Making magic for everyone
All items
No items listed at this time
Reviews
5.0
(3)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.
About ApothecaryMagicShop
Sales
12
On Etsy since 2017
Shop members
-
Rebecca Passer
Owner, Maker
22-year-old Jewish witch who has been practicing the craft for over 5 years. I live with my fiancé, Charlie, and our two cats who serve as our domestic familiars.
-
Charlie Hart
Owner, Photographer
23-year-old pagan witch who is new to the art of spellcraft.
-
Neil Catrick Harris
Assistant
Magical name Paitoon (meaning moonstone). I am a 9-year-old brown tabby who has been Rebecca's familiar the entire time she has practiced magic.
-
Laverne Cats
Assistant
My magical name is Hermione because I don't understand that the name Hermione is associated with Harry Potter and I picked it. I am a 2-year-old mostly black Maine Coon, and I'm Charlie's familiar, but just like her, I'm new to this.
Shop policies
Last updated on 28 Nov, 2017
Delivery
See item details for estimated arrival times.
Customs and import taxes
Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.
Payment options
Secure options
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.
Returns & exchanges
See item details for return and exchange eligibility.
Cancellations
Cancellations: not accepted
Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.
More information
Last updated on
17 Dec, 2025
Frequently asked questions
Custom and personalised orders
We will gladly make custom potions or spells for you. Are you looking for a type of potion or spell not listed? Contact us and we will gladly create a listing for you in most cases*. Message us to let us know what you're looking for and we'll take it from there.
*Due to Etsy policy, potions which contain alcohol, or certain herbs cannot be sold on Etsy. If your potion would require such ingredients we will not be able to create a listing for you. We reserve the right to refuse any custom order in which the magic may be put to improper use.
How do I use a spell or potion?
All potions and spells are sent with step-by-step instructions on how to properly use them. We also try to give quality instructions in the listings so that you know exactly what you're getting yourself into.
Does this stuff actually work?
The answer is both yes and no. Magic works, but not always in the way you think it should. That is why we encourage customers to buy 1 bottle the first time they purchase a potion, so they can get a feel for the actual effect of the potion before they buy a ton of it.
Why are all these listings for just one bottle?
We encourage customers to buy 1 bottle the first time they purchase a potion, so they can get a feel for the actual effect of the potion before purchasing more. This way you know exactly what you will get before you pay for a lot of it. Think of it as a test bottle to see if you like it.
I have allergies and you said to contact you about that, why?
Our potions are not brewed in a controlled environment. We have all sorts of ingredients in our kitchen and the last thing we want to do is give someone a reaction.If you have an allergy we can still most likely send you a potion, we just want to be careful about what touches all the ingredients if you could react to it.
I want one of your potions but I'm allergic to/can't have one of the ingredients. What do I do?
Send us a message and we can create a custom listing for a version of the potion without the offending ingredient. Most ingredients have a magical equivalent, another ingredient with the same or similar effect as the ingredients listed. However, all of the ingredients we have listed are there for a reason, and a large part of that reason is cost. We want to make magic easily affordable to everyone but replacing an ingredient will likely increase the cost of your potion.
Why do some potions take longer to ship than others?
Quite simply, some of them take longer to make. A potion we can make in a day can ship out very quickly, but if it requires the light of the full moon to activate it, it may take longer.