ButtrCuttr

Q: Custom and personalized orders

We offer customs!! Please just message or email us and we will walk you through the process :)

Missouri, United States

10.2k
 Sales

5.0 (1.2k)

3 years
on Etsy

5.0 (1.2k)

10.2k
 sales

3 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

10.2k
 Sales

5.0 (1.2k)

3 years
on Etsy

5.0 (1.2k)

10.2k
 sales

3 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

10190 Sales

2166 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Reviews

5.0 (1227)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Brianne on 21 Mar, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Fantastic! Very pleased with the quality

Trout Clay Cutter, Fish Clay Cutter, Summer Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutters, Individual or Mirrored Set Options

Trout Clay Cutter, Fish Clay Cutter, Summer Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutters, Individual or Mirrored Set Options
Cami on 02 Mar, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These little cutie cutters will make adorable ornaments and jewelry! Our whole family loves fishing! And I might even make some creative stuff, too. The cutters all matched the description and they are made of good quality material. (As far as shipping, I totally forgot they were coming! That's my bad!)

Trout Clay Cutter, Fish Clay Cutter, Summer Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutters, Individual or Mirrored Set Options

Trout Clay Cutter, Fish Clay Cutter, Summer Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutters, Individual or Mirrored Set Options
Etsy buyer on 11 Feb, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great cutter. Too cute. Thank you!

Butter Polymer Clay Cutter, Butter Stick Clay or Cookie Cutter, 1.5in and 3.5” options, Polymer Clay Ornament Cutter

Butter Polymer Clay Cutter, Butter Stick Clay or Cookie Cutter, 1.5in and 3.5” options, Polymer Clay Ornament Cutter
Wild on 07 Feb, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These are so cute and such nice quality!! They shipped so quickly and the packaging was also so so nice!

Butter Polymer Clay Cutter, Butter Stick Clay or Cookie Cutter, 1.5in and 3.5” options, Polymer Clay Ornament Cutter

Butter Polymer Clay Cutter, Butter Stick Clay or Cookie Cutter, 1.5in and 3.5” options, Polymer Clay Ornament Cutter
Elizabeth on 22 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Well package with excellent instructions for use. Will buy from this vendor again.

Bundle of 8 Funky Floral Clay Transfer Sheet, 4x5 inches, Groovy Clay Transfer, Polymer Clay Transfer Paper, polymer clay pattern

Bundle of 8 Funky Floral Clay Transfer Sheet, 4x5 inches, Groovy Clay Transfer, Polymer Clay Transfer Paper, polymer clay pattern
Tracy on 19 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great little fish cutter! I use ceramic clay, not polymer and it is just too small. But, the quality is excellent. My fault for not checking first and ordering too small. I do recommend this item though. Shipping on point, didn't need customer service.

Victoria responded on 20 May, 2026

Hi Tracy! Thank you for the kind review :) We will DM you to send something that will work for your ceramics! Thank you, Vic&Jared

Minnow Clay Cutter

Minnow Clay Cutter
Julia on 17 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

A+ quality customer service as always!

Victoria responded on 20 May, 2026

Always a pleasure to work with you on your custom ideas! :)

Custom Clay Cutter Inquiry, CUSTOM Polymer Clay cutter

Custom Clay Cutter Inquiry, CUSTOM Polymer Clay cutter
Tessa on 16 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

So perfect I can’t wait to use it!

Moth Clay Cutter, Symetrical, Polymer Clay Cutter, Bug Clay Cutter, Strong PLA Tough Cutter, Dangle Clay Cutters, Stud clay cutter

Moth Clay Cutter, Symetrical, Polymer Clay Cutter, Bug Clay Cutter, Strong PLA Tough Cutter, Dangle Clay Cutters, Stud clay cutter
Cathy on 16 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I never been so excited to get bass cutters. These will be a huge hit with the worms. Great quality and clean cutters

Bass Clay Cutter

Bass Clay Cutter
Cathy on 16 May, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I love how these minnows turned out. Great cutters. Super clean.

Minnow Clay Cutter

Minnow Clay Cutter

About ButtrCuttr

Polymer Clay Cutters and Tools

Sales 10,190

On Etsy since 2022

Polymer Clay Cutters and Tools

BUTTR CUTTR is all about family and community!

Hi, I’m Vic(toria) and I have been making polymer clay earrings since 2020. My husband and I decided to buy our first 3d printer in 2022 and we have been tirelessly working to build Buttr Cuttr ever since! We work just about every weeknight while our kids are sleeping to pack orders, design new cutters and brainstorm new ideas. We wish we could say this is our full time job, but Jared works 50+ hours at a car Restoration shop and I am busy raising two kids. We wouldn’t be here if it weren’t for the AMAZING community of the clay world. We love connecting with you guys through messages and Instagram. Thank you from the bottoms of our hearts for continuing to show up and support us.

Instagram

Shop members

Jared & Victoria

Owner

We are Vic and Jared! A husband & wife team who work to create fun and unique polymer clay cutters. We love the clay community so much and wouldn’t want to be anywhere else <3

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

More information

Last updated on 17 Dec, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Custom and personalized orders

We offer customs!! Please just message or email us and we will walk you through the process :)

Seller details

View shop registration details

ButtrCuttr

Featured items

Plant Leaf Clay Cutters, Dangle and Statement sizes, Stud size available under separate listing, Polymer Clay Cutters, Botanical Clay Cutter

WHOLE PETAL BUNDLE, 12 Petal Clay Cutters, 4 styles, Each in 5mm, 8mm, 12mm, Floral Clay Cutters, More grouping options in separate listing

THE WHOLE COLLECTION, Tswift Pt 2, Please read description for more details, Tswift Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutter

Plant Leaf Clay Cutters | Houseplant Clay Cutters | Dangle and stud Size Options | Polymer Clay Cutters | Botanical Clay Cutter | Spring

All items

Red Glasses Clay Cutter, Tswift Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay cutter, sunglasses Clay Cutter, Glasses Clay Cutter

Green flower with orange middle Clay Transfer Sheet, 4x5 inches, Groovy Clay Transfer, Polymer Clay Transfer Paper

Beetle Polymer Clay Cutter | Gothic Bug Scarab Clay Cutter | 3D Printed Embossed Cutter for Jewelry

Stacked books clay cutter, Tswift Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutter

Haunted House Polymer Clay Cutter | Spooky Halloween House Clay Cutter | 3D Printed Embossed Cutter

Butterfly Life Cycle Clay Cutter Set – 3D Printed Polymer Clay Tools – Caterpillar, Cocoon, Leaf & Butterfly Cutters

Two piece gingerbread house Clay Cutter, Two piece clay cutter set, One size, Christmas Clay cutter, Winter clay cutter

Star Polymer Clay Cutter – 3D Printed Clay Earring Tool – Celestial Starburst Jewelry Cutter

Plant Leaf Clay Cutters, Dangle and Statement sizes, Stud size available under separate listing, Polymer Clay Cutters, Botanical Clay Cutter

Salmon Clay Cutter

Bass Clay Cutter

Trout Clay Cutter, Fish Clay Cutter, Summer Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutters, Individual or Mirrored Set Options

Ghost Goose Polymer Clay Cutter | Spooky Goose in Ghost Costume Cutter in 2 Sizes | 3D Printed Embossed Clay Cutter for Jewelry

Butter Polymer Clay Cutter, Butter Stick Clay or Cookie Cutter, 1.5in and 3.5” options, Polymer Clay Ornament Cutter

Basic Circle Clay Cutter, Sizes .5 inches to 2 inches, increments of .25 inches, Basic shape sets available in separate listing

ORGANIC NO 4, Polymer Clay Cutter, Two size options, 1in, 1.5in

Butterfly Clay Cutter, Tswift Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutter

ORGANIC NO 15, Polymer Clay Cutter, Two size options, 1in, 1.5in

Round Donut Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutter, Individual or Mirrored, Three Sizes Available, Stud, Dangle, Statement

Cowboy Like Me, Tswift Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutter, Cowboy Boot Clay Cutter, Cowboy Hat Clay Cutter, Western Clay Cutter, Mirrored

Lightning Bolt clay cutter, Polymer Clay Cutter, 1.5 inch, mirrored set available

Spooky Conversation Heart Polymer Clay Cutter Set | “Bite Me” & “Spooky Babe” Heart Cutters | 3D Printed Embossed Clay Cutters

Polymer clay cutter, Organic shape clay cutter, Oval Clay Cutter, 3d Printed

Arched Window Polymer clay cutter, Organic shape clay cutter, Arched clay cutters, Pointed Arch cutter

Funky Flower with stem Dangle Set, Polymer Clay Cutter Set, Clay Dangle Sets, Funky Clay Cutter, 2 piece cutter set, mirrored flower option

Stamp Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutter, Two size options, 1in, 1.5in

Basic Square Clay Cutter, Sizes .5 inches to 2 inches, increments of .25 inches, Basic shape sets available in separate listing

Petal Cutter Sets, Four Styles, 3 different sizes available, 5mm, 8mm, 12mm, Floral Clay Cutters, More grouping options in separate listing

Spooky Moth Polymer Clay Cutter | Skull Moth Butterfly Clay Cutter in 3 Sizes | 3D Printed Embossed Cutter for Jewelry

ORGANIC NO 12, 1.25 in, Funky Polymer Clay Cutter, Organic Shape

Oval Spiderweb Clay Cutter, Halloween Clay Cutter Available in Two Sizes, Polymer Clay Cutter, Spooky Clay Cutter

Essential Arch Clay Cutter Set, Or Individual, Polymer Clay Cutter, Organic Arch Shape, 3d print clay cutters

Skinny Arch Clay cutter, polymer clay cutter, clay tool, earring tools, 3D print cutters, unique clay cutters, Funky clay tool

Worm Clay Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutter

Croissant Embossed Clay Cutter | Polymer Clay Cutter | Bread Clay Cutter | Spring Cutters | Bakery Clay Cutter | Coffee Shop Clay cutter

Fork and Spoon Clay Cutter, Individual or set, Picnic Clay Cutters, Polymer Clay Cutters

Reviews

About ButtrCuttr

Shop members

Jared & Victoria

Shop policies

Returns & exchanges

More information

Frequently asked questions

Custom and personalized orders

Seller details