Beautiful Handmade Leather, Rubber, Rope, Wax Kink Toys

Northampton, Massachusetts

Buyers are raving!

This shop got multiple 5-star reviews in the past 7 days.

Announcement    Check out our special deals:


Last updated on Feb 9, 2021

Check out our special deals:



All Items

Agreeable Agony

Contact shop owner

Agreeable Agony


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
Quality 359 Shipping 313 Customer service 168

About AgreeableAgony

Sales 13,940
On Etsy since 2011

Toys for pleasure, and toys for pain....

Toys for pleasure, and toys for pain....

Agreeable Agony is a collective of crafters/artisans and kinksters from the east coast who make beautiful handmade floggers, dragon tails, slappers, candles, claws, pretty colored bondage rope, and other kinky toys, and have a passion for sex education!

We are the Consent Collective of Western Mass.

Based out of Western Massachusetts, Agreeable Agony is run by community leaders and local craftsmen, teaming up to provide a high quality product to members of the community at a reasonable price. With a combined 10 years of leadership and safety training both in and out of the community, we've decided to focus our expertise not only on bringing you a quality product, but on bringing you informative opinions and intelligent discourse from the very community we represent.

When we're not crafting, vending, or brainstorming for clever sounding about pages, we help to educate our local communities through munches and classes. With experience both building and running communities, we hope to forge a more tolerant and understanding future for our play. See the links to the right for some of the local groups we associate with regularly, as well as some great links to other incredibly informative sites. Thanks for visiting, we look forward to helping you!

Shop members

  • LNinja

    Owner, Candle Maker & Businessy Fellow

    Ninja is owner of AgAg and candle maker extraordinaire. When he's not running munches, you can find him selling toys, playing tabletop games, fixing computers, contra dancing.

  • Jesse (Waiting_)

    Creator, Crafty Motherfucker, Crafty Motherfucker

    Jesse splits his time between the streets of Western Massachusetts, and the limitless expanse of the US Interstate. He hates fun and is only truly at peace building you toys. Also a lovable bear with a heart of gold (don't tell anyone we told you so)

Shop policies

More information

Last updated on Feb 9, 2021
Frequently asked questions
Wholesale availability

We do offer limited product line wholesale purchasing for retail stores. If interested please contact

If you know a store that you wish carried our stuff, please contact us or have them contact us!

Custom and personalized orders

We are always happy to help you design and build the custom toy of your dreams. If you want a custom item please feel free to contact us directly at or through the Etsy "request a custom" feature on our page.

Gift wrapping and packaging

All of our packaging material can be discreet, although not always subtle.

We mail all of our packages in brown paper/cardboard mailers or in USPS branded boxes/envelopes. Our return address lists our business name only as "AgAg."

Some smaller orders may be shipped in mailers that have our Squid logo on the outside. They do not include our business name or any reference to kink. If you wish to specifically avoid even the squid artwork please include a note in your order that you wish plain packaging.

For international mail, we do have to declare the contents of the package legally and fully, but we do our best to avoid sex and kink

If you have any questions or concerns or requests regarding packaging feel free to contact us directly.

I have seen your items at a show and you sell books and other accessories?

Etsy is a marketplace specifically only for hand made items. We are allowed to offer and do offer some add-ons for orders that are not made by us (safety shears, books, etc). But all of our listings here are items hand made by our team.

If you are looking for rope accessories (suspension gear, shears, rings, carabiners, books, etc) please check out our full website that has a few more of these items available.

Where can I find your products to look at in person!?

We do not have a retail storefront presence but we do sell at a variety of kink events all over the country.

See our website blog for updates on our upcoming events:


You can also find many of our products in your friendly local sex shop! Goodvibes, Babeland, Smitten Kitten, and many other stores carry our products.
For a complete list of stores carrying our products check here:

***Know another shop that you would like to see our stuff in? - Please put us in touch!***