Women's Vintage Clothing, Jewelry, Bags and Accessories

Indianapolis, Indiana · 861 Sales


Women's Vintage Clothing, Jewelry, Bags and Accessories

Indianapolis, Indiana 861 Sales On Etsy since 2011

4.5 out of 5 stars

Announcement   Women's vintage clothing & accessories
✽ instagram |


Last updated on Jun 28, 2016

Women's vintage clothing & accessories
✽ instagram |

Kara McKenzie

Contact shop owner

Kara McKenzie

View all 109 items


Average item review
4.5 out of 5 stars

kblaum2 on Feb 13, 2017

5 out of 5 stars
Verified purchase

Just what I wanted for Mardi Gras 2017 !!


mjbrent1 on Feb 7, 2017

5 out of 5 stars
Verified purchase

Great shorts that fit perfectly, I love them! Thanks :)

Macarena Barros

Macarena Barros on Feb 1, 2017

5 out of 5 stars
Verified purchase

Completely in love!! 💛✨

View all 303 reviews


Fancy That Vintage: A Love Story

I've always loved old and forgotten things. As a child, I would trade the Coca-Cola bottles and ephemera found on our farm for very specific and well thought over selections of 40-year-old buttons at the local antique store. The thrill I get from unearthing something special is not all that different from the feeling a gambler gets from a win. I. Cannot. Stop.

I started selling vintage clothing and accessories back in 2006 when I realized that I didn't have enough closet space for the treasures I was snatching up. Somehow it backfired and tripled my storage problem, but I would drown happily in a sea of 1960s dresses and leather jackets so it all works out.

I should probably introduce myself. My name is Kara. Aside from vintage clothing, I like honeycrisp apples, demolition derbies, Neil Young records, old photos, dancing, carbohydrates, sequins, typography, drive-in movies, and long walks on the beach. I excel in sarcasm, drinking bubbly wine, playing dress up, and drawing straight lines without a ruler. I tend to get kind of grouchy when I'm hungry and I hate being cold.

It's great to meet you. I'm sure this is the start of a long and wonderful relationship.


Shop members

  • Kara McKenzie


Shop policies

Last updated on December 26, 2016
❖ Welcome to Fancy That Vintage! It's great to see you! ❖

Accepted payment methods

  • Pay with Visa
  • Pay with Master Card
  • Pay with American Express
  • Pay with Discover
  • Pay with PayPal
  • Buy with Apple Pay
  • Pay with Sofort
  • Pay with iDeal
  • Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
❖ Fancy That Vintage accepts payment via Paypal as well as Etsy Direct Checkout.
❖ Shipping and handling charges include the cost of postage, packing materials (tape, boxes, bubble wrap, envelopes, ink, paper, etc.), and insurance if applicable.

❖ Domestic packages are shipped via USPS Priority Mail with tracking within five business days of your payment. Notification will be sent as soon as your lovely new items are on their way.

❖ If you are interested in buying outside of the US, please DO NOT HESITATE to contact me! I am more than willing to do so.

❖ International packages will typically be sent via USPS First Class International Mail. Delivery is determined by location, and may take up to 45 days. Please note that 45 days is the extreme, but it is a possibility. If you need an item to arrive more quickly, please let me know. I can send your item via USPS Global Priority Mail at an additional cost, and will adjust the shipping price to meet your needs.

❖ Regarding international orders, any additional customs charges, value added taxes (VAT), or duty charges for your country are the responsibility of the buyer. I cannot misrepresent any items on customs forms. This includes referring to the item as a "gift" or lowering the item's value.
Refunds and Exchanges
❖ Any item may be returned for store credit within 2 days of receiving said item. The item must be in its original condition, and you must contact me before shipping the item back. Shipping is covered by the buyer both ways. Delivery confirmation/tracking must be used, and must be sent to me ahead of time.
Additional policies and FAQs
❖ To ensure that an item is the best fit for you, compare the listed measurements to your own body measurements. If you have any questions about an item, please contact me before purchasing. I'm more than happy to take extra measurements and photos. Let Fancy That do right by you.