Chocolate Covered Oreos and Prezels For Your Party!

Carlstadt, New Jersey
3,164 Sales

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

Sweettoothsweetie is taking a short break


Note from shop owner NOT TO WORRY! Just taking some time to catch up on my reserved orders! I will, however, answer any and all emails in the meantime, usually within 12 hours. THANKS!

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Aug 4, 2022

NOT TO WORRY! Just taking some time to catch up on my reserved orders! I will, however, answer any and all emails in the meantime, usually within 12 hours. THANKS!


Contact shop owner



No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:

About Sweettoothsweetie

Sales 3,164
On Etsy since 2009

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Chocolate! Need I Say More?

What can I say? Some babies are born with a silver spoon in their mouths... I was born with a sweet tooth!

I am honored to be a part of my customer's fun celebrations, whether it's for a wedding, baby shower, baptism, christening, 50th birthday, 40th birthday, 30th birthday, sweet 16 or baby's 1st birthday!

I absolutely love doing what I do!

Shop members

  • Janelle

    Owner, Maker, Chocolate Junkie

Shop policies

Last updated on May 10, 2022
Chocolate! Need I say more?

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I do not offer refunds on food items. However, if a mistake was made on my behalf due to an incorrect order or shipping date, I will certainly offer a full refund!
Sweettoothsweetie accepts credit cards through PayPal as well as direct checkout.

I ship priority mail with tracking from the U.S. Parcel service 6 days a week. A tracking # will be sent as soon as your order ships.

Priority shipping normally takes 2-3 days, however, this is not guaranteed! EXPRESS shipping is guaranteed to arrive in 1-2 days. Contact me if you would like this option and I will quote a shipping price.

I strongly recommend that someone is available to accept the package as soon as it is delivered so that it does not hang out on the porch! I can not be responsible for theft or melting if left to sit outside!

Please note that I am not responsible for delays in shipping due to the USPS issues, such as severe weather etc. (So far, I have never had a problem with the USPS and a late delivery!)
Additional policies and FAQs
Customer service is my top priority!! I will answer any and all questions or concerns within 12 hours. In most cases, much sooner!

I tend to book up very quickly, so I recommend placing an order as soon as possible to reserve your date.

Sometimes, I am able to make and ship an order at the last minute. PLEASE message me to see if this is possible! I DO NOT charge an extra fee for rush orders.

Keep in mind, all orders are made fresh and packaged with tender loving care! (Please feel free to read my reviews) I guarantee your order will arrive safe and sound, not a single broken cookie!!

I know how tempting it may be to sneak a treat or two before your event, so I ALWAYS include a few extras for "taste testing." No one will ever know!

As always, if you are sending any of my treats as a gift, I will include a personalized greeting card for FREE! Let me know the details you would like said in the card when checking out.

* * * If you have your own personalized tags or ribbons, I will be happy to tie them on the favors at NO additional charge! * * *