Hand-painted maps, stationery and gifts

Georgia, United States · 4421 Sales


Hand-painted maps, stationery and gifts

Georgia, United States 4421 Sales On Etsy since 2008

5 out of 5 stars

Announcement   Use the search bar to shop your city ➹ Scroll down to read policies + FAQ, including how to carry our line wholesale and inquiries about local pick-ups.

Last updated on Jun 16, 2016

Use the search bar to shop your city ➹ Scroll down to read policies + FAQ, including how to carry our line wholesale and inquiries about local pick-ups.

Natalie Kilgore

Contact shop owner

Natalie Kilgore

Peachtree City, Georgia 3" Stickers
Peaches Personalized Notepad
Charleston, South Carolina Skyline Notecard Set
New Orleans, Louisiana Skyline Magnet
Athens, Georgia Skyline Art Print
Atlanta Hometown Pencil Set // Gold Foil
Hotty Toddy Pencils
Nashville, Tennessee Skyline Magnet
Sunflower Crown Personalized Notepad
New Orleans, Louisiana Skyline Mug
Rainbow Notecard Set
Letterpress Atlanta, Georgia Map Coasters
Red and Black Georgia Pencil Set
Nashville, Tennessee Skyline Mug
Charleston, South Carolina Skyline Mug
New Orleans, Louisiana Art Print
View all 235 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
Laura Russell

Laura Russell on Jul 24, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful stamp! Natalie was super easy to work with and the stamp is absolutely perfect! I will definitely be back. Thank you so much!

Suzanne Hackney

Suzanne Hackney on Jul 19, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

Will be so perfect for a favor for the bachelorette trip! Thanks so much!

View all 1120 reviews


About Natty Michelle Paperie

Hi, I'm Natalie, and I'm so glad you're here! Welcome. Ever since I was old enough to pick up a crayon and hold it in my hand, I've been coloring, drawing and painting. I love to create, and I've always held a special place in my heart for snail mail. I combined these two passions in 2010 and opened Natty Michelle Paperie -- a play on my nickname + of course, paper! -- my online stationery and gift shop where I sell my original artwork, handmade notecards, invitations and other wonderful whimsies. Most of my artwork is inspired by travel; I love illustrating maps and city landmarks that make a place special.

I work out of my home studio right outside Athens, Georgia, specializing in hand-painted paper goods, maps and other custom art. All goods are printed on high-quality paper with a soft texture similar to watercolor paper, giving the hand-painted designs dimension and a life all their own.

In 2015 I partnered with Night Owl Paper Goods in Birmingham to create a line of birch ornaments and notebooks featuring my artwork, and I regularly collaborate with my friends at Smokey Road Press in Athens to create one-of-a-kind letterpress map coasters and prints as well. In 2016 I hope to expand my city skyline collection and add more stamps, mugs and party cups to the shop -- stay tuned for more soon!

When I'm not creating, you can find me antiquing, watching college football ("Go Dawgs!") and spending time with my husband and baby son, Archie. Oh, and my friends call me “Natty," so now you can, too!

Please contact us if you have general questions or would like to work together -- we look forward to hearing from you!

Shop members
  • Natalie Kilgore

    Owner, Creator, Designer

  • James Kilgore

    Bookkeeper, Accountant, Supportive Husband

  • Archie Kilgore

    Shop Baby

Shop policies

Last updated on July 2, 2016
▲ Welcome to Natty Michelle Paperie! We're glad you're here.

Our hours are Monday through Thursday, 10 am to 5 pm EST. If you message us after hours, we're likely away from the office and will respond to you the following business day. Weekend messages will be returned within 48 business hours. Thank you in advance for your patience and understanding!

Accepted payment methods

  • Accepts Etsy gift cards
We accept all major credit cards via Direct Checkout and through Paypal. Credit card payments that are processed through PayPal do not require you to create an account to check out.

Please note that we require payment in full before beginning work on invitations and all other custom projects.
All custom art items, invitations and stamps are shipped via USPS Priority Mail with tracking.

All stationery, letterpress goods, art prints, mugs, cups and other non-custom items are shipped via First Class with tracking in 3-5 business days; let me know ASAP if you want to upgrade your order to include faster shipping and/or tracking and I will invoice you for the difference in cost. Estimated overnight delivery via USPS is $23.00.

Custom rubber stamps are currently on a 1.5-2 week turnaround. All customers will be notified via e-mail with tracking info when their custom order is shipped.

Please note: Total turnaround time for all custom work, like our hand-painted maps, is about 6 weeks from start to finish. Every project is different, so please contact us directly with any questions about your unique order: hello [!at]
Refunds and Exchanges
We want you to be 100% satisfied with your purchase. If for some reason you are not happy, please contact us immediately so we can remedy the situation! We will do everything we can to help.

▲ Merchandise must be requested for refund or returned within 15 days of original purchase.

▲ Please note that used, opened and/or final sale items cannot be returned. Custom orders that have been reviewed by customers through a proof-and-approval process also cannot be returned.

▲ Any custom orders, like custom art or stamps, not fulfilled by customer after 90 days with instruction, approval or response cannot be refunded for a full credit but may be transferred to a store credit.
Additional policies and FAQs
We currently offer a variety of our goods to retailers with wholesale prices.

Here is a link to our New Account Inquiry Form, where you can provide a few more details on your shop and get set up as a retailer with us:

Please also refer to our Wholesale Terms & Conditions here for details and guidelines:

We do not drop ship or sell on consignment at this time. Thank you!

Since Natalie is a local artist with many locally inspired goodies, we get asked about pick-ups a lot! We would love to meet each and every one of you in person and say thank you, but unfortuantely we can't accommodate everyone. Because this shop is run out of our home, it's important to respect the privacy of our family as well. We know shipping is a bummer, but we assure you that S&H rates are calculated to be as low as possible! If you have any questions about shipping rates or extremely large orders, please don't hesitate to contact us: hello [!at]

Because we value the quality of the paper of our products and cannot guarantee print or paper quality with at-home printing, we do not offer PDFs for print (our one exception is custom map artwork). We believe in design consistency and want to preserve the integrity of our work -- thanks in advance for your understanding!

Mugs, party cups, go cups, magnets, stickers, letterpress coasters, postcards and art prints are not customizable. This includes names, dates, business information, etc.

Items that can be personalized, like stamps, notepads, custom art and select stationery, include info about how to personalize within the listing.

Locals, come out and shop with us in person in 2016! Please see a list of our market dates here:

Please contact hello [!at] with all press inquiries.

All products feature original artwork by Natalie Kilgore ©2010 - 2016 Natty Michelle Paperie, LLC. All rights reserved. Natty Michelle Paperie art and paper products may not be reproduced or transmitted in any form for resale or personal use, including electronically or by photocopying, unless you receive written permission from Natalie Kilgore. Please be kind!