Reviews
-
Dani on 21 May, 2026
5 out of 5 starsExactly as described. The average agate you can expect to find on Lake Superior. Some nice enough to cut but most good for tumbling and casual collecting. I needed an example of what real agates looked like for my family for their first time at Agate Days in Moose Lake this summer. They’re new to rock hounding and needed to see what they can expect to find.
-
Grandma on 20 May, 2026
5 out of 5 starsI love this package of Lake Superior agates, the package even came quickly, well packed, and with a personal note, what a neat surprise. To top it off, the package arrived on the same day as I emptied a barrel of the tumbler, so the whole lot just fit nicely in the 3 lb barrel. I am so pleased and excited to see them polished. I will definitely keep this seller in my favorite list. Thank you, be blessed, Joy Dykstra ❤️
-
Julia on 08 Apr, 2026
5 out of 5 starsThese are beautiful agates! It’s a good variety of bands and I love the orange colors. Highly recommend this seller. Shipping was prompt and transaction was very smooth. Thank you!
-
Bob on 27 Mar, 2026
5 out of 5 starsMerchandise arrived as represented and quicker than expected. Great transaction.
-
Lorene on 09 May, 2026
2 out of 5 starsThe size of the agates are a lot bigger then the picture shown, which was a huge disappointment. I was expecting them to be small like the picture showed, and to receive more stones for my pound, but because of the size, well not so many. the pricing is also quite high. Sorry, your note on the age of the rocks is very wrong, there is no way the rocks are over a million years old when the earth according to the Bible is only approximately 6,000 years old.
Nathan responded on 10 May, 2026
Sorry these agates didn’t meet your expectations! I believe I gave you more than a pound of agates like I do for all my orders. Maybe I am missing something but I believe my listing is the cheapest Lake Superior agate listing on Etsy (by weight at least). Unless you are referring to the shipping, but I can’t exactly control the gas prices. I actually lose money on the shipping because the shipping price on Etsy doesn’t accurately reflect USPS shipping prices. I also appologize for the hand written card detailing the age of these agates, I wasn’t aware the geologic timescale was offensive. I know the geologic timescale is crazy and hard to fathom, but there is plenty of reliable scientific literature stating the earth is 4.56 billion years old.
About AgateFiend
Shop policies
Accepted payment methods