Makers of Prims and Pickers of Treasures

Munnsville, New York

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!



All Items

Michele Russ

Contact shop owner

Michele Russ


Average item review
4.5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
Quality 43 Shipping 63 Customer service 31

About BetweenUsSisters

Sales 1,044
On Etsy since 2018

Makers of Treasures and Pickers of Prims

Our Brick and Mortar Shop was opened on September 11, 2005. It began on a 4 month trial rental of a spot in our small town. We did well and continued to rent the spot on a month by month basis until the opportunity came along for one of us to own the building with us renting the entire downstairs of a historical building in our town. We prospered and grew for many years savoring many firsts as young parents might; our first bolt of fabric, our first trade show, our first buying trip, our first line of curtains, our first line of paint etc. Many of these firsts are still offered by us at two local vendor malls. However, around 2017 sales began to drop off. Internet sales were too convenient for customers and foot traffic declined and ultimately we closed our shop but the passion did not die. We had to reinvent our wheel. Etsy was an avenue we ventured down. It allowed us to continue to pick treasures and offer them to a broader market as well as gave us more time to make the treasures we love. Then along comes 2020 and the Covid Pandemic. Things shut down and business nearly halted. We were one of the first in our area to perfect our face mask "operation" and did a combination of donating/selling over 3,000 masks and are still going at it, just not as strong. We plan to continue to do what we love and continue to grow our online presence with Etsy and our own website which remains a work in process.

Production partners

  • CountrySampler

    Berne, IN

    They create and publish the magazine

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits