Naperville, Illinois


The Pastry Tart Bakery

Naperville, Illinois | On Etsy since 2011

Top shop for gifts.

A buyer bought a gift from this shop and gave it a 5-star review!

PastryTartBakery is taking a short break


Note from shop owner Thank you visiting The Pastry Tart Bakery! Due to a family medical emergency, I am temporarily unable to take future orders. Many thanks to everyone who has sent kind words of support to my family and I during this difficult time. I will still be communicating via email, but there will be a delay in response. Thank you for your understanding, and have a very sweet day! :)

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Dec 2, 2014

Thank you visiting The Pastry Tart Bakery! Due to a family medical emergency, I am temporarily unable to take future orders. Many thanks to everyone who has sent kind words of support to my family and I during this difficult time. I will still be communicating via email, but there will be a delay in response. Thank you for your understanding, and have a very sweet day! :)


Contact shop owner



No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:
quality 7 shipping 42 customer service 55

About PastryTartBakery

Sales 508
On Etsy since 2011

Necessity really is the mother of delicious invention!

My son has a peanut allergy. Not a mild one, either. In elementary school, his kind teachers would phone me a few days in advance of in-class parties to let me know I needed to bring something in for him he could actually eat (because all of the local bakeries produced contaminated goodies).

So I baked. And I decorated. (Because plain cookies are booooring). Other mothers took notice and began asking about my cookies, so I would bake for them, too. Life was bright and lovely and beautiful.

Then my husband lost his job during the economic downturn and was unemployed for 18 months. We had some savings, but like many other American families, bankruptcy and foreclosure was looming on the horizon.

With no realistic job prospects for me (I had been a SAHM for 11 years), I prayed...and listened to the wonderful supportive words of friends and family who encouraged me to turn my cookie-making passion into something that would put food on the table for my children.

After a lot of research, snapping a few photos, and two weeks of anxious waiting, I received my first Etsy order. How empowering, to finally feel back in control of your financial destiny!

Today we are in a much better place than when my Etsy journey began, but I don't think there is much in my past I would trade in for an "easier" experience. (Though winning the lottery would be nice!) Thanks to our hardships, my husband and I have a rock-solid marriage (he uses his professional expertise to give me wonderful advice on how to be more efficient--the Achilles' heel of we creative types, you know). I've learned a whole lot about how strong and independent I really am, and I have the freedom to raise my children *and* do a job I simply adore.

It's tough work with long hours and I'm not quite financially independent...but I'm rich in so many other ways now, and that's something money can't buy!

Shop members

  • Tawnya


    One woman doing her best to carve a little bit of creative joy out of my corner of the dessert universe...while raising a family with a rainbow of food allergies and intolerances! What I do gives me great joy; sharing that joy with others is love!

Shop policies

Last updated on May 15, 2014
The Pastry Tart is passionate about pastry, and about crafting divine, delicious, and creative cookies that will satisfy your need for uniqueness and taste. I work in a peanut-free facility, am fanatical about taking precautions against possible allergen cross-contamination, and am constantly testing and developing new allergy-free recipes. Let me know if you have specific dietary requirements, and we'll see if we can bake up a solution!

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
Due to the (eventually) perishable and custom nature of my goods, no refunds or exchanges are available.

CANCELLATIONS: DOMESTIC orders may be canceled without penalty if notice is given a minimum of 31+ days prior to your requested delivery date. INTERNATIONAL orders may be cancelled without penalty 41+ days prior to shipping. NO REFUNDS on orders cancelled within after these cutoffs. Once an order has been baked and/or shipped, there are absolutely no refunds.

If you do not know exactly how many cookies you will need and to avoid unnecessary cancellation fees, I encourage you to order as many as you minimally think you will need; you have up to 14 days prior to your order shipping date to add cookies on to your order. :)

If you are uncertain about ordering, feel free to contact me to arrange purchase of a cookie sample. I encourage you to taste my goodies before you commit to buying!

I take customer service and satisfaction very seriously. I want your experience with The Pastry Tart to be exceptional! Please contact me with any concerns, and we will work together to come up with the best solution.
I am pleased to announce we now accept credit card payments through Etsy's Direct Checkout, as well as payments through PayPal!


Orders are placed onto the production schedule ONLY upon receipt of successful payment (or deposit for large orders). Cookies are baked fresh and decorated a few days days in advance of cookie shipment date to ensure absolute freshness. Total production time is usually 3-4 days. (We want that icing to dry enough for safe shipping!) This does NOT include time for shipping.

Order 60-119 cookies and receive a 15% domestic shipping discount.
Order 120+ cookies and receive a 10% discount on the cost of cookies. (Package upgrades and other extra services are not eligible for discounts.)

Orders sent to *military addresses* receive a 5% discount regardless of quantity--and thank you so much for your service! :)

Sorry, discounts cannot be multiplied.

RUSH ORDERS: If you need a rush order (less than 10 business days in advance of necessary shipping date), contact me to check on availability. Fees for these orders are $20 or 20% of order cost, whichever is greater. For orders required in *less than* 5 business days in advance of shipping date, fees are $30 or 30% of order cost, whichever is greater. These fees are to cover the cost of overtime required to suddenly add additional unplanned load to the work day/week, especially if it has to fall on a weekend.

** Be aware that rush orders usually will require overnight shipping, which is extremely expensive, so for the sake of your budget it is best to plan and order well in advance!
DOMESTIC ORDERS are shipped via USPS Priority Mail (3-5 business days). Cookie shipping is done at the beginning of the business week (Monday-Tuesday) to arrive for weekend events. Please order custom goods as far in advance as possible, and we will decide on a good delivery date to coordinate with your event. Large orders (over 5 dozen items) should be ordered 4 or more weeks in advance. I cannot be held responsible for delivery delays.

Tracking numbers/delivery confirmation is included in your shipping fee.

Any difference in shipping costs between estimated and actual rate at time of shipment in excess of $5 will be refunded to you. I do not pad my shipping costs to make extra profit.

INTERNATIONAL ORDERS are shipped via USPS International Priority Express Mail (5-8 days) or FedEx Global Express (1-5 days) only, to ensure maximum freshness and lowest cost to clients. All customs taxes and duties are the responsibility of the purchaser. Please keep in mind that some countries have very strict import restrictions--let me know your country and I will do my best to let you know if I am able to ship baked goods with minimum risk of delay to you from the United States. I properly fill out all customs documents required for your country and hold no liability for any delays due to customs. My cookies are considered "Non-Perishable Foods," so usually are not a problem to most customs agencies. :)

Contact me prior to purchasing if you would prefer this option so I can correctly calculate domestic or international shipping and set up your custom listing with the proper rate.

All possible care is taken to ensure the safe transport of your baked goods so they arrive to you as beautiful as they left. Orders are double-boxed and cushioned well (cookies have bubble wrap and/or cardboard spacers between them to minimize *any* movement), but please keep in mind the fragile nature of edible goods. I cannot guarantee against breakage, as the package is out of my hands once it ships, but I usually include a couple of extra cookies to help offset any possible problems. If you are worried about breakage, I encourage you to order about 3-5% extra, especially for fragile cookie shapes such as starfish. I am not responsible for carrier handling of packages.

I try to use biodegradable and/or repurposed inside packing materials whenever possible to cut down on my carbon footprint. Let's all do our part for the planet!
Additional policies and FAQs
STORAGE: Decorated cookies keep for about 2-3 weeks in an airtight container kept at room temperature (please do not refrigerate).

RETAINER FEES / DEPOSITS: If you are placing an order to be filled more than 8 weeks into the future and your order is projected to total over $300 (not including shipping costs), you may choose to pay a retainer fee or deposit to hold your spot open on my production schedule. My schedule fills up very quickly, and this will guarantee availability for your event date without having to pay the entire cost up-front. Deposits are usually 50% of projected cost (not including shipping) and are non-refundable. Full balance is due four (4) weeks prior to your order shipping date. If balance is not paid in full by your deadline, you risk losing both your deposit and your spot on the production schedule.

Cookies come individually wrapped in food-safe, crystal clear "cello" bags, heat sealed with a customizable round sticker tag on the back. The cello bags I use are *not* the cheap ones found at craft stores; my bags are specially designed for food preservation, are 1.6mil cello, and coated with saran to maximize freshness. Cookie favors will then be placed in inner boxes cushioned with bubble wrap, and usually bubble wrap and/or cardboard backers between cookies to minimize as much movement as possible. These boxes are then packed into sturdy shipping containers with lots of padding to help keep your sweet treats as safe as possible during shipping. Large orders may be separated into multiple boxes to minimize the risk of damage as much as is humanly possible. This over-the-top method of packaging has served me *very* well, and I have a good track record of orders arriving without damage. :)

I will happily ship directly to your gift recipient with a note included! Include a comment during checkout with your gift message and recipient address.

I love working on custom orders! Contact me and let’s see what we can dream up together!

All items are created in a peanut-free facility. Specific allergen information is included in individual item listings and with each order, but assume all products will be processed with wheat, dairy, egg and possibly tree nut contamination (due to flavourings and certain special non-icing decorations).

If you would like to request items for special dietary needs, please feel free to contact me! I happily do my best to accommodate a variety of allergy-friendly cookie needs such as nut-free and dairy free. :) Unfortunately, I can only accommodate gluten free requests for those who are following the diet by choice, or are not highly sensitive/intolerant of gluten (unlike me *pout*), or Celiac. As you folks know, wheat flour floats for DAYS and gets everywhere, no matter how well you clean...and clean...and clean. *sigh*

We welcome wholesale requests (even for custom designs), so drop us a line with your inquiry! There is an opening order, and we do have wholesale rates. Lead time is usually a minimum of 4 weeks for wholesale orders to accommodate volume in our very busy schedule. Some cookie styles are not currently available for wholesale orders.