BabyEverAfterCo

Massachusetts, United States

7.5k
 Sales

4.9 (1.2k)

9 years
on Etsy

4.9 (1.2k)

7.5k
 sales

9 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

7.5k
 Sales

4.9 (1.2k)

9 years
on Etsy

4.9 (1.2k)

7.5k
 sales

9 years
on Etsy

All 140
Baby Bodysuits 135
Wooden Blocks 4
Nursery Signs 1

Request Custom Order

Contact shop owner

7493 Sales

317 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on 30 Oct, 2025

Contact shop owner

Danielle

Reviews

4.9 (1198)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

David on 24 Oct, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Product is excellent quality and looks beautiful!

Personalized I Was Handpicked For Earth By My Brother Sister In Heaven Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental Rainbow

Personalized I Was Handpicked For Earth By My Brother Sister In Heaven Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental Rainbow
Debbie on 22 May, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Was a grest seller. Awsome product.

CUSTOM ORDER - Debbie

CUSTOM ORDER - Debbie
Aly on 08 May, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

The quality of the lettering is great! This is such a cute onesie I can’t wait to gift it!

Don't Mess With Me, My Aunt (Custom Name) Is A Real Witch! Gift Baby Bodysuit

Don't Mess With Me, My Aunt (Custom Name) Is A Real Witch! Gift Baby Bodysuit
kirstin on 14 Apr, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Nice design and good quality. I would recommend!

Will You Be My Godparents? Custom Name Baptism Baby Bodysuit

Will You Be My Godparents? Custom Name Baptism Baby Bodysuit
Crystal on 19 Feb, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Love it! Seller very responsive and helpful.

My Big Brother | Sister | Drools Bloodhound Dog Sibling Fur Baby - Baby Bodysuit

My Big Brother | Sister | Drools Bloodhound Dog Sibling Fur Baby - Baby Bodysuit
Jennifer on 23 Jan, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

The blocks turned out so cute!!

Custom Block Letters 2" Hard Wood Name Woodworking Personalized Baby Shower Gift Shelf Decor Nursery Baby Announcement Free Shipping

Custom Block Letters 2" Hard Wood Name Woodworking Personalized Baby Shower Gift Shelf Decor Nursery Baby Announcement Free Shipping
Etsy buyer on 26 Dec, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

It was a very touching gift for my daughter in law. Thank you.

I Was Handpicked For Mommy & Daddy By A Special Angel in Heaven Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental

I Was Handpicked For Mommy & Daddy By A Special Angel in Heaven Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental
Etsy buyer on 16 Dec, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

My son loved it! His first baby. It was exactly as described.

I Was Handpicked For Mommy & Daddy By A Special Angel in Heaven Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental

I Was Handpicked For Mommy & Daddy By A Special Angel in Heaven Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental
Jessica on 23 Nov, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Love the onesie! it arrived on time and appears to be good quality.

Rainbow Baby Handpicked For Earth By My Custom Name Brother Sister in Heaven Baby Bodysuit RB1 Sentimental - Rainbow only

Rainbow Baby Handpicked For Earth By My Custom Name Brother Sister in Heaven Baby Bodysuit RB1 Sentimental - Rainbow only
Etsy buyer on 21 Oct, 2024

4 out of 5 stars

UPDATE - seller reached out immediately and offered to correct. Would recommend Item definitely runs small as seller stated so keep that in mind.

My Auntie Doesn't Spoil Me She is Just Very Accommodating | Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental Family Personalized

My Auntie Doesn't Spoil Me She is Just Very Accommodating | Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental Family Personalized

About BabyEverAfterCo

Personalized Baby Bodysuits & Wooden Nursery Keepsakes

Sales 7,493

On Etsy since 2016

Personalized Baby Bodysuits & Wooden Nursery Keepsakes

Welcome to Baby Ever After — where every little moment becomes a keepsake.

We’re a small family run shop that believes childhood should be celebrated with love, laughter, and beautiful memories that last a lifetime. From our soft, cozy baby onesies to our personalized wooden keepsakes, each piece is designed to help you capture life’s sweetest beginnings one milestone at a time.

Every order is created with care and attention to detail, right here in our family studio. We love turning your special moments — from birth announcements to “baby’s first Christmas” — into something you can hold onto forever.

Whether you’re decorating a nursery, announcing your new arrival, or finding that perfect gift for new parents, we’re honored to be part of your family’s story.

Because here at Baby Ever After, every memory deserves to last a little longer.

Shop members

Danielle

Owner

Shop policies

Last updated on 13 Dec, 2016

Delivery

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

BabyEverAfterCo

Featured items

Custom I Was Handpicked for Mommy & Daddy by Angel in Heaven Baby Bodysuit

Best Friend | Twin Baby Set | Twin Besties | Best Friends Baby Bodysuit

Crib Name Sign | Baby Plaque | Custom Personalized Wood Nursery Round

2 Inch Custom Wooden Name Blocks – Personalized Baby Blocks for Nursery Shelf Decor or Newborn Photo Prop

All items

Personalized Wooden Letter Blocks | Baby Picture Prop

Blue Engraved Baby Name Blocks for Birth Announcement | 2 Inch Stained Wood

Purple Wooden Letter Name Blocks – 2 Inch Personalized Decorative Block for Nursery

Crib Name Sign | Baby Plaque | Custom Personalized Wood Nursery Round

Custom I Was Handpicked for Mommy & Daddy by Angel in Heaven Baby Bodysuit

Rainbow Baby in Heaven Handpicked For Earth By My Custom Name Bodysuit Onesie ®

2 Inch Custom Wooden Name Blocks – Personalized Baby Blocks for Nursery Shelf Decor or Newborn Photo Prop

Movie Baby Onesie® Custom Production Date and New Parent Names Bodysuit

Forever and Ever Amen Loved by God Religious Baby Cotton Bodysuit

Christian Newborn Saved By Grace Faith Unisex Cotton Baby Bodysuit

Godparents Proposal Baby Bodysuit | Custom Baptism Gift for Godmother & Godfather

I Mustache You A Question Will You Be My Godfather? Custom Name Godparent Question Baptism Baby Bodysuit

Dog Sibling Baby Bodysuit | Bloodhound My Big Brother or Sister

Sweet As Can Bee | Baby Shower | New Baby | Baby Announcement | Baby Bodysuit

Best Friend | Twin Baby Set | Twin Besties | Best Friends Baby Bodysuit

I Was Handpicked For Mommy & Daddy By A Special Angel in Heaven Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental - Rainbow

Best Friends Triplet Set (3) Baby Bodysuit

Air Kisses Only Please | Polite way To Say No Kisses | Germ Free | New Baby - Baby Bodysuit - Cute

I Am Proof That God Answers Prayers Miracle Baby Faith Baby Bodysuit

All Of God's Grace In One Little Face Prayers Miracle Baby Faith Baby Bodysuit

Don't Mess With Me, My Aunt (Custom Name) Is A Real Witch! Gift Baby Bodysuit

I Can't Wait To Meet You Grandma Baby Announcement Promoted To Grandma Baby Bodysuit

Made to Worship Called to Love Baby Faith Baby Bodysuit

My Grandma Is My Guardian Angel | Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental

Rainbow Baby Handpicked For Earth By My Brother in Heaven Infant Bodysuit

Plot Twist Movie Fan Cute Funny Baby Announcement Baby Bodysuit

Happy First Father's Day Daddy Papa Custom Name | Funny Cute Adorable Father's Day New Father Baby Bodysuit

Happy First Father's Day Daddy Grandpa Custom Name | Funny Cute Adorable Father's Day New Father Baby Bodysuit

My Big Brother | Sister | Drools American Cocker Spaniel Dog Sibling Fur Baby - Baby Bodysuit

Ah! Good Sir I Do Believe I Have Shat Me Pantaloons | Funny Poop Joke Baby Bodysuit

My Big Brother | Sister | Drools Welsh Terrier Dog Sibling Fur Baby - Baby Bodysuit

My Auntie Loves Me Checklist | Grandma/Grandpa/Auntie/Custom Name Baby Bodysuit Sentimental Family

I'm Your Father's Day Gift - Mom Says You're Welcome Father's Day New Father Baby Bodysuit

Only The Best Husbands Get Promoted To Daddy Baby Announcement Father's Day New Father Bodysuit

Drinking Buddies | Twin Baby Set | Best Friends Baby Bodysuit

I'm Your Father's Day Gift (Mom Says You're Welcome) Father's Day New Father Baby Bodysuit

Announcement

Reviews

About BabyEverAfterCo

Shop members

Danielle

Shop policies

Delivery

Customs and import taxes

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations