FirstandPaper

New Jersey, United States

16.5k
 Sales

4.9 (2.9k)

7 years
on Etsy

4.9 (2.9k)

16.5k
 sales

7 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

16.5k
 Sales

4.9 (2.9k)

7 years
on Etsy

4.9 (2.9k)

16.5k
 sales

7 years
on Etsy

All 87
Placemats 51
Digital Downloads 30

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Nov 14, 2025

--------------------------------------------------------
FIRST + PAPER CONTACT INFO
--------------------------------------------------------

We will always do our best to get back to you within 24 hours of your message. With that being said, we're very busy gals and messages have become easy to miss. Please know we'll get to your requests as soon as possible, we promise!

Easiest way to reach us is here by message or through our website:
www.firstandpaper.com

We can't thank you enough for all of your continued support throughout the year and look forward to many exciting things to come!

So happy to be back :)
Loren + Nicole
First and Paper, LLC

www.firstandpaper.com
@first_and_paper

Contact shop owner

First and Paper

Reviews

4.9 (2908)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Jessica on Mar 28, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Super easy to download alot of great print outs that came in handy.

Pastel Teacher Planner Bundle- Digital Download Only - Lesson Plans - Classroom Forms - Undated Monthly /Daily - To do List - 105 Pages

Pastel Teacher Planner Bundle- Digital Download Only - Lesson Plans - Classroom Forms - Undated Monthly /Daily - To do List - 105 Pages
brooke on Mar 26, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

easy to use great product

Pastel Teacher Planner Bundle- Digital Download Only - Lesson Plans - Classroom Forms - Undated Monthly /Daily - To do List - 105 Pages

Pastel Teacher Planner Bundle- Digital Download Only - Lesson Plans - Classroom Forms - Undated Monthly /Daily - To do List - 105 Pages
Andrea on Mar 26, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

So cute and helpful! V

Easter Bulletin Board Letters- Digital Download Only - A-Z - Easter Patterns & Colors - Bold Font - Classroom Decor

Easter Bulletin Board Letters- Digital Download Only - A-Z - Easter Patterns & Colors - Bold Font - Classroom Decor
MyHappyPlace on Mar 23, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

my staff love the colors of the letters

Retro Summer Bulletin Board Letters- Digital Download Only - A-Z - Fun Colors & Patterns - Bold Font - Classroom Decor

Retro Summer Bulletin Board Letters- Digital Download Only - A-Z - Fun Colors & Patterns - Bold Font - Classroom Decor
Lenise on Mar 11, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is exactly what I was looking for to give to my granddaughter! Great quality, Quick shipping. Would purchase from again!

Personalized Kids Placemats - Princess Theme - Preschool Level Activities/ Kids Puzzles - Party Favor/Gift - Double Sided Placemat

Personalized Kids Placemats - Princess Theme - Preschool Level Activities/ Kids Puzzles - Party Favor/Gift - Double Sided Placemat
charnay on Feb 28, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is so helpful thank you!

Preschool Assessments - Digital Download Only - Ages 2-5 - Progress Report for Developmental Areas - Student Reports - Pastel colors

Preschool Assessments - Digital Download Only - Ages 2-5 - Progress Report for Developmental Areas - Student Reports - Pastel colors
Etsy buyer on Feb 27, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Adorable and functional placemat! My daughter has been having so much fun learning the states and capitals with this. Makes a great gift. Highly recommend!

Personalized Kids Placemats - USA - States and Capitals - Map of United States - Label your own map- Custom theme - Gifts

Personalized Kids Placemats - USA - States and Capitals - Map of United States - Label your own map- Custom theme - Gifts
Etsy buyer on Feb 27, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Love these adorable placemats! They make a great gift for the little ones in your life. The shop was so easy to work with and delayed my shipment at my request when I realized I’d be traveling when it would normally arrive. Highly recommend!

Personalized Kids Placemats - Multiplication Table - Activities/Kids Puzzles - Elementary Math - Educational - Double Sided Placemat

Personalized Kids Placemats - Multiplication Table - Activities/Kids Puzzles - Elementary Math - Educational - Double Sided Placemat
lauretta on Feb 25, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

So cute. My grandson loves it! Only issue, which was resolved once I contacted them, was getting tracking info.

Personalized Kids Placemats - Cars/Trucks - Activities/ Kids Puzzles - Preschool - Kindergarten - Party Favor/Gift - Double Sided Placemat

Personalized Kids Placemats - Cars/Trucks - Activities/ Kids Puzzles - Preschool - Kindergarten - Party Favor/Gift - Double Sided Placemat
Julie on Feb 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I specifically looked them up after getting my first child’s birth stat done back in 2021. 4 years later and they did just as amazing!

First + Paper: Custom Order (DYWB)

First + Paper: Custom Order (DYWB)

About FirstandPaper

First + Paper

Sales 16,508

On Etsy since 2018

First + Paper

Our Story

Hi, we're Nicole Sausville and Loren DiDiego and we love to create! Whether it be designing or crafting, baking, drawing or painting, we love it all. And after 20 years of being best friends and creating together, we're so excited to have opened our very own custom design shop!

First & Paper was started because we're always looking for new opportunities to be creative! Each and every item in our shop was designed with thought, care, and that handmade touch that makes the best occasions memorable! Feel free to email us about a custom project at FirstandPaper [!at] gmail.com :)

In our Etsy shop you'll find all things Party & Gift!
Visit our website to check out our custom-made, personalized invitations, hosting essentials, gifts and more: www.firstandpaper.com

Also, be sure to follow us on Instagram to see all our latest projects!
@first_and_paper

We hope you'll enjoy everything as much as we enjoyed creating it!
Loren & Nicole

shop-website

Instagram

Shop members

Loren DiDiego

Owner
Nicole Sausville

Owner
Taylor Stapleton

Director

Shop policies

Last updated on Sep 24, 2023

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Digital downloads

Instant downloads

Your files will be available to download once payment is confirmed. Here's how.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 6 hours of purchase

Privacy policy

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Can I customize an already existing poster?

Of course, please choose custom poster under the listing of the poster you're interested in and mention your requests in the personalization section when checking out. We'll follow up with a preview for your approval before moving onto the printing stage!

Can I order a custom item that I don't see in your shop?

Of course, we're happy to create something custom for you! Please message us for a custom link.

Can I order a custom college poster

Yes you can! Please choose custom poster under any college poster listing and mention your School of choice in the personalization section when checking out. Feel free to mention any specific references you'd like to see on your poster and we'll follow up with a preview for your approval before moving onto the printing stage!

Do I have to choose custom placemat if I want my child's name on it?

Nope. Our placemats include personalization. The custom option is for if you would like a new theme that we don't currently offer in our shop :)

Can I choose 3 different themes for a set of 3 placemats?

Yes! Please enter the theme and name for each placemat in the personalization section when choosing a set of 3. For example:
ABC - Loren
Rainbow - Nicole
Dinosaurs - Taylor

FirstandPaper

Featured items

Personalized Kids Placemats - Cursive Name/Retro - Activities/ Kids Puzzles - Preschool - Kindergarten - Party Favor/Gift - Double Sided

St. Patrick's Day Worksheets - Digital Download Only - Preschool - Letter Practice - Tracing - Counting - Matching - Cutting - Coloring

Valentine's Day Worksheets - Digital Download Only - Preschool - Letter Practice - Tracing - Counting - Matching - Cutting - Coloring

Pastel Teacher Planner Bundle- Digital Download Only - Lesson Plans - Classroom Forms - Undated Monthly /Daily - To do List - 105 Pages

All items

123 Bingo - Digital Download Only - Number Practice - Number Recognition - Bonus: Bulletin Board Numbers

First + Paper Rush Shipping

Thanksgiving/Fall Worksheets - Digital Download Only - Preschool - Letter Practice - Tracing - Counting - Matching - Cutting - Coloring

Christmas Worksheets - Digital Download Only - Preschool - Letter Practice - Tracing - Counting - Matching - Cutting - Coloring

Student Desk Tags - EDITABLE FILE With Canva - Digital Download Only - Playroom Pop Colors - Includes Shapes - Numbers - Letters and Name

Student Desk Tags - EDITABLE FILE With Canva - Digital Download Only - Retro Summer Colors - Includes Shapes - Numbers - Letters and Name

Happy Mail for Students - Digital Download Only - Brag About Your students! - 4 Colors - BONUS - Reward Chart

Pastel Teacher Planner Bundle- Digital Download Only - Lesson Plans - Classroom Forms - Undated Monthly /Daily - To do List - 105 Pages

Pastel Bulletin Board Letters- Digital Download Only - A-Z in 6 Pastel Colors - Bold Font - Classroom Decor

First + Paper - Custom Order (Placemats)

First + Paper - Custom Order (TV Show Posters)

Pastel Rainbow ABC + 123 Posters - Digital Download Only - 1-20 (x2) A-Z (x2) - Rainbow Colors & Patterns - Classroom Decor - Bonus Shapes

Pastel Rainbow Number Posters - Digital Download Only - 1-20 (x2) - Rainbow Colors & Patterns - Classroom Decor - Two sizes Per Letter

Pastel Rainbow Letter Posters - Digital Download Only - A-Z (x2) - Rainbow Colors & Patterns - Classroom Decor - Two sizes

Preschool Assessments & Report Card Bundle - Digital Download Only - Progress Report for Developmental Areas - Student Reports - Pastel

Preschool Assessments - Digital Download Only - Ages 2-5 - Progress Report for Developmental Areas - Student Reports - Pastel colors

Preschool Report Card - Digital Download Only - Ages 2-5 - Progress Report for Developmental Areas - Student Reports - Pastel colors

Rainbow Colors Bulletin Board Letters - Digital Download Only - A-Z - Rainbow Colors & Patterns - Classroom Decor

Back To School Theme Bulletin Board Letters - Digital Download Only - A-Z - Fun Colors & Patterns - Classroom Decor Images

Colors + Shapes Bingo - Digital Download Only - Color and Shape Recognition - Preschool Games - 12 Bingo Boards

Retro Summer Bulletin Board Letters- Digital Download Only - A-Z - Fun Colors & Patterns - Bold Font - Classroom Decor

Pastel Bulletin Board Letters- Digital Download Only - A-Z - Pastel Colors & Patterns - Bold Font - Classroom Decor

Easter Bulletin Board Letters- Digital Download Only - A-Z - Easter Patterns & Colors - Bold Font - Classroom Decor

ABC Tracing Worksheets V2 - Digital Download Only - A-Z Find the Letter, Trace, & Color - PreK/Kindergarten - Bonus Bulletin Board Letters

Easter/Spring Worksheets - Digital Download Only - Preschool - Letter Practice - Tracing - Counting - Matching - Cutting - Coloring

Valentine's Day Worksheets - Digital Download Only - Preschool - Letter Practice - Tracing - Counting - Matching - Cutting - Coloring

St. Patrick's Day Worksheets - Digital Download Only - Preschool - Letter Practice - Tracing - Counting - Matching - Cutting - Coloring

ABC Dot Dot Search Worksheets - Digital Download Only - A-Z Find the Letter & Trace - Preschool/Kindergarten - Bonus Bulletin Board Letters

ABC Tracing Worksheets - Digital Download Only - A-Z Find the Letter, Trace, & Color - Preschool/Kindergarten - Bonus Bulletin Board Letters

Holiday Bingo - Digital Download Only - Preschool + Kindergarten Games - Classroom Games

ABC Bingo - Digital Download Only - Letter Practice - Letter Recognition - Bonus: Bulletin Board Letters

123 Play-Doh Mats - Digital Download Only - Number Practice - Number Tracing - Bonus: Bulletin Board Numbers

ABC Play-Doh Mats - Digital Download Only - Letter Practice - Letter Tracing - Bonus: Bulletin Board Letters

First + Paper: Custom Order (DYWB)

First + Paper - Custom Order - City/College Collages

Personalized Kid's Placemats - Bluey Christmas - Activities/Puzzles - Preschool - Kindergarten - Party Favor/Gift - Double Sided

Announcement

Reviews

About FirstandPaper

Shop members

Loren DiDiego

Nicole Sausville

Taylor Stapleton

Shop policies

Shipping

Customs and import taxes

Digital downloads

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations

Privacy policy

More information

Frequently asked questions

Can I customize an already existing poster?

Can I order a custom item that I don't see in your shop?

Can I order a custom college poster

Do I have to choose custom placemat if I want my child's name on it?

Can I choose 3 different themes for a set of 3 placemats?