My 3 Sisters Italian Cookies LLC

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

Announcement    Thanks for stopping by and checking out all of our delicious baked goods. Remember skinny people are easiest to kidnap, so stay safe and eat cookies! Sweetest regards, M3S


Last updated on Apr 9, 2019

Thanks for stopping by and checking out all of our delicious baked goods. Remember skinny people are easiest to kidnap, so stay safe and eat cookies! Sweetest regards, M3S


Rebecca Pirone

Contact shop owner

Rebecca Pirone


Average item review
4.5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
Shipping 13 Customer service 12

About My3SistersCookies

Sales 198
On Etsy since 2012

Old Italian family recipes.

Growing up in a large Italian family surrounded by great food and family. These are recipes that have been in my family for generations and we were taught how to cook by our grandparents. Spending time in the kitchen with family smelling the sweet and savory enlightens all of your senses

We use local ingredients and the small batches to make sure the quality is in every cookie. These cookies have no preservatives in them, so when you receive them they are individually packaged and have a shelf life of about 2-3 weeks. Or you can use a freezer bag and freeze them up to 6 months.

Check out our facebook page at

We love hearing our customers Italian heritage stories. Please contact us if you have any questions or concerns e-mail address is (

Shop policies

Last updated on January 10, 2017
Welcome to My 3 Sisters Italian Cookies! We hope you enjoy all of our wonderful family cookies.

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
We only do partial refunds if you are unhappy with your purchase. Damaged/lost goods qualify for a full refund excluding shipping costs. We do not refund shipping costs.

If you have damaged items and would like a replacement, we will reship the items on us, but customer must repay shipping. Insurance is not available through USPS on perishable items and we apologize for the inconvenience. However, we pride ourselves on the care we take to the items we ship
We accept paypal so you can use any credit card even if you do not have a paypal account. Please contact before purchase if you would like to work out another option. Payments are due within 5 days of purchase or the transaction will be canceled and all non-payment issues are taken to Etsy. Once the payment has been processed then we will bake your cookies to be shipped.
All items are not baked until the payment is received and then all cookies are shipped priority mail. We try to ship cookies on Monday and Tuesday so the cookies will not stay in the Post Office for the weekend. You'll receive your cookies in 24-48 hours from when they were baked for the freshest tasting snacks. Priority mail is our only option to guarantee that freshness of our food items. PLEASE BE SURE THAT THE ADDRESS WHICH APPEARS ON THE ORDER IS THE ADDRESS YOU WISH TO HAVE YOUR ITEM(S) SHIPPED TO. ONCE WE PRINT OUR LABEL ON-LINE THIS WILL BE THE ADDRESS WE WILL SHIP TO.IF AN INCORRECT ADDRESS IS GIVEN WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR INCORRECT ADDRESSES.
Additional policies and FAQs
Custom orders are welcome. We do offer catering discounts and large order discounts. Please contact us directly for any further questions or concerns about your order.