Handcrafted, one of a kind, jewelry made with love.

Annapolis, Maryland · 2453 Sales


Handcrafted, one of a kind, jewelry made with love.

Annapolis, Maryland 2453 Sales On Etsy since 2010

5 out of 5 stars
Bethany Stoltzfus

Contact shop owner

Bethany Stoltzfus


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
View all 1144 reviews


Hi! Im Beth! I am the one woman show that designs, creates, photographs, packages, and ships each and every piece from my small home studio in Maryland. I have background in both graphic design and culinary arts. I love adventures, tacos, houseplants (really all plants), enthusiastic people, and mint tea. When Im not working Im usually hanging with my kiddo and our French Bulldog, Gummy Bear.

Ive always been super artsy fartsy; I have painted, drawn, and sculpted most of my life. It wasn't until 2015 that I decided to give silversmithing a try. I first picked up a torch to attempt to fix a broken cuff I loved. It was love at first solder. I found some tutorials online and slowly taught myself the craft. Named after my daughter, who was 3 at the time, Numi Olive has slowly grown into something I could have never imagined. I feel absolutely blessed to be able to do something that I love so much!

My designs are stone focused with bohemian vibes and traditional elements inspired by the techniques of the American southwest. I love clean, bold designs that are fun and easy to wear.

I update the shop weekly. Follow me on Instagram @numiolive to stay up to date with update info and lots of previews and general insight into my work.

Thank you so much for the love and support!

Around the web

Shop members

  • Bethany Stoltzfus

    Owner, Creator, Designer

  • Numi

    Stamper Of Boxes, Hand Polisher Extraordinaire

  • Gummy Bear


Shop policies

Last updated on July 10, 2018
Hi! Welcome to my shop! I use traditional techniques to create one of a kind pieces that are meant to be cherished for years to come. I put hours of work into the design and construction of each piece! Oh, and lots and lots of love!

Accepted payment methods

  • Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept returns and exchanges
Contact me within: 3 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 7 days of delivery
I don't accept cancellations
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
The following items can't be returned or exchanged
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:
  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Items on sale
Refunds and exchanges are handled on a case-by-case basis. If you are dissatisfied, please contact me as soon as possible and we can discuss the best option. I do not accept returns or exchanges based on wrong size- please know your ring size before ordering (check out ) and read product descriptions carefully, but i am also more than happy to work through a solution. I only want satisfied customers!
Paypal, Direct Checkout and Etsy Gift Cards are accepted for purchase. Items are shipped once payment has been cleared.
I ship out all items as fast as i can- usually 2-3 days, sometimes less. All US orders are shipped USPS first class mail with insurance.
All orders will be shipped to the address listed on the Etsy invoice. Please make sure that this address is correct prior to purchasing.

I cannot be held liable for incorrect shipping addresses or uninsured items lost or stolen during shipping. Any issues with missing packages but tracking says delivered must be addressed with USPS.
If an insurance claim is the way that we have to go I will do my part and issue the full refund when the claim goes through.

International orders are shipped via USPS First Class International Mail ( 8-21 business days). If you are not in the US, please know your country's import policies and customs fees, as you are responsible for paying these.

Please allow 1-3 business days to ship your order after the payment has been cleared (made to order and custom pieces take a bit longer). Orders are shipped Monday-Friday. Once the item is shipped, you should receive it in 5-7 business days (US).
Additional policies and FAQs
While I strive to only use the highest quality materials, please understand that how you care for your jewelry will greatly increase its longevity. Please understand that some stones, more than others, are breakable. There are many factors that go into this, and I do what i can to make your jewelry as durable as possible. Please know that damage may occur to the stone is mishandled, or if suffers any trauma- is dropped, bumped, etc. Please remove your jewelry before bathing/showering, swimming, washing your hands, etc. Large stones can be especially susceptible to damage from bumping or mis handling. I do all i can in the design and construction to make the stone as safe and secure as possible, but proper care and respect on your end will ensure it will last.

Sterling silver is a metal that will tarnish. Proper care and storage can fix and prevent tarnish. Sterling silver will show signs of wear over time. This can be corrected by polishing. Sunshine polishing cloths are really great to give your piece a quick polish- Now available for purchase in the shop!

I also off free polishing/ re-oxidizing (darkening) of any of my pieces free of charge! Just pay shipping to and from and I'll have your piece shining like new!

If you have any questions about this please don't hesitate to reach out before or after your purchase!

All my packages are shipped and packaged with care. I box my items with packaging that is great for gifting. If you are sending as a gift directly I will be more than happy to add a note or card with the order and address everything directly to the recipient!

Many rings can be sized up (not down) easily. Please reach out for any questions regarding this. Traditional cuffs and stamped cuffs can easily be shortened if needed- please don't hesitate to ask if this is needed.
If you have already received the item and realize that you would like it adjusted in size (if doable) I will gladly do so- at no cost to you. I will just ask that you cover all shipping costs.
If you have any questions at all please don't hesitate to shoot me a message!

Layaway is not offered at this time.

I will reserve an item after it has been listed for at least 24 hrs. Please contact me about details on this.