Sea Glass Jewelry - Cinderella by the Sea Handcrafted

Tuckerton, New Jersey

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

Announcement    Handcrafted Fine Sea Glass Jewelry. Guaranteed Genuine Sea Glass & Genuine Cape May Diamonds. FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS to USA. Made by the artist.


Last updated on Nov 4, 2019

Handcrafted Fine Sea Glass Jewelry. Guaranteed Genuine Sea Glass & Genuine Cape May Diamonds. FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS to USA. Made by the artist.


Susan Spicer-McGarry

Contact shop owner

Susan Spicer-McGarry


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
Quality 13 Shipping 8 Customer service 9

About CinderellaByTheSea

Sales 239
On Etsy since 2014

I am a full-time jewelry artist. Personally handcrafted fine jewelry.

I am a full-time artist & make my home at the New Jersey shore. All my work is personally handcrafted. Each piece is one of a kind. Nothing is outsourced, or mass produced.

Hopelessly addicted to genuine sea glass, with a passion for fine and antique jewelry, and a love of working with metals - it was only natural that I combine them in my work. Inspired by the natural elements of sand and sea, I incorporate rare premium quality, natural sea glass, precious metals, genuine freshwater pearls, and genuine Cape May diamonds in my work to create organically elegant designs that compliment the quiet beauty of genuine, unaltered sea glass. Obsessed with artistic detail and durability, I create by hand all my clasps - each is an original work. I also handcraft all my finding, bezels, ear wires, and bails.

All my listing photos are taken in natural daylight. The utmost care has been taken to ensure the true color of each piece is represented in listing photos and sea glass color names. Colors seen on your display screen may vary slightly.

Whenever possible I refer to the popular book "Pure Sea Glass", by Richard LaMotte as a guide for sea glass color names. Names of colors not listed in his book are sourced from research on antique glassware, vintage glassware, antique bottles, glass manufacturers and common usage within the sea glass community.

Shop members

  • Susan Spicer-McGarry

    Owner, Jewelry Artist, Designer

    Handmade fine jewelry created with genuine sea glass.

Shop policies

More information

Last updated on Nov 13, 2018
Frequently asked questions
Is it real sea glass?

Absolutely. I use only genuine, natural, ocean-tumbled, beach found, unaltered sea glass in all my jewelry designs. Only the salt and sand have been rinsed away.

Custom and personalized orders

Your special piece of sea glass can become a beautiful wearable memory. Contact me to design and created a custom piece of jewelry.

Are orders shipped with tracking?

Absolutely. Every order is shipped USPS First Class with tracking. Additionally, I keep a photograph of the addressed shipping envelope. Customers receive the tracking number via Etsy convo. Orders confirmed by USPS tracking as delivered are no longer my responsibility.