Nostalgia Mama

Sartell, Minnesota · 2792 Sales


Nostalgia Mama

Sartell, Minnesota 2792 Sales On Etsy since 2010

5 out of 5 stars

Shop owner




Contact shop owner


G1 My Little Pony Newborn Baby Yo-yo
G1 My Little Pony Newborn Twin - Puddles
Rose Petal Place Dolls - Set of 6
Topps Cheap Toy Garbage Pail Kids Brainy Janey
Hallmark Halloween Ghost Lapel Pin
Halloween Pencils - Russ Ghost and Cat
Beetlejuice Cartoon Figures - Burger King
Golden Dream Barbie Doll 1980
Poochie Frame Tray Puzzle New Unopened
Heart Family Babies Doll Lot
Tea Bunnies Figures Lot - TBG
Disney Little Mermaid Twin Flat Bed Sheet
Green Hornet Ring - 1966 Promo Lays Chips
Lisa Frank Rose Art Markie Frame Tray Puzzle
View all 50 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars

thehalls98 on Dec 3, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

Perfect! Arrived quickly! Thank you!!


wjbigfattymascara on Dec 2, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

item was near perfect condition. highly impressed.


wjbigfattymascara on Dec 2, 2016

4 out of 5 stars

i think the item was in pretty good condition for its age. it was missing some hair and had some torn parts in the bathing suit, besides that i am impressed.

Caitie Davis

Caitie Davis on Nov 18, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

I had this toy as a child & seeing it again brought back a flood of memories. So happy I found one for an appropriate price!

View all 1289 reviews


How It Began

I've always enjoyed garage sales and thrift stores. A lot of times I would find things I remembered from my childhood, tempted to purchase for the sentimental value, but not really needing to add more clutter to my home. In 2010, I came across Etsy, and realized I wasn't the only one who enjoyed these little connections with the past. I had a few items I had picked up from sales, and decided to open a shop as a sort of experiment. Well it wasn't long before I had sold a few toys. From then on, I had a new perspective when it came to thrifting. Finding toys from my past allows me to relive the memories, and also pass them on to others. I spend the spring and summer months scouring garage sales, and during the cold Minnesota winter, I spend a lot of time in the thrift stores. I absolutely love it!


Around the web

Shop members

  • Emily

    Owner, Professional Thrifter

    Wife, Mother, Rescuer of Toys.

Shop policies

Last updated on April 15, 2014

Accepted payment methods

  • Pay with Visa
  • Pay with Master Card
  • Pay with American Express
  • Pay with Discover
  • Pay with PayPal
  • Buy with Apple Pay
  • Pay with Sofort
  • Pay with iDeal
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards
I accept Paypal or credit cards.
I do not accept money orders.
I am currently only shipping twice a week, but please let me know if your order is urgent, and I can ship it as soon as possible.

If actual shipping cost is considerably less than the estimated amount, I am willing to provide a refund for the overcharge. (Please note that all shipping amounts also include the cost of packaging materials.)

International orders welcome!
Refunds and Exchanges
Let me know if you are unhappy with your item, or if it arrived damaged, and we will work something out!
Additional policies and FAQs
All my shop items are stored in a pet-free, smoke-free residence. However, because these items come second-hand from garage sales and thrift stores, I can't speak for their previous storage environments. I work hard to clean most items, but if something is particularly dirty or stinky, I will try to make note of it in the listing.

I am willing to reserve listings for up to 3 days.

Minnesota sales tax is charged to all purchases made by Minnesota buyers, as required by law.