Top shop for gifts.
Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!
Announcement Welcome! Our baked goods are all made from scratch by hand in small batches. We use only the finest ingredients and are committed to delivering you the freshest goods possible. That's why we only use real butter, milk, and eggs. From our kitchen straight to yours. Enjoy!
Announcement
Welcome! Our baked goods are all made from scratch by hand in small batches. We use only the finest ingredients and are committed to delivering you the freshest goods possible. That's why we only use real butter, milk, and eggs. From our kitchen straight to yours. Enjoy!
Items
Featured items
All Items
Reviews
-
![]()
Amy on Jan 9, 2021
5 out of 5 starsCookies were so good they did not last long! Next time, we’ll need to order more.
-
![]()
Carolyn on Dec 30, 2020
5 out of 5 starsThis is my third year purchasing from your shop and the quality has always been wonderful. Unfortunately, and by no fault of your own, the cookies I ordered in mid-December still have yet to arrive at their destination and we are now closing in on January. So, while I am disappointed, I know the quality of your baked goods is wonderful and I hope to order again.
-
![]()
David on Dec 18, 2020
5 out of 5 starsThe item itself is top notch. The USPS dragged their feet. Item was shipped 2 day Priority Mail on 12/10/2020. Item was received on 12/18/2020.
-
![]()
allisonflood24 on Dec 15, 2020
5 out of 5 starsMy grandma used to make Congo squares when we were growing up. We’ve been trying to find them for years and we finally did!! The bars and the service couldn’t have been better and we will definitely be ordering again!
-
![]()
Melissa on Dec 6, 2020
5 out of 5 starsI purchased these cookies as a gift and the recipient was beyond pleased. They told me the cookies were delicious! I received excellent customer service throughout the questions I contacted them with.
The shipping was extremely fast and the packaging was exactly what I had hoped for!!
Do not hesitate to buy from Apple Mill Bakery!! -
![]()
Mary on Dec 3, 2020
5 out of 5 starsTHIS WAS A GIFT & I WAS TOLD BY THE RECIIPIENT THAT IT WAS BEAUTIFUL,
-
![]()
Melanie on Nov 23, 2020
5 out of 5 starsThank you, Anne! The feedback from all 4 households were very positive. And your quick turn-around was great! Will definitely be ordering again!
-
![]()
Denise on Apr 16, 2020
5 out of 5 starsI received the order quickly. There a few broken cookies but that was to be expected. However, I was happy because they were delicious, just as good as the bakery i usually get them from.
-
![]()
Julie on Feb 18, 2020
5 out of 5 starsYou can't go wrong with these. It is so nice to bring homemade cookies and there is no comparison to these. Wonderful! You are gifted Anne. Thank you.
-
![]()
Julie on Feb 18, 2020
5 out of 5 starsWe love these so much that they quickly disappear. Delicious!!
About AppleMillBakery
-
Cookie tins waiting to be filled and shipped out.
-
Everything in our kitchen is made by hand. Right down to hand dipping each cookie in velvety smooth chocolate.
-
-
-
Cookie dough on its way to sweet, buttery perfection.
Homemade. Made from scratch. Everyday. Just the way it should be.
Baking has always been a passion with us. We love what we do and are so excited to share it with you! We start with third generation family recipes. Then we make everything from scratch using the finest and freshest ingredients available. The result is delicious baked goods that taste just like mom's. Straight from our kitchen to yours!
Shop members
-
Anne
Owner
The baker behind the bakery. I am an entrepreneur and avid baker. I love spending time with my family & friends, and my golden retriever. With my bachelor's in business and my heart in the kitchen, I knew starting a bakery was the right fit for me.
Shop policies
Shipping
Payment options
Returns & exchanges
I don't accept returns, exchanges, or cancellations
I accept returns I do not accept returns
I accept exchanges I do not accept exchanges
I accept cancellations I do not accept cancellations
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for: