StitchWitcheryCo

Handmade knitwear from Columbus, OH

Columbus, Ohio

| 152 Sales |

StitchWitcheryCo is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

Average review rating is 4.8 or higher

Melinda Cassidy

Contact

Following shop Follow shop

Announcement The Skelly design is now available as a customizable ear warmer!

If you're hunting for a custom beanie (sports teams, monogrammed, etc.), please feel free to send a message and let's see if we can work something out 🖤

Follow us on Instagram at @stitchwitcheryco

Announcement

Last updated on Feb 15, 2024

The Skelly design is now available as a customizable ear warmer!

If you're hunting for a custom beanie (sports teams, monogrammed, etc.), please feel free to send a message and let's see if we can work something out 🖤

Follow us on Instagram at @stitchwitcheryco

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Reviews

Average item review

(68)

See reviews that mention:

james on Mar 6, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Very nice, and fast shipping

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie
Miranda on Mar 5, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Love this hat! The seller communicated promptly in response to a question as well.

The Sandworm Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, seasonal, Beetlejuice beanie, Halloween beanie

The Sandworm Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, seasonal, Beetlejuice beanie, Halloween beanie
Ghouli on Jan 31, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

the hat's great, the pom-pom is Massive, and i love the colors

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie
Gnoman Republic on Jan 13, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

My mom loved it! Thank you!

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie
Elias on Jan 13, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Super Nice Cap! High quality and so nicely wrapped. You can tell care was taken in product and I much appreciate.

The Fangs Out Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, Halloween beanie, vampire beanie, Halloween, handmade

The Fangs Out Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, Halloween beanie, vampire beanie, Halloween, handmade
Kimberly on Jan 1, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

I gifted it to my sister in law and she loved it!

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie
Dorian on Dec 16, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

I really love the hat - I would just add that it actually is pretty big (which works for me, as I have a big head).

Santa Hat Double Brim Knit Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, seasonal, Santa hat, Christmas, Xmas

Santa Hat Double Brim Knit Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, seasonal, Santa hat, Christmas, Xmas
Siani on Dec 16, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

Super cute! And comfy I got it for my friend

Santa Hat Double Brim Knit Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, seasonal, Santa hat, Christmas, Xmas

Santa Hat Double Brim Knit Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, seasonal, Santa hat, Christmas, Xmas
Anna on Dec 14, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

This is a gorgeous item and I just know my daughter will love it. It arrived so quickly for a custom piece. To say I am impressed with this hat would be an understatement.

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie
Jammie on Dec 13, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

Keep coming back for more as gifts. Soft cozy warm. Everyone who received has loved! And with so close to holiday was grateful they shipped so quick.

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

About StitchWitcheryCo

Sales 152

On Etsy since 2015

Stitch Witchery

My mom and I have always enjoyed crafting together - I get 100% of my creative DNA from her - so one November day back in 2017 we decided to have a maker day, and I decided that my project that afternoon would be learning how to knit. The rest, as they say, is history.

I instantly was hooked. I would be anxiously awaiting getting off work so that I could come home and create, but there are only so many things you can make for yourself, your friends and your family, and so a few years later, Stitch Witchery was born!

Instagram

Shop members

Melinda Cassidy

Owner, Creator, Designer

Shop policies

Last updated on Oct 18, 2021

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 24 hours of purchase

StitchWitcheryCo

Handmade knitwear from Columbus, OH

Announcement

Featured items

Items

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

Kid's Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Kid's, unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

Beetlejuice Slouchy Beanie, Faux Fur Pom // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, Beetlejuice hat, Halloween hat

The Sandworm Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, seasonal, Beetlejuice beanie, Halloween beanie

All Items

The Skelly Ear Warmer - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Unisex, knit ear warmer, skull ear warmer, knit headband

The Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

The Grimoire Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, basic beanie, slouchy knit beanie, custom

The Salem Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, slouchy, custom, fair isle

Beetlejuice Slouchy Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, seasonal, Beetlejuice beanie, Halloween beanie

Beetlejuice Slouchy Beanie, Faux Fur Pom // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, Beetlejuice hat, Halloween hat

The Sandworm Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, seasonal, Beetlejuice beanie, Halloween beanie

The Sally Beanie, The Nightmare Before Christmas // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, Halloween beanie, TNBC

Eyeball Beanie, eyeball pompom // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, pompom beanie, knit hat, halloween beanie

The Fangs Out Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, Halloween beanie, vampire beanie, Halloween, handmade

Kid's Skelly Beanie - BYOB (Build Your Own Beanie) // Stitch Witchery Co., Kid's, unisex, knit beanie, skull beanie, Halloween beanie

Kid's Beetlejuice Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Kid's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, seasonal, Beetlejuice, Halloween hat, kid's beanie, baby

Kid's Sandworm Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Kid's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, seasonal, Beetlejuice beanie, Halloween hat, faux fur pom

Kid's Eyeball Beanie, eyeball pompom // Stitch Witchery Co., Kid's, Unisex, knit beanie, fall, pompom beanie, knit hat, halloween hat

Old Salt Nautical Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, slouchy, custom, fair isle, nautical, sailor

The Cable Knit Beanie in Fall Leaves // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, unisex, knit hat, cable knit, custom, faux fur pom pom, teens

The Cable Knit Beanie in Hudson Bay // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, unisex, knit hat, cable knit, custom, faux fur pom pom, teens

The Cable Knit Beanie in Spice Market // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, unisex, knit hat, cable knit, faux fur pom pom, teens

The Cable Knit Beanie in Harvest // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, unisex, knit hat, cable knit, custom, faux fur pom pom, teens

Pastel Double Pom Beanie // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men's, unisex, knit beanie, pastel beanie, faux fur pom pom, pastel, rainbow

The Wanderlust Beanie in Denver // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, slouchy, colorblock, knit hat, winter hat

The Wanderlust Beanie in LA // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, slouchy, colorblock, knit hat, winter hat

The Wanderlust Beanie in Cape Cod // Stitch Witchery Co., Women's, Men’s, Unisex, knit beanie, slouchy, colorblock, knit hat, winter hat