NotBettyCookies

Custom Sugar Cookies

1750 Sales

NotBettyCookies

Custom Sugar Cookies

1750 Sales On Etsy since 2010

5 out of 5 stars
(484)

Announcement   Thank you for visiting my shop! I am currently taking orders for event dates July 8th and beyond. PLEASE CONTACT BEFORE PLACING AN ORDER, TO ENSURE AVAILABILITY ON MY 2017 BAKING CALENDAR. Thank you so much, I look forward to baking for you!

Announcement

Last updated on May 5, 2017

Thank you for visiting my shop! I am currently taking orders for event dates July 8th and beyond. PLEASE CONTACT BEFORE PLACING AN ORDER, TO ENSURE AVAILABILITY ON MY 2017 BAKING CALENDAR. Thank you so much, I look forward to baking for you!

Kathryn Harter

Contact shop owner

Kathryn Harter

Personalized Forty and Fabulous Sugar Cookies
$48.00
Viva l'italia! Sugar Cookie Collection
$48.00
Fairy Tale Sugar Cookie Collection
$48.00
Circus Baby Shower Sugar Cookies
$48.00
mylilmiss Custom Listing
$56.00
Go Go Scooter Cookie Collection
$42.00
Sparkle Ballerina Sugar Cookie Collection
$58.00
Fresh Produce Sugar Cookie Collection
$38.00
Artist Party Sugar Cookie Collection
$48.00
Vintage 1950's Sock Hop Sugar Cookie Collection
$48.00
You are Capable of Amazing Things Sugar Cookies
$38.00
Sweet Baby Owl Sugar Cookies
$48.00
Owl Sugar Cookies
$42.00
Little Lamb First Birthday Sugar Cookies
$42.00
Lingerie Sugar Cookies
$42.00
Summer Pool Party Sugar Cookie Collection
$42.00
USMC Marine Corp Sugar Cookie Collection
$52.00
3 Dozen Mini Sugar Cookie Collection
$36.00
Emoji Text Sugar Cookies
$38.00
Ahoy! Nautical Themed Sugar Cookie Collection
$42.00
View all 152 items

Reviews

Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
(484)
Jo Buschman

Jo Buschman on May 16, 2017

5 out of 5 stars

This actually is my 2nd order from Not Betty Cookies. The 1st order was let me say BEAUTIFUL, DELISH and I should have ordered another dozen. My guest praised me for these wonderful cookies. I couldn't take the credit but this baker is awesome and I am ordering 2 dozen for my grandaughter's birthday. I am so impressed with her cookies, shipping and beautiful decoration on the cookies themselves.

AMLessley

AMLessley on May 15, 2017

5 out of 5 stars

My daughter literally screamed with excitement when I opened up her cookies!!! Thank you so much for such amazing cookies!!!!!!!! 😍

Laura Stark

Laura Stark on May 4, 2017

5 out of 5 stars

These cookies were a big hit! So professionally decorated, and individually bagged with a cute ribbon. They tasted great too. This is my second order. I highly recommend NotBettyCookies.

View all 484 reviews

Shop policies

Last updated on February 27, 2017
Thank you for visiting Not Betty Cookies! I work hard to customize your cookies just the way you imagined them. I bake and decorate all my cookies by hand, using only the highest quality ingredients.

Accepted payment methods

  • Pay with Visa
  • Pay with Master Card
  • Pay with American Express
  • Pay with Discover
  • Pay with PayPal
  • Buy with Apple Pay
  • Pay with Sofort
  • Pay with iDeal
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards
  • Other Method
Payment
Paypal or Etsy Direct Check Out please.
Shipping
For a specific event date, you must contact me before you order to ensure I have space on my baking calendar. **If you do not contact me before purchasing, I will ship your order on my first available ship date.** You can check my shop announcement for my most up to date availability.

I ship via USPS Priority Mail (Priority Mail transit time is generally 2-3 Days, although it is not guaranteed) Expedited or guaranteed delivery date services are available at an additional charge. I am not responsible for shipping delays caused by USPS.

Limited insurance coverage is included with USPS Priority Mail. Additional coverage may be available for an additional fee to USPS.
Refunds and Exchanges
I take great care to pack my cookies so they arrive in the same perfect condition they were in when they left my hands. Once they are picked up from the postal service, they are then at the mercy of USPS.* I am not responsible for breakage caused in transit.* Sometimes breakage does occur. If you are ordering for a special occasion, I suggest ordering a few extra just to be safe.
Additional policies and FAQs
Each cookie is cut, baked and decorated by me, all by hand, one cookie at a time. Slight variations may occur from batch to batch. The overall design element will not be compromised.

Each cookie will be heat sealed in clear cellophane bags for maximum freshness.

I do not offer quantity discounts as all my cookies are baked fresh to order. I will give each of your cookies the same amount of time and attention whether you order 12 or 120.

These cookies are baked in a kitchen that also uses peanut butter, nuts and lots of dairy.

********************These cookies are not allergen safe.****************************