The Casey BarberSHOP

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

CaseyBarberSHOP is taking a short break


Note from shop owner The Etsy outpost of The Casey BarberSHOP is closed. For our full line of cards, enamel pins, and other gift items, please visit The Casey BarberSHOP flagship store at

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Jul 29, 2019

The Etsy outpost of The Casey BarberSHOP is closed. For our full line of cards, enamel pins, and other gift items, please visit The Casey BarberSHOP flagship store at


Contact shop owner



No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:
Quality 60 Shipping 93 Customer service 7

About CaseyBarberSHOP

Sales 3,545
On Etsy since 2010

See more at The Casey BarberSHOP -!

The Etsy outpost of The Casey BarberSHOP offers **a limited selection** of Hamilton-inspired greeting cards and prints. For the full range of Hamilton items and more pop culture-inspired products, including enamel pins, buttons, stickers, and more, please visit HTTPS://SHOP.CASEYBARBER.COM.

Take a look at the slideshow above to see how I create each piece—from pencil sketch to watercolor painting to finished print or card.

Shop members

  • Casey

    Owner, Yinzer

    You know that friend who's always quoting '80s movies and binge-watching 10 shows at once? Yeah, that's me. In addition to running The Casey BarberSHOP, I'm a food writer & photographer. For my food-related work, please see

Shop policies

Last updated on February 9, 2018
Welcome to the Etsy outpost of The Casey BarberSHOP! For the complete selection of pop culture-inspired products, please visit The Casey BarberSHOP flagship site at

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept cancellations
Request a cancellation within: 6 hours of purchase
I don't accept returns or exchanges
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
Returns and exchange details
The Casey BarberSHOP does not offer refunds or exchanges on items once they have been shipped. If you would like to exchange your order for items of equivalent value before they are shipped, please contact me within 6 hours of purchase.

If your item arrives damaged, please take clear photos of the damage as proof for insurance purposes, and contact me to initiate a refund or replacement.
Payment is accepted via Etsy Direct Checkout, which accepts all major credit cards as well as PayPal.

For additional help with checkout:

If you would like to cancel an order, please contact me within 6 hours of purchase. I can't guarantee I'll be able to honor requests for cancellation sent after this time period.
Make sure to double-check your shipping address when placing your order. I do not offer replacements or refunds on lost or delayed items for which the buyer specified an incorrect or unconfirmed address. If you’ve already placed an order with an incorrect shipping address, please contact me within 8 hours of purchase to correct it.

Once payment has cleared, orders typically ship 1-3 business days after purchase. All items are shipped from New Jersey via USPS. Delivery times vary, but USPS estimates its shipping times as follows for US addresses:
PRIORITY MAIL EXPRESS: 1-2 business days
PRIORITY MAIL: 1-3 business days
FIRST CLASS PACKAGE: 2-5 business days

To check the estimated delivery of a Priority Mail package, you can use the USPS Priority Mail Delivery Map with the origin zip code of 07015.

You will receive a tracking number with your shipping confirmation email. **PLEASE USE THIS TRACKING NUMBER TO MONITOR DELIVERY OF YOUR PACKAGE.** I am not responsible for shipping delays caused by USPS and cannot expedite packages in transit. Once an order has been shipped, the USPS holds primary responsibility for information and assistance regarding the package. [All this to say, when in doubt, choose Priority Mail.]

I do not offer replacements or refunds for packages that have been confirmed as delivered via USPS tracking. If a package has been tracked as delivered but you have not received it, first check with any family members and neighbors; a building manager, concierge, doorman, or superintendent, if you have one; and your mail carrier. Then call/visit your local post office or call USPS at 800-610-8734 and request the GeoTracking data from the handheld scanner of the carrier. Many mysteriously "lost" packages show up the next day once this information is requested.

If the package can't be located via either of those methods, please contact me **within 7 business days** of package delivery notification and include your order information in the message. I can assist you in filling out a Missing Mail Search form ( and/or submitting a mail theft form.

If a package is stuck in transit, please contact me and include your order information in the message. I can assist with opening a USPS case review.
Additional policies and FAQs
For a complete FAQ, please see the More Information section below.

Other questions? Please feel free to email me directly with any questions at shop [!at], and please include your order number for reference if appropriate.

More information

Last updated on Jan 31, 2018
Frequently asked questions
Where can I buy your Schuyler Sisters pins?

All Hamilton-inspired enamel pins, including the Schuyler Sisters are available at The Casey BarberSHOP flagship store:

Do you offer overnight shipping? When will my order arrive?

Yes, you can choose USPS Priority Mail Express at checkout. Orders typically ship out the following business day after the order is placed, though exceptions are necessary for weekends and holidays. For a complete list of USPS estimated shipping times, please see the full shipping policies section above.

Do you ship internationally?

On Etsy, I only ship to the United States and Canada. I ship to all countries at The Casey BarberSHOP flagship store:

Do you offer bulk pricing?

If you are a brick and mortar store owner with a seller's permit/resale certificate, I would be happy to discuss wholesale opportunities with The Casey BarberSHOP. Please fill out the wholesale account application at and I'll be in touch! Unfortunately, I do not offer trade pricing to individual customers.

Can I buy your designs as digital downloads?

I'm sorry, but I don't offer digital downloads or license my designs. However, subscribers to The Casey BarberSHOP newsletter periodically receive exclusives such as downloadable gift tags, phone wallpapers, and more. Sign up at

Can you make custom/personalized cards for wedding or bridal shower invitations?

At this time, I cannot customize or personalize existing card designs. However, if you are interested in an original watercolor painting for a wedding or other gift, I would be happy to discuss. Please email me directly at; prices for original work start at $300.