Silicone Molds, Stencils, Stickers, Pins, and more!

Downers Grove, Illinois

Top shop for gifts.

A buyer bought a gift from this shop and gave it a 5-star review!

CakesByKristi is taking a short break


Note from shop owner Thank you for your interest in Cakes by Kristi! Unfortunately, Cakes by Kristi is no longer creating custom toppers or sprinkles.
Molds are still available on my website at
I apologize for any inconvenience!

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Oct 17, 2022

Thank you for your interest in Cakes by Kristi! Unfortunately, Cakes by Kristi is no longer creating custom toppers or sprinkles.
Molds are still available on my website at
I apologize for any inconvenience!

Kristi Caccippio

Contact shop owner

Kristi Caccippio


No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:

About CakesByKristi

Sales 2,076
On Etsy since 2014

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Who is Kristi or Cakes by Kristi?

Shop members

  • Kristi Caccippio

    Owner, Creator, Designer

    Kristi has an extreme passion for all things cake. You can find Kristi's work published in American Cake Decorating Magazine, Cake Central Magazine, and Cake Master's Magazine! You can also see her on Food Network's CAKE WARS too!

Production partners

  • Customized Products

    LA, CA

    I ordered these pins from The/Studio online.

Shop policies

Last updated on Jun 24, 2019


See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options
Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.


Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

More information

Last updated on May 11, 2022

Frequently asked questions

Care instructions

Once you receive your topper, make sure it is in good condition and store in a dark, room temperature area that has low humidity until you need it. DO NOT store in the refrigerator or freezer as your toppers may melt from the moisture! If your topper has wafer paper, it is VERY important to keep it away from moisture.

If for your topper somehow arrives damaged- CONTACT ME WITHIN (2) TWO DAYS of it arriving. Also be prepared to send photos of the damage as well as photos of the box it was shipped in.

Custom and personalized orders

I love custom orders! Custom orders always require AT LEAST two weeks to complete. Please contact me if you would like something you don't see in my shop!
Many items can be personalized, just message me to make sure I can personalize what you would like.
If you see a variety of items in my shop you would like, please contact me for a custom listing so I can save you a bit on shipping!
***Custom Orders START at $35, regardless of items*** (these are items that are not in my shop- examples include animals, cupcake toppers, flowers, etc.)

I noticed you are in the Chicagoland area! Can you make me a cake?

No. I do not take cake orders any longer. I highly recommend ECBG Cake Studio for cake orders in the Chicagoland area as I work there part-time and do all the fondant work.

I just messaged you about a custom order. How long should I expect to wait before recieving a response?

Depending on the time of the week and the time of year, you may wait anywhere from a few hours to 4-5 days for a response from me.
Please understand that I deal with many, many orders on a weekly basis and cannot always respond in good time due to confirmed orders that need to be completed and shipped out.
I DO NOT answer messages on Saturday or Sunday regarding custom orders as I am spending time with my family.

Help! I need my topper this week! Is it possible?

In most cases, no, it is not possible to make, dry, and ship out the pieces listed in the Cakes by Kristi shop within one week. All pieces usually require at least 3-5 days to dry after being made. That being said, Cakes by Kristi does keep some of the more popular items on hand for emergency situations, so feel free to message and ask to see if the item you want is on hand.

If I order my topper(s) from you, when should I expect to recieve them?

All Cakes by Kristi items are made to order unless otherwise specified. Once your order has been placed, it generally takes a few days before I get to it depending on the amount of orders I have at the time of your purchase.
IF YOU NEED YOUR TOPPER BY A CERTAIN DATE, please message me and let me know! Shipping times are APPROXIMATE.
All toppers take anywhere from 2-5 days to fully dry before shipping out.
Cakes by Kristi ships using USPS priority mail. Generally, it takes about 1-5 days to ship anywhere in the continental U.S.

Do you have allergen information for your listings?

All Cakes By Kristi items are made using Satin Ice Fondant, which is vegan, gluten free, dairy free, nut free, and egg free.
Please note that some toppers may use royal icing to achieve a certain look. Royal icing DOES contain meringue powder (egg whites).
Toppers are made in a facility that processes nuts, dairy, wheat, fish, meat, and eggs. If you have a serious food allergy, it is not recommended that you purchase from Cakes by Kristi. Cakes by Kristi DOES NOT guarantee that trace particles from these allergens will not be in the air in the facility at the time of your topper(s) being made.
If the allergy is NOT life threatening, I can use different tools that have not been used with these food allergens, but you MUST let me know.

Can you color match the topper to a picture if I send you one?

I can get as close as I can to your color, but I do not guarantee a 100% match EVER. This is due to screen resolutions varying between computers. Please understand I will try my best to get the closest version of your sample.

I placed an order and it has already shipped, but I typed in the incorrect address! Can I get a refund?

No. Unfortunately, it takes a lot of time to create toppers, and once they have been mailed out, I can not use them for another order. They have a limited shelf life. Please make sure your address is correct before placing an order.

How can I track my order?

All orders are shipped via USPS unless you request otherwise. USPS has been overwhelmed with the number of packages they have been receiving. Please allow 24-48 hours to allow shipping information to appear. You can track your package from your order tab by clicking on your purchase and clicking "Track package"