Handmade Felt Saint Softies - Pictured in the NY Times

Kansas City, Missouri · 9990 Sales


Handmade Felt Saint Softies - Pictured in the NY Times

Kansas City, Missouri 9990 Sales On Etsy since 2007

5 out of 5 stars

Announcement   QUICK SHIPS ship next business day!!! If you are looking for a Saint that is not currently on my shop please etsy convo me and I will list it for you. :)


Last updated on Jan 17, 2018

QUICK SHIPS ship next business day!!! If you are looking for a Saint that is not currently on my shop please etsy convo me and I will list it for you. :)

Saintly Silver, Founder

Contact shop owner

Saintly Silver, Founder

View all 174 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
View all 2814 reviews


Once upon a time...

There was this woman, with a love of the Saints and gifted by Our Lord in sewing and all things creative. She was blessed by God, with the idea of creating these Saints she so loved in a form she could sew and made of felt. These felt Saints were something more palpable, and soft for wee hands, and gentle enough to to be comforted with in slumber. She diligently made these lovable Saints with the desire to teach their stories to all of those who would listen. She knew that many loved the Saints, but even more could grow to love them in this new form and most especially when they learned the stories of their lives. Her desire to bring to creation even the obscure Saints that have not even been pictured in books or statues she knew would aide in the belief of their heroic holiness and a willingness to ask for their intercession. Aided by her patroness St. Anne, and the patroness of her shop St. Rose of Lima she continues to this day to propagate the Faith, and share the virtues of these holy heroes and role models in creation of the Saintly Silver Felt Saint Softies.

Shop members

  • erin

    Owner, Founder

    Erin is an active member of a Latin Mass Community in the Kansas City area. She has been married for over 25 years, has 5 children here to raise, one in heaven, and one grandchild. She is a self-taught artist who loves the Saints.

Shop policies

Last updated on August 11, 2016
Welcome to Saintly Silver!
Home of the original Felt Saint Softie, and pictured in the New York Times! We've been making Felt Saints for over 9 years on etsy. Started by our Founder, Erin, we are now a team of caring artists, with a desire to make quality products that encourage the Faith.

We live in a world where everything is made by machine and processed in an assembly line fashion.  Machines have provided the ability to produce items faster and make larger profits for companies. However, not enough attention is paid to detail, quality, or the individuals that work in these places.

We chose to do something better. We do not focus on the amount of money we can make, but on how many lives we can impact.

We want something bigger than us. We want to use our God given talents to create a Saint Softie that not only rewards our team of artists, but our family of customers.  We want to provide a product with high quality craftsmanship as well as Faith inspiration.

Our designs are always made with quality materials. We use wool blended felt and polyfill made in the USA, embroidery floss made in France, and thread made in Germany.

There are no assembly lines here, just a team of warmhearted artists striving for excellence in a caring work environment. It is hard to believe, but true; we choose not to make decisions off of dollar signs, but spiritual rewards.

We pray together, create together, and ask for blessings from God for all of you.

Accepted payment methods

  • Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
We are happy you chose to shop with us, and YOU should be happy you chose to shop with us. We most kindly take returns of new items within 30 days of purchase.
Payment can be made through Paypal or USPS money order.

Cancellation of orders that have not requested customization can be done via etsy convo. Just send us an etsy convo and we'll take care of cancelling your order and refunding your Paypal straight away. :)
If this is your first purchase with our shop here’s some information on the shipping process. Every listing (unless stated in the listing title, QUICK SHIP) on etsy is for an item that will be made after purchasing. We keep an order queue for all orders. This process can take up to 3 weeks depending on how many orders are in our order queue. Once your order is processed we can give you an approximate ship time (when your order will go to the post and begin its journey to you). If you would like to know that time frame please send us an etsy convo and we’d be happy to provide you with that time line. No problem! We will also send you an etsy convo when your order ships so you will know it has left our location and it’s on its way to you.

Please note that our items are handmade with care, and this does take time. No die cutters, or assembly line processes here! We are artists that take care in each step of construction. This process can take up to 3 weeks depending on how many orders are in our order queue. During busy seasons, i.e. Christmas, Easter, First Communion and Confirmation our order queue is very full! To ensure your item gets to you in the time line needed please order early.

Your order is insured for $100.00 and is shipped USPS Priority Mail. This is a 1-3 day service. Etsy will have the tracking number on your order so you can stay up to date on your orders mailing progress. If you would like more than $100.00 Insurance coverage on your order please contact us via etsy convo and we can add additional insurance to your order for an additional fee. Please note that this is an additional charge to the shipping cost already paid for with your order. Once your order has left our care, Saintly Silver is not responsible for lost, damaged or stolen packages.

Your order will be shipping by next business day, via USPS Priority Mail which is a 1-3 day service. Your order is insured for $100.00. If you would like more than $100.00 Insurance coverage on your order please contact us via etsy convo and we can add additional insurance to your order for an additional fee. Please note that this is an additional charge to the shipping cost already paid for with your order. Once your order has left our care, Saintly Silver is not responsible for lost, damaged or stolen packages.


Please use etsy convo's. It really is the most efficient way to reach us. We use email only for paypal and not for customer contact. We wouldn't want to miss a really important message from you about your order! Thanks! :)
Additional policies and FAQs
Current listing of available Saintly Silver Felt Saint Softies & Softies:

St. Abigail
St. Abraham
St. Adelaide
St. Adelina
St. Adeline
St. Agatha
St. Aidan of Lindisfarne
St. Agnes
St. Agostina Patrantoni "Livia"
St. Albert
St. Aldegundis
St. Alena
St. Alexander of Comana
St. Alexandra of Amisus
St. Alice
St. Alphonsus Ligouri
St. Alyssa
St. Ambrose
St. Amelia
St. Anastasia
St. Andre Bessette
St. Andrew
Bl. Anna Maria Taigi
St. Anne
St. Ansgar
St. Anthony of Padua
St. Apollonia
St. Athanasius
St. Aubrey of Citeaux ( St. Alberic)
St. Audrey (St. Etheldreda)
St. Augustine
St. Augustine of Canterbury
St. Aurelia
St. Barbara
St. Barnabas
St. Basiliscus (Bishop of Comana)
St. Beatrice
St. Benedetta
St. Benjamin
St. Bernadette Soubirous
St. Bernadette Soubirous (Peasant depiction)
St. Bernard of Clairvaux
St. Blaise
St. Bonaventure
St. Boniface
St. Brendan
St. Bridget of Sweden
St. Brigid of Ireland
Bl. Bronislava
St. Caleb
Our Lady of Mount Carmel
St. Carmen Salles
St. Caroline
St. Catherine of Alexandria
St. Catherine of Bologna
St. Catherine of Laboure
St. Catherine McAuley
St. Catherine of Siena
St. Cecilia
St. Charles Borromeo
Bl. Chiara "Luce" Badano
St. Christian
St. Christina
St. Christopher
St. Clare of Assisi
St. Clare of Montefalco
St. Clement (Pope Clement the I)
St. Colette
St. Columba of Iona
Bl. Conor O'Devaney
St. Conrad of Parzham
St. Constance
Little Crown of the Blessed Virgin
St. Cyprian
St. Cyril
Our Lady of Czestochowa
St. Damian (brother of St. Cosmas)
St. Damien of Molokai
St. Daniel the Prophet
St. David of Wales
St. David the King
St. David of Thessaloniki
St. Declan
St. Dennis
St. Dismas
Divino Nino - Divine Infant
Divine Mercy Jesus
St. Dominic
St. Dominic Savio
St. Dorothy
St. Dymphna
St. Edward
St. Eligius
St. Elijah
St. Elizabeth
St. Elizabeth Ann Seton
St. Elizabeth of Constantinople
St. Elizabeth of Hungary
St. Elizabeth of Portugal
Bl. Elizabeth of the Trinity
St. Emily
St. Emma
V. Father Englemar Unzeitig
St. Estelle
St. Etheldreda (St. Audrey)
St. Eugene of Mazenod
Bl. Eva of Liege
St. Ezekiel the Prophet
Our Lady of Fatima
St. Faustina
St. Felicissima
St. Felicity
St. Fernando III (King of Castille)
St. Finnian of Clonard
First Communion Boy
First Communion Girl
Flame of Love Immaculate Heart of Mary
St. Florian
St. Frances of Rome
St. Frances Xavier Cabrini
St. Francis of Assisi
St. Francis de Sales
St. Francis Xavier
Bl. Francis Xavier Seelos
Bl. Francisco Marto
V. Fulton Sheen
St. Gabriel
St. Gemma Galgani
St. Genevieve
St. Gennaro of Naples
St. George
St. Georgia
St. Gerard Majella
St. Germaine Cousin
St. Gianna Beretta Molla
St. Giles
Our Lady of Good Remedy
Good Shepherd Jesus
Our Lady of Grace (OLM)
St. Gregory
St. Gregory the Great
Our Lady of Guadalupe
Guardian Angel Boy
Guardian Angel Girl
St. Gwenn
St. Hallvard
St. Hannah
St. Helena of the True Cross
St. Henry
St. Hildegard of Bingen
Holy Family
St. Honore (St. Honoratus)
St. Hope
Our Lady of Hope
St. Hugh of Lincoln
St. Ignatius of Loyola
Immaculate Heart of Mary
Infant Jesus of Prague
St. Irene of Chrysovalantou
St. Irene of Thessalonica
St. Isaac Jogues
St. Isaac Jogunes (alternate design)
St. Isabella of Portugal
St. Isabelle of France
St. Isaiah (Prophet)
St. Isidore the Farmer
Bl. Jacinta of Fatima
Jacob's Ladder
Jacob the Patriarch
St. James (the Greater)
St. Jane Frances of Chantel
St. Jerome
St. Joan of Arc
Bl. John the XXIII of Rome
St. John the Apostle
St. John the Baptist
St. John Berchmans
St. John Bosco
St. John of Capistrano
St. John the Evangelist
St. John Gabriel Perboye
St. John of Nepomuk
St. John Neuman
Bl. John Henry Newman
St. John Paul II
St. John Vianney
St. John the Wonderworker
St. Jose Maria Escriva
St. Joseph
St. Joseph the Worker
St. Joseph of Arimathea
St. Joseph the Patriarch
St. Josephine Bakhita
King Josiah
St. Juan Diego
St. Jude
St. Julia
St. Julia Maria Ledochowska
St. Juliana Falconieri
St. Julitta
St. Junipero Serra
St. Junipero Serra (alternate version)
St. Justina
Bl. Karolina Kozkowna
St. Kateri Tekakwitha
St. Katharine Drexel
Our Lady of Kibeho
St. Kieran the Elder
St. Kieran the Younger
St. Kilian (St. Cillian)
Our Lady of Knock
St. Laura of Cordoba
St. Lawrence
St. Lea
St. Leo
St. Lillian
St. Livia
St. Lorenzo Ruiz
St. Louis de Montfort
St. Louise de Marillac
Our Lady of Lourdes
St. Love
St. Lucy (w/candles)
St. Lucy (w/cup)
St. Luke
St. Lydia
St. Madeleine Sophie Barat
Madonna and Child
St. Malachi the Prophet
St. Margaret of Antioch
Bl. Margaret of Castello
St. Margaret of Hungary
St. Margaret of Scotland
St. Margaret Mary
St. Margaret Mary Alacoque
St. Maguerite d'Youville
Bl. Maria Anna Blondin ( Esther Blondin)
Bl. Maria Gabriella
St. Maria Goretti
St. Maria Rosa Mystica
St. Maria Won Kwi-Im
St. Marianne Cope
Bl. Maris Stella of the Most Blessed Sacrament
Maris Stella (Our Lady Star of the Sea)
St. Mark
St. Martin de Porres
St. Martin de Tours
Mary Undoer of Knots
St. Mary Mackillop
St. Mary Magdalen
St. Matthias the Apostle
St. Matthias (alternate version)
St. Matilda
St. Matthew
St. Maura
St. Maurice
St. Maximilian Kolbe
St. Megan (St. Margaret Ward)
St. Meinrad of Einsiedeln
St. Melania
Our Lady of Mercy (Ransom)
St. Methodius
St. Michael the Archangel
St. Michael of the Saints
Bl. Miguel Agustin Pro
St. Miles Gerard
Bl. Milo of Selincourt
Our Lady of Miracles
St. Miriam
St. Monica
St. Monica (alternate design)
St. Natalie
St. Nathanael (St. Bartholomew)
St. Nathaniel (alternate design)
Angel of the Nativity
Jesus of the Nativity
Mary of the Nativity
St. Joseph of the Nativity
Shepherd of the Nativity
St. Balthazar Magi of the Nativity
St. Caspar Magi of the Nativity
St. Melchoir Magi of the Nativity
St. Nektarios
St. Nicholas
St. Nicholas Owen
St. Nicholas of Tolentino
St. Non
St. Odilia
St. Olav
St. Oliver Plunkett
St. Olivia
Bl. Oscar Romero
St. Owen of Lichfield
St. Padre Pio
St. Paola Elisabetta Cerioli
St. Pascal Baylon
St. Patricia of Naples
St. Patrick
St. Paul
St. Peregrine
St. Perpetua
Our Lady of Perpetual Help
St. Peregrine
St. Peter
St. Peter Claver
St. Peter Damian
St. Petka of Serbia
Bl. Pier Giorgio Frasatti
St. Philip the Apostle
St. Philip Neri
St. Philomena
St. Polycarp
Pope Benedict XVI
Pope Francis
Our Lady Queen of Peace
St. Rachel the Matriarch
St. Radegunde
St. Raphael the Archangel
St. Raymond Nonnatus
St. Rebecca
St. Remigius
St. Rita of Cascia
St. Robert Bellarmine
St. Robert Southwell
St. Rocco
St. Rolland
St. Ronan of Locronan
St. Rose of Lima
St. Rose Philippine Duchesne
St. Rose of Sardinia
St. Rose Venerini
St. Ruth the Matriarch
Sacred Heart of Jesus
St. Samantha
St. Samuel the Patriarch
Santo Nino de Cebu
St. Sarah the Matriarch
St. Scholastica
St. Sebastian
St. Sebastian (alternate version)
St. Silvia
St. Simeon the God-receiver
St. Simon Stock
V. Solonus Casey
St. Sophia
Our Lady of Sorrows
Fr. Stanley Rother
St. Stanislaus of Cracow
St. Stephen the Martyr
St. Symeon of Emesa
St. Sunniva
St. Susanna
St. Tarcisius
St. Teresa of Avila
St. Teresa Benedicta of the Cross
Bl. Teresa of Calcutta (Mother Teresa)
Mother Teresa
St. Theodore Guerin
St. Theodore Stratelates
St. Theodore of Sykeon
St. Theopan the Recluse
Bl. Theresa of Jesus Gerhardinger
St. Therese of Lisieux
St. Thomas
St. Thomas the Apostle
St. Thomas Aquinas
St. Thomas Becket
St. Thomas More
St. Timothy
St. Ursula
St. Valentine
St. Veronica
St. Victoria
St. Vincent de Paul
St. Vivian
Our Lady of Walsingham
St. William of York
St. Winifred
St. Winifred (alternated design)
Our Lady Seat of Wisdom
St. Zachary
St. Zelie Martin
St. Zita
St. Zita (alternate design)

If the saint is on this list and not on our shop more than likely someone has purchased it, and it hasn't been relisted on our shop yet. Just send us an etsy convo and we will have a listing up for you right away. :)

Don't see the saint you are looking for??? No problem, you can purchase the Custom Saint listing and just note the Saint you would like us to make for you. Custom Saints can be purchased with the listing "Custom Felt Saint Softie".

New to Catholicism or non-Catholic and buying a gift for a Catholic???

LOOKING FOR A SAINT WITH A CERTAIN NAME??? Alphabetical listing here..