Blue Arrow Records

Cleveland, Ohio
| 1,377 Sales | 5 out of 5 stars 5 out of 5 stars

BlueArrowRecords is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

95% or more recent reviews were 5 stars.

Announcement    Vintage Vinyl & So Much More!!!


Last updated on Mar 12, 2020

Vintage Vinyl & So Much More!!!



All Items


Contact shop owner



Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:

About BlueArrowRecords

Sales 1,377
On Etsy since 2014

Vintage Vinyl & MORE!

Blue Arrow Records has it all - we feature a wide ranging selection of vintage vinyl, cassettes, music memorabilia, books, pulp fiction, vintage magazines, rock t-shirts, posters, vintage mens' and womens' clothing, shoes, jewelry, accessories, and even some funky housewares... All housed in a historic mid-century storefront complete with neon blue arrow!

Here at Blue Arrow, we specialize in quality and reasonably priced LPs and 45s spanning from the 1950s to the present day. You can peruse selections from jazz, country, classic rock, soul, rock-n-roll and more! New merchandise is added daily to the already well stocked shelves. No matter what your taste is in music, you will find a home here.

The floor alone is worth the trip! Pete, the owner, personally renovated the 1300 square foot space, creating the incredible floor that he covered entirely with vintage album covers. Each album cover is a work of art, but together creates a musical mosaic that speaks to anyone who loves records - as you wander about, see how many familiar albums you can find!

We are located on historic Waterloo Rd. just steps from the Beachland Ballroom!
16001 Waterloo Rd.
Cleveland, OH 44110

Tuesday-Saturday: 12:00 - 7:00 pm
Sunday: 12:00-5:00 pm
Monday: Closed

Shop members

  • Pete & Debbie


    Hello friends, we are your hosts, the owners of Blue Arrow in beautiful Cleveland, Ohio. Pete has been an avid music collector since the early 70s, and Debbie has been collecting vintage clothing for 3 decades. We hope you find something special!

  • Rhonda

    Customer Service

  • Freeway

    Public Relations

  • Fluffy


  • Vox

    Quality Control

  • Monnie

    Human Relations

Production partners

  • ImageMart

    Cleveland, OH

    Locally owned and operated, ImageMart has been creating quality custom products in Cleveland since 1998. Partnering with local businesses to ensure that their visions become a reality. Skilled designers and technicians with decades of experience guarantee quality products and individual attention.

Shop policies

Last updated on May 10, 2022

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
Please contact us WITHIN 2 DAYS of receipt of your item if you are unhappy with your purchase. We will do our very best to offer a fair resolution, but reserve the right to deny an unreasonable request.


CLOTHING: We do not accept refunds due to fit and/or color. Please see our detailed measurements and message us with any questions regarding color. Many of our items are over 50 years old. We disclose all flaws and damage but expect wear consistent with age, i.e. occasional loose/missing seam stitches or missing hook/eye closures, sticky zippers, etc.

RECORDS: We do our very best to grade our records appropriately, please make sure you read our grading policy below. If you are unhappy with the quality, refunds will be given on a case-by-case basis.

CASSETTES: All of our cassettes are carefully play-tested on high quality equipment, unless they are sealed. If you are unhappy with the sound quality, refunds will be given on a case-by-case basis.

ALL OTHER GOODS (BOOKS, MAGAZINES, POSTERS, ETC.): Returns are given on a case-by-case basis.
Int'l Orders please contact us directly for quotes.

Deadline for Xmas Delivery is DEC. 15th. After that, please inquire about expedited shipping options.
Additional policies and FAQs
WE DO NOT PUT ITEMS ON HOLD. First come, first served.

Each of our records (and covers) are carefully inspected and thoroughly cleaned by hand. Any and all flaws are posted within the item's description in relationship to our grading guidelines as shown below:

Mint (M): This is a grade that won't be used unless the record is still sealed.

Near Mint (NM): This record shows no obvious signs of wear. A record that looks like new. The jacket may show only light wear with minor scuffing and/or edge-wear. The jacket will not have seam splits, folds, or cut-out holes.

Near Mint Minus (NM-): This record won't be perfect and may show very minimal signs of use. This is a record that may have been played but was handled with extreme care. The jacket may have light scuffing and/or edge-wear, minimal creasing, promotional cut-outs or cut corners.

Excellent (EX): This record will show light use and may have some mild scuffing and/or fine surfaces scratches that may create light surface noise. Light surface noise may be noticeable during quiet passages and in between tracks. This is a record that was obviously played and shows light to moderate wear. The jacket may have light to moderate scuffing, edge-wear, slight ring wear, lightly turned-up corners, promotional cut-outs or cut corners.

Very Good (VG): This record will show more signs of wear. Surface scuffing and light scratches will be much more visible. Surface noise will be more noticeable. Record labels may have writing, or stickers attached. The jacket will have scuffing and edge-wear and may have seam splits, ring wear, turned-up corners, and cut-out holes. Jackets may also have a previous owner's name or other writing.

Good (G): This record will have even more wear with significant surface noise, scratches, and possible groove wear. However, with all of these defects described, the record should play without skipping. The jacket may have seam splits, ring wear, turned-up corners, and cut-out holes. Jackets may also have a previous owner's name or other writing.