MysterySupplyCo

Horror, sci-fi, comic book, pin-up, and pulp gifts

Grand Rapids, Michigan
|
| 200 Sales | 5 out of 5 stars 5 out of 5 stars

MysterySupplyCo is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

95% or more recent reviews were 5 stars.

Announcement    All prints use archival inks on high quality luster (semi-matte) archival paper. Unlike dull matte prints others offer, the colors and details are *second to none* - these are not blurry upscaled images. I am always working on new prints. Thank you for visiting!

Announcement

Last updated on May 15, 2022

All prints use archival inks on high quality luster (semi-matte) archival paper. Unlike dull matte prints others offer, the colors and details are *second to none* - these are not blurry upscaled images. I am always working on new prints. Thank you for visiting!

Items

 

All Items

Mystery Supply Co.

Contact shop owner

Mystery Supply Co.

Reviews

Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
(77)
See reviews that mention:

About MysterySupplyCo

Sales 200
On Etsy since 2021

About Mystery Supply Co.

In the dead of night, in the secret hidden chambers behind the false bookcase, I'm hard at work digging through forgotten boxes and scouring forbidden tomes to bring discerning weirdos - such as yourself - the highest quality and most interesting vintage comic book, sci-fi, horror, novelty, cult, and pulp apparel and gifts.

✭ QUALITY ✭
Quality is very important to me. My goal is to offer *the highest quality prints* in this niche on Etsy. That includes both paper and image quality.

Many Etsy sellers offer prints on the cheapest, dullest paper. I have spent time and money ordering and comparing many print samples to determine the best paper for rich darks and vibrant colors. I've done side by side tests and the results were clear: these images look better on luster (semi-matte) paper.

All prints are carefully and painstakingly cleaned up and digitally restored by me. I remove spots, wrinkles, folds, tears, and other blemishes while keeping the integrity of the artwork. I spend hours at this because I love these images and want to offer the BEST quality vintage prints you can find.

Images are enlarged so they can be printed up to a poster size while remaining as sharp and detailed as possible.

➜ You will not find these vintage images at this level of quality anywhere else. If another Etsy seller has a similar image, carefully compare our listing to theirs: Do they show a close up of image detail? Read their reviews and look for mentions of wrinkles in the paper or blurry images. Then come back to Mystery Supply Co. and order the prints you deserve!

✭ CONTACT ME ✭
Would you like to see something I don't currently have? Is there an incredible old movie poster I missed? Did you find something interesting in an old comic or discover an old pulp magazine? Have a suggestion? Want a customization? Contact me! I'd love to hear from you.

If you're interested in vintage comic book and movie posters on more than what is offered here, check out https://www.mysterysupply.co (and sign up for the mailing list!).

Shop members

  • Ryan

    Owner, Designer

    I have a Fine Art degree and once worked for high-end NYC collectible dealers selling vintage comics books, original art, and movie posters.

Production partners

  • A print shop

    United States

    Mugs are printed and fulfilled by POD company.

  • A print shop

    CA, United States

    Prints our designs on products.

  • A print shop

    United States

    Printing and fulfillment.

  • A print shop

    Fremont, CA

    Print and ship POD items.

  • A Print Shop

    NY, United States

    Prints.

  • A Print Shop

    United States

    Printing and fulfillment.

  • POD Fulfillment

    NC, United States

    Prints and fulfills orders.

  • A Print Shop

    United States

    Prints my designs.

  • A printing company

    United States

    Printing and fulfillment company.

  • Print-on-demand drop shipper

    Charlotte, NC

    A fullfillment and shipping service for online retailers.

  • A print shop

    United States

    Printing and fulfillment.

Shop policies