5 out of 5 stars

Amazing! I purchased a sign on a Friday night for my brother, and almost immediately received a reply from Caitlin and Cameron. We conversed about what I wanted, and I sent them a few photos to take bits and pieces from. I received the sign in about a week and it is absolutely perfect. My brother loves it and it is very realistic. Would purchase again in a heartbeat.

CUSTOM Boat Wood Burned Sign from Your Photo, New Boat Owner, Personalized, Ship, Sailing, Sailor, Fishing, Fisherman, Captain, Navy, Tug

CUSTOM Boat Wood Burned Sign from Your Photo, New Boat Owner, Personalized, Ship, Sailing, Sailor, Fishing, Fisherman, Captain, Navy, Tug
Shalynn on 22 Apr, 2019

5 out of 5 stars

I ordered the wooden “As I sit in Heaven” wall decor. As we are about to “celebrate” Mother’s Day for the first time without my mom, I wanted to get something special for my step-dad, (Dad). I hope it eases some of his pain. The wooden piece is exactly as shown and described. It delivered quite quickly, and I’m so pleased. Thank y’all so much!!!!

REMEMBRANCE "As I Sit in Heaven" Wood Burned Sign, Funeral, Loss of Parent, Mom Dad, Grandparent, Spouse, Child, Death, Mourning, Grief, Sad

REMEMBRANCE "As I Sit in Heaven" Wood Burned Sign, Funeral, Loss of Parent, Mom Dad, Grandparent, Spouse, Child, Death, Mourning, Grief, Sad
Caitlin on 13 Feb, 2019

5 out of 5 stars

My husband loved his Christmas gift! Quality customer service and quick responses. Beautiful, authentic workmanship. I highly recommend!

AIRCRAFT CARRIER “Fair Winds and Following Seas” Wood Burned Sign, Navy, Marines, Air Force, Jet Planes, Coast Guard, Veterans Military

AIRCRAFT CARRIER “Fair Winds and Following Seas” Wood Burned Sign, Navy, Marines, Air Force, Jet Planes, Coast Guard, Veterans Military
Nini on 31 Dec, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

Perfect gift for my sister in law for Christmas. She loved it! Absolutely beautiful work.

WINNIE the POOH and PIGLET “I don't feel very much like Pooh today” A.A. Milne Quote Disney Wood Burned Sign

WINNIE the POOH and PIGLET “I don't feel very much like Pooh today” A.A. Milne Quote Disney Wood Burned Sign
Kimberly on 23 Dec, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

I absolutely LOVED this. Excellent quality and more beautiful than in the photos. I bought this as a gift for someone very special to me and she was blown away! Thank you very much. God Bless you and all who are reading this.

CUSTOM War Room PRAYER "This Means War" Wood Burned Sign, Personalized, Praying Hands, Philippians, Bible, Christian, Pastor, Christianity

CUSTOM War Room PRAYER "This Means War" Wood Burned Sign, Personalized, Praying Hands, Philippians, Bible, Christian, Pastor, Christianity
Mike on 18 Dec, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

Did a custom design and loved it. Cameron & Caitlin do quality work. The communication and response was very professional and timely. My purchase arrived right on time. I will be ordering again from this two. Thanks so much!

WINNIE the POOH and PIGLET “If there ever comes a day where we can't be together” A.A. Milne Quote Disney Wood Burned Sign, Graduation

WINNIE the POOH and PIGLET “If there ever comes a day where we can't be together” A.A. Milne Quote Disney Wood Burned Sign, Graduation
Travis on 09 Dec, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

This was a perfect gift for my cousin who lost her mother. It was very well done.

REMEMBRANCE "As I Sit in Heaven" Wood Burned Sign, Funeral, Loss of Parent, Mom Dad, Grandparent, Spouse, Child, Death, Mourning, Grief, Sad

REMEMBRANCE "As I Sit in Heaven" Wood Burned Sign, Funeral, Loss of Parent, Mom Dad, Grandparent, Spouse, Child, Death, Mourning, Grief, Sad
Lisa on 29 Nov, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

Thank you for my beautiful sign! It came out perfect and I can’t wait to display it :)

CUSTOM Wood Burned Sign of YOUR HANDWRITTEN Note, Anniversary, Grandparents, Wedding, Bridal Shower, Rememberance, Personalized Unique

CUSTOM Wood Burned Sign of YOUR HANDWRITTEN Note, Anniversary, Grandparents, Wedding, Bridal Shower, Rememberance, Personalized Unique
Michelle on 29 Nov, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

I loved that I could customize my order and that the sample you send via email, you had many different versions. This shop responded immediately and I received this on time. Thank you so much.

MICKEY MOUSE "It Was All Started By A Mouse" Walt Disney Quote Wood Burned Sign, Disney World, Disneyland, Inspirational, Motivational, Boss

MICKEY MOUSE "It Was All Started By A Mouse" Walt Disney Quote Wood Burned Sign, Disney World, Disneyland, Inspirational, Motivational, Boss

About CreatedConcoctions

Created Concoctions by Cameron and Caitlin Neace

Sales 440

On Etsy since 2015

Created Concoctions by Cameron and Caitlin Neace

The Founding of CreatedConcoctions

On January 24, 2015, Cameron and I went into business together and opened up our very own Etsy store! We launched CreatedConcoctions on a Saturday evening and sold our first item that very same day! We were greatly encouraged to open our store and we're so happy we did. After all, if we were making these creations anyways, why not try and sell them? We started out selling knitted baby hats, earmuff headbands and downloadable cards with plans for adding even more to our store as time went on and boy have we!

How did we pick the name "CreatedConcoctions" you ask? Well, it took about 48hrs to come up with a name that utilized two "C" words (mirroring our names) that hadn't already been taken. After much pondering and racking of the brain, the result was "CreatedCococtions" by Cameron and Caitlin Neace.

It would mean so much to us if you would share our Etsy store with your friends!

Instagram

Facebook

Shop members

Cameron and Caitlin Neace

Owner

We are newlyweds & owners of our Etsy store "CreatedConcoctions" through which we sell items we have created together! Caitlin also has a separate Etsy store called "AnEnchantedBox" for all your princess needs!

Shop policies

Last updated on 31 Oct, 2017

Delivery

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 12 hours of purchase

More information

Last updated on 17 Dec, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Custom and personalized orders

Always welcomed! We're constantly adding new items so if there is something you have in mind, let us know.

Unique and Handmade

All of our items are handcrafted and intentionally have those little indicators defining them as such. The "perfection" created by machines just leaves us cold. Since you are shopping on Etsy, we assume we are kindred spirits in this! We do our best to take photos that capture the actual colors of the item, but please realize that there may be some variation due to camera and computer monitor.

Reviews

If you are happy with your purchase, please take the time to review our store. You can post a review by logging into your Etsy account then, in the top right corner, click on Your Account >> Purchases and Reviews. If you have any issues with your purchase, please let us know before leaving feedback. It is very important to us that you be happy with your purchase!

Local Pick-Up

Orders are available for local pick-up from our home in the Butler, Pennsylvania area. If you would prefer this, simply include this in the "Note to Seller" at checkout and we will arrange a day and time for you to come by and pick-up your order. If you paid for shipping, the shipping costs will be refunded after you pick-up your order.

Do you accept returns?

All of our items are created when ordered therefore we do not accept returns. However, we do not want you to be disappointed, therefore will send you a photo of the completed item prior to shipping. Please be watching for it!

Shipping and Delivery

Please take note of the processing time of my items. This is NOT the same as the shipping time. This is the time needed to complete an order PRIOR to shipping. For details regarding the processing time, see listings as it varies depending on the item or refer to your order receipt for the "ship by date." We will always do our best to make and ship out your order as quickly as possible but please let us know if you have a specific deadline. We ship our items either USPS 2-3 Day Priority or USPS 1-2 Day Express - whichever is selected at checkout. Since we're not the one physically delivering your order, we can't guarantee the delivery date and are not responsible for USPS delays nor do we issue refunds or accept returns due to late delivery.