PenelopesPaperPantry

Specializing in Custom Celebration Stationery

Battle Creek, Michigan

| 102,780 Sales |

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

Average review rating is 4.8 or higher

Julie Hopkins

Contact

Following shop Follow shop

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Reviews

Average item review

(27943)

nleemeyer on Jan 21, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Birthday cards came out great and customer service was amazing

Invitation Printing Service,Invitation Printing,Stationery Printing,Wedding Invitation Printing,Any File,Any Vendor,Birthday Invitation

Invitation Printing Service,Invitation Printing,Stationery Printing,Wedding Invitation Printing,Any File,Any Vendor,Birthday Invitation
Kim on Jan 18, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

As described. Turned out beautifully. Very quick turn around. Great with communication and help with questions about ordering. Highly recommend!

Envelope Printing Service,Recipient Address,Guest Address,Return Address,RSVP Return Address,International Address,Color,Matching Design

Envelope Printing Service,Recipient Address,Guest Address,Return Address,RSVP Return Address,International Address,Color,Matching Design
JZAKD on Jan 18, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Absolutely loved everything I’ve ordered from this company.

Envelope Printing Service,Recipient Address,Guest Address,Return Address,RSVP Return Address,International Address,Color,Matching Design

Envelope Printing Service,Recipient Address,Guest Address,Return Address,RSVP Return Address,International Address,Color,Matching Design
Tom Langemo on Jan 16, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

These were exactly what I was hoping for and am about to order more for my family members!

Photo Coaster,Personalized,Custom Photo Coaster,Unique Gift,Keepsake Coaster,Personalized Coaster,Your Photos,4 Inch Square,Printed Coaster

Photo Coaster,Personalized,Custom Photo Coaster,Unique Gift,Keepsake Coaster,Personalized Coaster,Your Photos,4 Inch Square,Printed Coaster
Kathrine21 on Jan 14, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

The coasters turned out beautiful, and were a wonderful gift

Photo Coaster,Personalized,Custom Photo Coaster,Unique Gift,Keepsake Coaster,Personalized Coaster,Your Photos,4 Inch Square,Printed Coaster

Photo Coaster,Personalized,Custom Photo Coaster,Unique Gift,Keepsake Coaster,Personalized Coaster,Your Photos,4 Inch Square,Printed Coaster
Jousy on Jan 20, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Exactly what me and my husband expected.

Winnie The Pooh Baby Shower Invitation,Winnie The Pooh Invite,Winnie Baby Shower,Pooh Bear Shower,Baby Boy,Gold Foil Print,Envelope Included

Winnie The Pooh Baby Shower Invitation,Winnie The Pooh Invite,Winnie Baby Shower,Pooh Bear Shower,Baby Boy,Gold Foil Print,Envelope Included
blueizzntx on Jan 20, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful cards , they really worked hard for me

Romantic Beach Wedding Invitation Personalized Sunset Hearts In The Sand Destination Hawaii Shimmery Printed Invitations Envelopes Included

Romantic Beach Wedding Invitation Personalized Sunset Hearts In The Sand Destination Hawaii Shimmery Printed Invitations Envelopes Included
blueizzntx on Jan 20, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Loved my cards! Just beautiful!

Personalized,Invitation,Back Print,Wedding Invite Back Print,Photo Back Print,Text,Custom Back Print,RSVP Back Print,Color Back Print

Personalized,Invitation,Back Print,Wedding Invite Back Print,Photo Back Print,Text,Custom Back Print,RSVP Back Print,Color Back Print
Haley Pardue on Jan 20, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful invites. I loved that they came with envelopes. They even sent extra envelopes. Very affordable for high quality product.

Floral Stained Glass Wedding Invitation,Stained Glass Wedding Invite,Stained Glass Theme,Calligraphy,Shimmery Invitation,Envelope Included

Floral Stained Glass Wedding Invitation,Stained Glass Wedding Invite,Stained Glass Theme,Calligraphy,Shimmery Invitation,Envelope Included
Stephanie on Jan 19, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Shops was quick and easy to work with! Will look at using them next year!

Funny Ted Lasso Christmas Photo Card,Family Photo Card,Roy Kent,Personalized,Printed Card,Back Print,Return Address Label,Envelope Included

Funny Ted Lasso Christmas Photo Card,Family Photo Card,Roy Kent,Personalized,Printed Card,Back Print,Return Address Label,Envelope Included

About PenelopesPaperPantry

Sales 102,780

On Etsy since 2014

Penelope's Paper Pantry Story

Happy New Year!
Penelope's Paper Pantry is excited to announce the addition of a new staff member...my husband Bob has joined the team.
We are so thrilled to have him on board. His passion for the print business, quest for knowledge and creativity have been key in helping us grow.
Penelope’s Paper Pantry is beyond blessed to be a part of Etsy and the Etsy Community.
September 30th, 2022 marked the eighth anniversary of Penelope’s Paper Pantry Etsy journey.
What a life changing experience it has been! The shop began with six Christmas Family Photo cards and now features over 1500 designs specializing in four celebration categories: Wedding, Graduation, Baby and Christmas Photo cards.
This is our story...
The shop began when my daughter Chelsea was planning her wedding. She and now husband Noah (you may notice their names on many of the invitations) took me to a high end wedding stationery shop in San Francisco. The shop was small but featured binder upon binder from ceiling to floor of every wedding invitation designer imaginable. The pricing was high end and out of our budget. After reviewing the designs and paper along with having access to a printer and a lot of encouragement from my daughter Penelope’s Paper Pantry was created.
Penelope’s is named after my mother who inspired creativity in all of her seven children and now in her grandchildren and great grandchildren.
In the beginning there were two designers, who still remain on staff, they worked tirelessly along side me and I am so blessed they are still part of the team. The original design studio was the size of a utility closet and did not have any windows. There were days we would spend close to 12 hours working in that cozy little space. As the business grew two things were readily apparent, we needed more space and additional staff. And as only God can do, he provided additional staff and a larger place to work at just the right time. Penelope’s moved into a one bedroom apartment with lots of windows. It was just perfect.
The new location served us well for the next two years. The team grew and so did the business. We had a better understanding of our target customer, our offerings and seasonal shifts in business. It was very exciting! Every time we needed someone or something to continue to develop and grow the business God made a way.
In the Spring of 2018 we moved to a professional studio and office. The new space made it possible for design, production and packaging to all be under one roof. This arrangement has improved communication between the three teams and enhances quality control and productivity resulting in a very fast turn around time on orders.
The most important part of this experience has been our customers. People that took a leap of faith on our products and services when we were just starting out. It has been my longstanding philosophy that “if we listen to our customers we will never fail”. I still stand by that philosophy. Our customers have been amazing and have taught us so many things. Our designs, shop process and customer service initiatives have all been customer inspired. The goal we have for each customer is that you love the end result and that you have a positive experience shopping on Etsy.
Thank you to God, Etsy, the Etsy Community and the amazing customers that have made Penelope’s Paper Pantry survive and thrive over the past eight years. We look forward to being your stationery partner for many more years to come.

Facebook

Instagram

shop-website

Shop members

Julie Hopkins

Owner, Customer Service
Kristen Schau

Customer Service, Design Team Manager, Marketer

Married mom of 2 kids. I graduated with my Associates in Graphic Design in 2015. I've been with Penelope's since 2014 when we first opened.
Alayna Nail

Customer Service, Design Team Assistant Manager
Autumn Mast

Packaging Manager, Customer Service, Shipper

Shop policies

Last updated on February 16, 2023

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

More information

Last updated on Mar 14, 2023

Frequently asked questions

How "customizable" is the text?

The text is completely customizable.

Are envelopes included with the order?

Yes, the listing will state what color or you may have a choice of colors.

Will I be able to review my order before it's shipped?

Yes, we send unlimited proofs until the customer approved the design for print. An order is not printed without a customer's approval.

Custom and personalized orders

Please send us your custom details and custom requests in the "notes to seller" section at checkout, via an Etsy Message, or via e-mail to PenelopesPaperPantry@gmail.com.

Is it possible to RUSH an order?

Any request for less than the Standard 7-10 business day turnaround time may require a Rush Fee of $80 to $150 (Dependent on the complexity of the order and turnaround time requested).

Perks:
• The order is pushed to the top of our list
• We process change requests as they come in
• Our goal is to get an approval in 24-48 hours

Keep in mind:
• Rush orders need to be placed by 9am EST Mon thru Fri
• Expedited shipping is NOT a rush fee
• We are only open until 2pm on Fridays
• The designer will provide a deadline for your approval
• It's the customer's responsibility to keep up with correspondence
• The Customer must take the time to review the proof as unintentional errors are often made during "Rush" jobs.

PenelopesPaperPantry

Specializing in Custom Celebration Stationery

Featured items

Items

Romantic Beach Wedding Invitation Personalized Sunset Hearts In The Sand Destination Hawaii Shimmery Printed Invitations Envelopes Included

Romantic Beach Wedding Invitation Personalized Heart in the Sand Blue Beige Destination Tropical Hawaii Printed Invitation Envelope Included

Romantic Beach Wedding Invitation Personalized Heart in the Sand Shimmery Destination Tropical Hawaii Printed Invitation Envelope Included

Sunset Beach Wedding Invitation,Beach Wedding Invitation,Romantic,Heart in the Sand,Destination Wedding,Tropical Wedding,Envelope Included

All Items

Peter Rabbit Baby Shower Welcome Sign Personalized Foam Core Made to Match Custom Printed Sign Multiple Sizes Unique Gender Neutral Summer

Peter Rabbit Baby Shower Invitation Personalized Bunnies Greenery Blue Slate Gold Foil Printed Invitations Envelopes Included Couples Shower

Rustic Sunflower Floral Fall Wedding Invitation Personalized Gray Barn Wood Mason Jar Lights Shimmery Printed Invitations Envelopes Included

Rustic Gray Floral Fall Wedding Invitation Personalized Barn Wood Burgundy Berry Blush Roses Mason Jar Lights Shimmery Printed Invitations

Peter Rabbit Baby Shower Invitation Personalized Gender Neutral Gold Foil Sip and See Couples Baby Shower Printed Invitation With Envelopes

Welcome Sign,Baby Shower Welcome Sign,Winnie The Pooh Welcome Sign,Printed Foam Core,Multiple Sizes,Personalized Sign,Pooh Baby Shower Decor

Personalized Peter Rabbit Welcome Sign,Baby Shower Welcome Sign,Peter Rabbit Theme,Made To Match,Printed Foam Core,Multiple Sizes,Custom

Winnie The Pooh Baby Shower Invitation Personalized Gender Neutral Pooh Bear Honey Pot Bee Gold Foil Printed Invitation With Envelope Unique

Peter Rabbit Baby Shower Invitation Personalized Die Cut Gold Foil Front Print Back Print Gender Neutral Printed Invitations With Envelopes

Elegant Brunch and Bubbly Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Champagne Flute White Flowers Gold Print Shimmery Printed Envelopes

Wildflower Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Miss To Mrs Bridal Brunch Bridal Tea Brunch and Bubbly Printed Invitation Envelope Included

Honey Bee Floral Ceramic Coasters Set Of Four Summer Decor Gift For Her Mothers Day Gift Birthday Bridal Shower Unique Cork Back 4 Inch Size

Fairy Garden Ethereal Floral Butterfly Ceramic Coasters Set Of Four Summer Decor Gift For Her Mothers Day Gift Birthday Bridal Shower Unique

Elegant Pastel Floral Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Pastel Roses Bridal Brunch Shimmery Printed Invitations Envelope Included

Elegant Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized New Chapter Books Wildflowers Bridal Tea Bridal Brunch Printed Invitation With Envelope

Elegant Black and White Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Die Cut Calligraphy Classic Traditional Printed Invitations Envelopes Included

Rustic Gray Floral Summer Wedding Invitation Personalized Barn Wood Purple Lavender Lilac Fairy Lights Printed Invitation Envelopes Included

Romantic Northerns Lights Wedding Invitation Personalized Emerald Green Purple Alaska Shimmery Printed Invitations Envelopes Included Unique

Fun Dragonfly Floral Ceramic Coasters Set Of Four Summer Decor Gift For Her Mothers Day Gift Birthday Bridal Shower Unique Cork Back 4 Inch

Elegant Greenery Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Eucalyptus Vines Calligraphy Bridal Brunch Printed Invitations With Envelopes

Elegant Floral Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Blush Bridal Brunch Bridal Tea Brunch and Bubbly Printed Invitations Envelopes

Shabby Chic Floral Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Pink Rose Mason Jar Parchment Love In Bloom Printed Invitation With Envelope

Shabby Chic Floral Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Heart Blush Roses Parchment Love In Bloom Printed Invitations With Envelopes

Elegant Bow Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Aqua Bow She's Tying The Knot Bridal Brunch Miss to Mrs Printed Invitations With Envelopes

Bright Wildflower Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Bees Wildflowers Miss To Mrs Bridal Brunch Printed Invitations With Envelopes

Elegant Purple Floral Summer Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Lavender Roses Lilac Love In Bloom Printed Invitations Envelopes Included

Fun Watercolor Floral Summer Wedding Invitation Personalized Bright Floral Dusty Purple We Do Calligraphy Printed Invitations With Envelopes

Elegant Floral Summer Wedding Invitation Personalized Dusty Rose Greenery We Do Calligraphy Printed Invitations Envelopes Included Romantic

Elegant Floral Summer Wedding Invitation Personalized Blush Dusty Blue Roses We Do Calligraphy Shimmery Printed Invitation Envelope Included

Elegant Bow Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Aqua White Bow White Roses She's Tying The Knot Shimmery Printed Invitation With Envelope

Elegant Bow Bridal Shower Invitation Personalized Pink Glitter Print Bow Navy She's Tying The Knot Shimmery Printed Invitation With Envelope

Hummingbird Floral Ceramic Coasters Set Of Four Summer Decor Gift For Her Mothers Day Gift Birthday Bridal Shower Unique Cork Back 4 Inch

Shabby Chic Floral Garden Pots Ceramic Coasters Set Of Four Summer Decor Gift For Her Mothers Day Gift Unique Cork Back 4 Inch Tile Birthday

Unique Graduation Announcement Photo Invitation Personalized Party Invitation Class of 2025 Die Cut Printed Cards Free Envelope Addressing

Gold Floral Graduation Party Invitation Announcement Personalized Class of 2025 Gold Foil Printed Invitation Free Envelope Address Printing

Unique Floral Circle Graduation Party Invitation Announcement Personalized Class of 2025 Die Cut Printed Card Free Envelope Address Printing