Vintage and Handmade Seamlessly Blended

Top shop for gifts.

A buyer bought a gift from this shop and gave it a 5-star review!

Announcement    Check the $5 add on section for deep discounts and free shipping on some fun things to add to your regularly priced purchase.


Last updated on Mar 30, 2022

Check the $5 add on section for deep discounts and free shipping on some fun things to add to your regularly priced purchase.


Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language


All Items

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Sarah Dennis

Contact shop owner

Sarah Dennis


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:

About GardenWitchVintage

Sales 395
On Etsy since 2014

Come with us on a "Sale-ing Trip"!

We currently live in Fort Worth, Texas, but consider ourselves from all over. We love to search through other people's old stuff, and we love to share what we find. :)

We enjoy items that are timeless, sentimental, and of course pretty; that evoke an emotion every time you use or look at them. But we also believe that what we put in our space should be purposeful. Does the item look beautiful and function well? Does it have more than one purpose? These are questions we ask ourselves as we look for things to put in our home, and things you should ask yourself as well.

Think: How does this make me feel? Where would I put it? How can I use it? What will my friends think when they see it? Don't say, "I don't care what other people think!" Remember the last time you received a compliment on your good taste? It felt wonderful, didn't it? That affirmation plays a part, however small, in how we furnish our homes and our lives. And it's important too, because it sparks conversations and discussions on tastes, feelings, and convictions. And if you've never experienced the joy of having your excellent choices admired, you've come to the right place! We don't sell anything we aren't sad to let go. Everything has been photographed in our home, and we think it looks lovely there. It's just not big enough to hold all of these treasures!

We have added some handmade items to our shop! Some of the items are upcycled from estate sale finds, and many are created by Sarah. Vintage inspired stationary with a modern twist, upcycled clothing, and hand embroidery are some of the things you'll find tucked in the categories with vintage items.

We hope you enjoy what you see, and happy living!

Explore what a day in our shop is like through our pictures, and then come on in and see what's for sale! Please ask any questions you have, we want to help you find the perfect thing. :)

Shop members

  • Sarah Dennis

    Owner, Curator, Photographer

    I love looking, photographing, and describing my items. Finding these treasures and enjoying them until they find the perfect home is my thrill. I also make the handmade items in the shop!

Shop policies

Last updated on May 9, 2022
Hi there, I am so glad you stopped by! Repurposing vintage items is a passion of mine, and I feel so lucky to be able to share that with you. Please take a look around, and ask questions! I do not list anything we do not love having in our home, and we definitely love it for the short time we have it. I am always sorry to see things go, but it's fun to feel like I'm redecorating every time I have a purchase or go to a new estate sale!

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.


Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 24 hours of purchase


I accept paypal and direct checkout. Use whatever is easier for you! I am always quick to communicate, and if there's a problem on my end, I'll let you know so we can get it resolved right away.


I have made the decision to charge for shipping. All sellers do, but some put the cost of shipping into the item. That is fine but I prefer to keep them separate for the sake of transparency. On most items I have Etsy calculate the cost of shipping so there are no overages. However shipping costs vary a lot depending on the size of the box I end up using. If I am able to get your item safely packed in a smaller box I will happily refund you the difference. I do not make a profit on shipping. In fact just the opposite. Until changing my shop policies I was losing a lot of money on shipping.

I also charge a handling fee of 1.50 per item. This helps me pay for packaging materials which I use A LOT of to keep your items safe, and always reuse materials when possible, which is why your item may come packaged in materials from multiple other stores or locations. : ) It can take HOURS to get a week's order's all packaged up safely, so the handling fee also goes toward offsetting the cost of the time that takes.

I ship via USPS so that I can charge you the lowest price on shipping. Even then please note that to ship an item that weighs less than one pound ranges from about $6 to $10 depending on the weight and where you live in relation to me. If that seems like a lot to you, believe me, it's a lot to me too!

Additionally, sometimes the post office has a weather delay, or even damages or loses and item. I have learned the hard way that I cannot predict or take responsibility for post office issues. When you receive a shipping notification that means I have printed a label and dropped it off; however sometimes the post office does not scan it in until the next day or in rare cases several days later. I cannot guarantee anything after the drop off. If you need an item by a specific time please either purchase far enough ahead to plan for any delays or purchase expedited shipping (though this is also not a guarantee).

Unfortunately, if you provide the wrong address I cannot reship items that are returned or lost without another payment. I run a small business and that would really add up quickly.

At this time I do not ship internationally.

USPS requires insurance on items over $100 dollars, and in that event, you will be asked to pay for the insurance, which is usually around $4.00 for anything valued over $50. The great thing about this is that if something happens to your package you can be reimbursed!

Additional policies and FAQs

Non smoking home BUT we do have a dog. She does not smoke either, or help package or play with items. However she does stalk me in my office and a hair or two may slip past my notice.